EN FR
EN FR

2025​​​‌Activity reportProject-TeamMUSCLEES‌

RNSR: 202424539Y
  • Research center‌​‌ Inria Paris Centre at​​ Sorbonne University
  • In partnership​​​‌ with:CNRS, Sorbonne Université‌
  • Team name: Mathematical Understanding‌​‌ across Scales of Complex​​ Living Ecosystems with Emerging​​​‌ Structures
  • In collaboration with:‌Laboratoire Jacques-Louis Lions (LJLL)‌​‌

Creation of the Project-Team:​​ 2024 June 01

Each​​​‌ year, Inria research teams‌ publish an Activity Report‌​‌ presenting their work and​​ results over the reporting​​​‌ period. These reports follow‌ a common structure, with‌​‌ some optional sections depending​​ on the specific team.​​​‌ They typically begin by‌ outlining the overall objectives‌​‌ and research programme, including​​ the main research themes,​​​‌ goals, and methodological approaches.‌ They also describe the‌​‌ application domains targeted by​​ the team, highlighting the​​​‌ scientific or societal contexts‌ in which their work‌​‌ is situated.

The reports​​ then present the highlights​​​‌ of the year, covering‌ major scientific achievements, software‌​‌ developments, or teaching contributions.​​ When relevant, they include​​​‌ sections on software, platforms,‌ and open data, detailing‌​‌ the tools developed and​​ how they are shared.​​​‌ A substantial part is‌ dedicated to new results,‌​‌ where scientific contributions are​​ described in detail, often​​​‌ with subsections specifying participants‌ and associated keywords.

Finally,‌​‌ the Activity Report addresses​​ funding, contracts, partnerships, and​​​‌ collaborations at various levels,‌ from industrial agreements to‌​‌ international cooperations. It also​​ covers dissemination and teaching​​​‌ activities, such as participation‌ in scientific events, outreach,‌​‌ and supervision. The document​​ concludes with a presentation​​​‌ of scientific production, including‌ major publications and those‌​‌ produced during the year.​​

Keywords

Computer Science and​​​‌ Digital Science

  • A3. Data‌ and knowledge
  • A3.1. Data‌​‌
  • A3.1.1. Modeling, representation
  • A3.4.​​ Machine learning and statistics​​​‌
  • A6. Modeling, simulation and‌ control
  • A6.1. Methods in‌​‌ mathematical modeling
  • A6.1.1. Continuous​​ Modeling (PDE, ODE)
  • A6.1.2.​​​‌ Stochastic Modeling
  • A6.1.3. Discrete‌ Modeling (multi-agent, people centered)‌​‌
  • A6.1.4. Multiscale modeling
  • A6.1.5.​​ Multiphysics modeling
  • A6.2. Scientific​​​‌ computing, Numerical Analysis &‌ Optimization
  • A6.2.1. Numerical analysis‌​‌ of PDE and ODE​​
  • A6.2.2. Numerical probability
  • A6.2.3.​​​‌ Probabilistic methods
  • A6.2.4. Statistical‌ methods
  • A6.2.6. Optimization
  • A6.3.‌​‌ Computation-data interaction
  • A6.3.1. Inverse​​ problems
  • A6.3.2. Data assimilation​​​‌
  • A6.4. Automatic control
  • A6.4.1.‌ Deterministic control
  • A6.4.4. Stability‌​‌ and Stabilization
  • A6.4.6. Optimal​​ control
  • A9.2.6. Neural networks​​​‌
  • A9.2.7. Kernel methods

Other‌ Research Topics and Application‌​‌ Domains

  • B1.1.2. Molecular and​​ cellular biology
  • B1.1.5. Immunology​​​‌
  • B1.1.6. Evolutionnary biology
  • B1.1.7.‌ Bioinformatics
  • B1.1.8. Mathematical biology‌​‌
  • B1.2. Neuroscience and cognitive​​ science
  • B2. Digital health​​​‌
  • B2.2. Physiology and diseases‌
  • B2.2.3. Cancer
  • B2.2.4. Infectious‌​‌ diseases, Virology
  • B2.2.6. Neurodegenerative​​ diseases
  • B2.3. Epidemiology
  • B2.4.​​​‌ Therapies
  • B2.4.1. Pharmaco kinetics‌ and dynamics
  • B2.4.2. Drug‌​‌ resistance
  • B2.6.3. Biological Imaging​​
  • B9.6.4. Management science

1​​​‌ Team members, visitors, external‌ collaborators

Research Scientists

  • Pierre-Alexandre‌​‌ Bliman [Team leader​​, INRIA, Senior​​​‌ Researcher, HDR]‌
  • Luca Alasio [INRIA‌​‌, Researcher]
  • Jean​​ Clairambault [Inria,​​​‌ Emeritus, HDR]‌
  • Sophie Hecht [CNRS‌​‌, Researcher]
  • Diane​​ Peurichard [INRIA,​​​‌ Researcher]
  • Nastassia Pouradier‌ Duteil [Inria]‌​‌
  • Philippe Robert [Inria​​​‌, Emeritus, from​ Jul 2025, HDR​‌]
  • Philippe Robert [​​INRIA, Senior Researcher​​​‌, until Jul 2025​, HDR]

Faculty​‌ Members

  • Bernard Cazelles [​​SORBONNE UNIVERSITE, Professor​​​‌ Delegation, HDR]​
  • Benoît Perthame [Sorbonne​‌ Université, Emeritus,​​ HDR]
  • Teresa Taing​​​‌ [UNIV POITIERS,​ Associate Professor Delegation,​‌ from Sep 2025]​​

Post-Doctoral Fellows

  • Hiroshi Horii​​​‌ [Inria, until​ Sep 2025]
  • Suney​‌ Toste Regalado [INRIA​​, Post-Doctoral Fellow,​​​‌ until Mar 2025]​

PhD Students

  • Naoufel Cresson​‌ [INRIA]
  • Manon​​ De La Tousche [​​​‌SORBONNE UNIVERSITE]
  • Morgane​ Doukhan [SORBONNE UNIVERSITE​‌, from Sep 2025​​]
  • Marcel Fang [​​​‌Inria, until Apr​ 2025]
  • Sam Gaborieau​‌ [Sorbonne Université]​​
  • Pierre-Alexandre Grott [Université​​​‌ de Toulouse, from​ Sep 2025, ED​‌ BSB - Toulouse, co-supervised​​ by J. Paupert and​​​‌ D. Peurichard]
  • Angelina​ Jammart [INRIA,​‌ from Oct 2025]​​
  • Nicolas Martinez Tomas [​​​‌FSMP, from Oct​ 2025]
  • Lia Sela​‌ [Sorbonne Université,​​ from Sep 2025]​​​‌

Interns and Apprentices

  • Morgane​ Doukhan [INRIA,​‌ Intern, from Apr​​ 2025 until Aug 2025​​​‌]

Administrative Assistant

  • Meriem​ Guemair [INRIA]​‌

External Collaborators

  • Clara Choukroun​​ [SORBONNE UNIVERSITE,​​​‌ from Dec 2025]​
  • Marcel Fang [Inria​‌, from Apr 2025​​]

2 Overall objectives​​​‌

Figure 1

Diagram describing connections between​ activities involving microscopic and​‌ macroscopic models, as well​​ as stochastic and deterministic​​​‌ ones.

Figure 1:​ Scheme of the team​‌ activities

MUSCLEES is the​​ evolution of the MAMBA​​​‌ Inria project-team, headed by​ Marie Doumic (now head​‌ of the Inria project-team​​ MERGE in Saclay) during​​​‌ 9 years (2014-2022); which​ was in turn a​‌ continuation of the BANG​​ Inria project-team, headed by​​​‌ Benoît Perthame during 11​ years (2003-2013). Just as​‌ its scientific ascendants, this​​ new project-team aims at​​​‌ developing, analyzing, controlling, observing,​ identifying and simulating models​‌ involving dynamics of phenomena​​ encountered in various biological​​​‌ systems.

The nature of​ the corresponding populations involved​‌ is very diverse, as​​ well as the nature​​​‌ of the interactions between​ their members. They may​‌ contain chemical species, cells,​​ molecules, neurons, bacteria, (human​​​‌ or animal) individuals. We​ are interested for example​‌ in cell motion, (physiological​​ or tumor) cell development,​​​‌ binding/unbinding of macro-molecules, bacteria​ micro-colony growth, tissue development,​‌ repair, ageing and degeneration,​​ epidemic spread, vector control,​​​‌ together with methodological questions​ related to these aspects.​‌

In accordance with the​​ context, we will use​​​‌ stochastic or deterministic models,​ systems of ordinary (possibly​‌ defined on graphs) or​​ partial differential equations, and​​​‌ agent-based approaches. We will​ also consider the link​‌ between models of different​​ types, exploring the behavior​​​‌ across different scales, and​ will appeal to tools​‌ from control theory to​​ treat issues of (optimal​​​‌ or non-optimal) control, state​ observation or parametric identification.​‌

In Fig. 1,​​ we give an overview​​​‌ of the different research​ axes of the MUSCLEES​‌ team. The horizontal axis​​ distinguishes schematically between the​​ stochastic and deterministic descriptions,​​​‌ while the vertical axis‌ indicates the description scale.‌​‌ At the heart of​​ our research lie the​​​‌ different applications that drive‌ our mathematical studies: living‌​‌ tissues/cell populations, reaction networks​​ and epidemiology (in green​​​‌ in Fig. 1).‌ All our efforts, even‌​‌ the most theoretical ones,​​ will be motivated by​​​‌ biological questions/challenges with applications‌ in these different fields.‌​‌ The MUSCLEES team proposes​​ to tackle these challenges​​​‌ from different and complementary‌ angles, attempting to provide‌​‌ generalizations and unified points​​ of view in the​​​‌ study of biological systems:‌ Axis 2 (in dark‌​‌ red in Fig. 1​​) is devoted to​​​‌ the understanding of the‌ role of stochasticity in‌​‌ biological systems through the​​ development and analysis of​​​‌ Stochastic Differential Equations (SDE)‌ for reaction networks; Axes‌​‌ 3 and 4 (in​​ blue in Fig. 1​​​‌) aim to provide‌ a theoretical understanding of‌​‌ continuum models widely used​​ to describe biological systems​​​‌ at the population scale,‌ essentially by use of‌​‌ Ordinary Differential Equations (ODE)​​ for the applications to​​​‌ mathematical epidemiology (dark blue‌ in Fig. 1),‌​‌ or of Partial Differential​​ Equations (PDE) for various​​​‌ applications (in light blue‌ in Fig. 1);‌​‌ and Axis 5, the​​ most interdisciplinary axis of​​​‌ our research team, is‌ entirely devoted to the‌​‌ development of valid agent-based​​ models directly confronted to​​​‌ in vitro/in vivo data‌ for bacterial growth and‌​‌ tissue development and ageing​​ (orange in Fig. 1​​​‌). Lastly, Axis 1‌ (in red arrows in‌​‌ Fig. 1) represents​​ one of the fundamental​​​‌ perspectives to link all‌ our research activities. It‌​‌ is devoted to establishing​​ the link between the​​​‌ various modelling viewpoints taken‌ in the other research‌​‌ axes, by deriving, as​​ rigorously as possible, the​​​‌ continuum (ODE, SDE, PDE)‌ models from microscopic agent-based‌​‌ descriptions.

The MUSCLEES project-team​​ gathers researchers with complementary​​​‌ skills and interests in‌ applied mathematics (partial differential‌​‌ equations, stochastic processes, control​​ theory). Our goal is​​​‌ to incorporate the different‌ knowledges present in the‌​‌ team as well as​​ expertise obtained from first​​​‌ hand collaborators specialists of‌ the considered applications, in‌​‌ order to provide firm​​ mathematical ground to the​​​‌ representation, understanding, numerical assessment‌ and control of the‌​‌ biological systems of interest.​​ As a peculiarity, we​​​‌ also intend to locate‌ these questions in the‌​‌ larger framework of analysis​​ methods. We will always​​​‌ attempt to unify as‌ much as possible the‌​‌ specific application domains within​​ a common formalism, with​​​‌ scales ranging from individual‌ decision to collective behaviour:‌​‌ this vision and methodology​​ go far beyond the​​​‌ specific applications we have‌ listed. Altogether, the team‌​‌ ambitions to provide a​​ deep Mathematical Understanding across​​​‌ Scales of Complex Living‌ Ecosystems with Emerging Structures,‌​‌ whence the acronym: MUSCLEES​​. Our planned activities​​​‌ are exposed below. As‌ a rule, they are‌​‌ activities already currently in​​ progress or whose realisation​​​‌ will be undertaken soon.‌ Longer-term actions or perspectives‌​‌ are mentioned specifically, whenever​​ needed.

3 Research program​​​‌

The research program is‌ organized along the five‌​‌ following axes.

  • Axis 1​​​‌ – Multiscale study of​ interacting particle systems
  • Axis​‌ 2 – Stochastic models​​ for biological systems
  • Axis​​​‌ 3 – Theoretical analysis​ of nonlinear partial differential​‌ equations (PDE) modelling various​​ structured population dynamics
  • Axis​​​‌ 4 – Mathematical epidemiology​
  • Axis 5 – Development​‌ and analysis of mathematical​​ models for biological tissues​​​‌ confronted to experimental data​

The logic of this​‌ structure is as follows.​​ A first perspective is​​​‌ related to the various​ scales. Axis 1​‌ is related to the​​ passage from microscopic to​​​‌ mesoscopic scales (these terms​ are recalled in the​‌ beginning of the Section​​ 3.1). The passage​​​‌ to the macroscopic scale​ and/or the study of​‌ the corresponding models is​​ the core of the​​​‌ Axes 2 (stochastic models),​ 3 (deterministic PDEs) and​‌ 4 (deterministic ODEs). In​​ this respect, Axis 5​​​‌ holds a special place,​ as it is devoted​‌ to the precise confrontation​​ of measured data and​​​‌ model, for some of​ the problems studied in​‌ Axis 3. In a​​ complementary manner, Axes 1,​​​‌ 2 and 3 are​ of a more theoretical​‌ nature, and Axes 4​​ and 5 more focused​​​‌ on specific applications.

3.1​ Axis 1 – Multiscale​‌ study of interacting particle​​ systems

MUSCLEES permanent members​​​‌ involved: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman, Sophie​ Hecht, Benoît Perthame, Diane​‌ Peurichard, Nastassia Pouradier Duteil​​

A growing literature has​​​‌ been devoted to the​ precise mathematical understanding of​‌ the mechanisms subtending pattern​​ formation in multi-agent systems.​​​‌ This subject was initially​ brought forth by pioneering​‌ articles on statistical physics-oriented​​ models for biological systems,​​​‌ and subsequently cemented by​ a wealth of contributions​‌ in the fields of​​ automation theory and engineering.​​​‌ In the midst of​ this broad academical trend,​‌ a research current led​​ by the works of​​​‌ Hegselman and Krause 105​ on bounded confidence models,​‌ and the groundbreaking papers​​ of Cucker and Smale​​​‌ 74 on emergent behaviours,​ started to focus more​‌ specifically on the problems​​ of consensus or alignment​​​‌.

Multi-agent systems refer​ to systems of N​‌ agents represented​​ by points in a​​​‌ given configuration space (most​ often, the Euclidean space​‌ d), which​​ evolve according to coupled​​​‌ dynamics of the form​

x ˙ i (​‌ t ) = 1​​ N i =​​​‌ 1 N ϕ i​ j ( x j​‌ ( t ) -​​ x i ( t​​​‌ ) ) . 1​

Here, the vector (​‌x1(t​​),,​​​‌xN(t​))(​‌d)N​​ represents the collection of​​​‌ all the states of​ the agents at some​‌ time t0​​, while the maps​​​‌ ϕij:​dℝ​‌d, encode pairwise​​ interactions between agents, which​​​‌ usually depend on their​ relative distance and orientation,​‌ but could also depend​​ on the individual nature​​​‌ of the agents, which​ is encoded in the​‌ indexing ϕij​​.

Depending on the​​​‌ nature of the interaction​ functions ϕij​‌, these models can​​ be roughly classified in​​ two categories. In the​​​‌ first one, interactions are‌ pre-determined by a given‌​‌ interaction network, which represents​​ the inherent structure of​​​‌ the population's interactions. Then‌ each pairwise interaction ϕ‌​‌ij is non-zero​​ if and only if​​​‌ the edge (i‌,j) is‌​‌ part of the underlying​​ graph of interactions. The​​​‌ second approach considers the‌ particle interactions as functions‌​‌ only of the particle's​​ positions: ϕij​​​‌:=ϕ.‌ In this case, there‌​‌ is no underlying network.​​

Mathematically, one of the​​​‌ main challenges in the‌ study of these systems‌​‌ is their multi-scale aspect.​​ Indeed, the reason that​​​‌ such systems have been‌ introduced is to link‌​‌ local interactions to global​​ behavior. Moreover, in numerous​​​‌ applications these systems are‌ very high dimensional, as‌​‌ they are composed of​​ many individuals, all potentially​​​‌ interacting. Studying and simulating‌ interacting particle systems becomes‌​‌ a particularly challenging problem​​ when the dimension of​​​‌ the system increases. This‌ is referred to as‌​‌ the “curse of dimensionality”,​​ a term coined by​​​‌ Bellman in the context‌ of dynamic optimization of‌​‌ high-dimensional systems. One way​​ around this problem is​​​‌ to move away from‌ the microscopic viewpoint where‌​‌ each agent is considered​​ individually, and consider instead​​​‌ the mean-field limit, which‌ provides a kinetic description‌​‌ of the system. This​​ approach consists of approximating​​​‌ the influence of all‌ agents on any given‌​‌ individual by one averaged​​ effect, which amounts to​​​‌ studying a single partial‌ differential equation (PDE), instead‌​‌ of a large system​​ of coupled ordinary differential​​​‌ equations (ODE).

As several‌ limiting processes can be‌​‌ considered when one passes​​ from an `agent-based' description​​​‌ of a system to‌ a `continuous' one, let‌​‌ us make clear some​​ nomenclature that we will​​​‌ employ throughout this document.‌ We will refer to‌​‌ as `microscopic' the models​​ of agent-based type, i.e​​​‌ systems of ODE that‌ describe the evolution of‌​‌ each agent in a​​ population (each described by​​​‌ individual variables such as‌ position, speed, size, etc).‌​‌ We will first be​​ interested in taking the​​​‌ limit of large number‌ of individuals from our‌​‌ agent-based models, leading to​​ continuum (possibly non-local) PDE​​​‌ models describing the evolution‌ of the agents' probability‌​‌ distribution (structured in space,​​ time, possibly size etc).​​​‌ We will refer to‌ these models as `mesoscopic',‌​‌ where `mesoscopic' is to​​ be understood here as​​​‌ an intermediate scale, describing‌ populations composed of an‌​‌ ideally infinite number of​​ agents but still expressed​​​‌ at the individual scale‌ (no rescaling of time‌​‌ or space, i.e interactions​​ still expressed at the​​​‌ agents' scale). On the‌ other hand, we will‌​‌ refer to as `macroscopic'​​ the PDE models obtained​​​‌ after rescaling in time‌ and space the mesoscopic‌​‌ models, in various regimes​​ (diffusion limit, hydrodynamic limit​​​‌ etc) and under proper‌ assumptions on the order‌​‌ of the agents' interactions.​​ According to the assumptions​​​‌ made on the interactions,‌ these `macroscopic' models will‌​‌ correspond to different microscopic​​ dynamics.

3.1.1 Micro-Meso: Graph​​​‌ limits

MUSCLEES permanent members‌ involved: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman, Nastassia‌​‌ Pouradier Duteil

In 2014,​​​‌ Medvedev used techniques from​ the recent theory of​‌ graph limit to derive​​ rigorously the continuum limit​​​‌ of dynamical models on​ deterministic graphs 128.​‌ The limiting equation, so-called​​ “graphon equation” now describes​​​‌ the evolution of the​ particle's positions x(​‌t,s)​​ as a function of​​​‌ time t and of​ the “continuous index” s​‌I (representing the​​ particle's individual identities, in​​​‌ an infinite population):

∂​ t x ( t​‌ , s ) =​​ I ϕ (​​​‌ s , s '​ , x ( t​‌ , s ' )​​ - x ( t​​​‌ , s ) )​ . d s '​‌ 2

In 50,​​ we extended this idea​​​‌ to a collective dynamics​ model with time-varying weights,​‌ adopting the graph point​​ of view described above.​​​‌ We showed that this​ approach is more general​‌ than the mean-field one,​​ and the Graph Limit​​​‌ can be derived for​ a much greater variety​‌ of models.

Our work​​ will involve deriving graph​​​‌ limits for systems of​ particles that can be​‌ structured along a trait​​ that characterizes their interactions,​​​‌ such as volume, mass​ or phenotype. Among the​‌ open problems that we​​ aim to address in​​​‌ collaboration with Nathalie Ayi​ (LJLL, Sorbonne University), one​‌ of them concerns the​​ graph limit for multi-agent​​​‌ systems evolving on weighted​ random graphs. More specifically,​‌ we will consider that​​ the interactions between agents​​​‌ are given by ϕ​ij(x​‌j(t)​​-xi(​​​‌t)):​=ξij​‌ϕ(xj​​(t)-​​​‌xi(t​)), where​‌ (ξij​​)i,j​​​‌ are random variables whose​ laws are probability distributions​‌ on + that​​ depend on the indices​​​‌ i,j.​ Graphs with random topologies​‌ are often used to​​ model systems such as​​​‌ neuronal networks, coupled lasers​ and communication or power​‌ networks. In 128,​​ the continuum limit of​​​‌ collective dynamics on random​ graphs was derived for​‌ graphs whose edge weights​​ ξij can​​​‌ be either 0 (i.e.​ there is no edge)​‌ or 1. Our aim​​ will be to generalize​​​‌ this results to random​ weighted graphs, whose weights​‌ can be given by​​ any positive real number.​​​‌ Results will then possibly​ be extended to temporal​‌ random graphs, whose edge​​ weights evolve in time​​​‌ as in blinking systems.​

In a parallel direction,​‌ we will explore the​​ possibilities of the graph-limit​​​‌ formalism in the framework​ of epidemiological models on​‌ graph. A first step​​ was done in 84​​​‌ by deriving the graph​ limit of an epidemiological​‌ model on graphs, which​​ results in a system​​​‌ of coupled structured PDEs​ for the susceptible, infected​‌ and recovered populations. The​​ graph-limit approach will allow​​​‌ us to ask ourselves​ fundamental analytical and modeling​‌ questions regarding the role​​ of the interaction network​​​‌ in the spread of​ an epidemic. It will​‌ also give us the​​ possibility to address control​​ and optimal control problems​​​‌ aiming to minimize the‌ infected population by controlling‌​‌ the graphon (i.e. the​​ continuous interaction network). Another​​​‌ possibility will be to‌ address inverse problems in‌​‌ order to infer the​​ graph structure based on​​​‌ the epidemic spread. This‌ project will link the‌​‌ research of team members​​ involved in Sections 3.1​​​‌ and 3.4.

3.1.2‌ Micro-Meso: Beyond mean-field limits‌​‌

MUSCLEES permanent members involved:​​ Sophie Hecht, Diane Peurichard,​​​‌ Nastassia Pouradier Duteil

When‌ the interaction between particles‌​‌ is independent of each​​ particle's individual nature, i.e.​​​‌ ϕij=‌ϕ, the particles‌​‌ are said to be​​ exchangeable, or indistinguishable​​​‌. In this case,‌ the classical approach to‌​‌ link microscopic and mesoscopic​​ models is a limit​​​‌ process called “mean-field limit”,‌ and consists of approximating‌​‌ the population by a​​ sum of localized point​​​‌ masses, and then of‌ sending the number of‌​‌ agents to infinity, while​​ sending each individual mass​​​‌ to zero 86.‌ In this way, the‌​‌ total mass of the​​ population is conserved throughout​​​‌ the limit process, and‌ everything can be done‌​‌ in the framework of​​ probability measures. The limit​​​‌ PDE is typically a‌ non-linear transport equation of‌​‌ the type

t​​ μ ( t ,​​​‌ x ) + ∇‌ · V [ μ‌​‌ ( t , ·​​ ) ] ( x​​​‌ ) μ ( t‌ , x ) =‌​‌ 0 , V [​​ μ ( t ,​​​‌ · ) ] (‌ x ) = ∫‌​‌ d ϕ (​​ y - x )​​​‌ d μ ( t‌ , y ) ,‌​‌

in which μ(​​t,·)​​​‌𝒫(ℝ‌d) represents the‌​‌ particle distribution at time​​ t, and the​​​‌ non-local velocity V[‌μt] represents‌​‌ the averaged effect of​​ the whole population on​​​‌ each individual. However, this‌ approach has a main‌​‌ drawback: it does not​​ take into account the​​​‌ intrinsic volume of the‌ individuals, since they are‌​‌ approximated by their centers​​ of mass. As a​​​‌ result, in many cases‌ the limiting PDE fails‌​‌ to reproduce the behavior​​ of the microscopic system,​​​‌ in particular when modeling‌ congestion effects due to‌​‌ size constraints.

This is​​ a major modeling limitation,​​​‌ and resolving it is‌ crucial. Several works have‌​‌ highlighted a discrepancy between​​ the microscopic and continuum​​​‌ modeling approaches. For instance,‌ in the context of‌​‌ emergency crowd evacuation, microscopic​​ models are able to​​​‌ reproduce the well-known effect‌ of arch formation in‌​‌ front of exits, resulting​​ in congestion and dramatic​​​‌ slow-down of the crowd's‌ evacuation 126. This‌​‌ effect still eludes all​​ natural continuum limits. Another​​​‌ example can be found‌ in the modeling of‌​‌ cell division: microscopic models​​ capture the fact that​​​‌ the cell population is‌ naturally pushed outwards at‌​‌ the birth of a​​ new daughter cell because​​​‌ of its added volume.‌ This effect is lost‌​‌ in continuum models, as​​ there is no concept​​​‌ of individual size.

The‌ goal of this part‌​‌ of the project is​​​‌ to address this issue.​ We will first focus​‌ on the simple situation​​ of a population of​​​‌ agents whose only interactions​ are due to “non-overlapping”​‌ constraints: if two agents​​ are within a certain​​​‌ distance (representing their diameter),​ they exert a repulsive​‌ force on each other;​​ if their distance is​​​‌ greater than this diameter,​ there is no interaction.​‌ Despite the simplicity of​​ this setting, the micro-macro​​​‌ limit is highly non-trivial​ due to the role​‌ of the agents' size​​ in the dynamics. Indeed,​​​‌ in the continuum description,​ the information on the​‌ agents' size is lost,​​ and the condition on​​​‌ the agent-to-agent distance no​ longer makes sense, as​‌ the concept of individual​​ agents is gone. However,​​​‌ intuitively, one would expect​ that this distance condition​‌ would correspond to a​​ density condition in the​​​‌ continuum setting: interactions take​ place if and only​‌ if the local density​​ is above a critical​​​‌ threshold. We will explore​ these questions on systems​‌ with identical particles (same​​ and fixed sizes), and​​​‌ take a particular interest​ in how non-overlapping configurations​‌ translate into local density​​ constraints at the population​​​‌ level.

In order to​ gain insights into the​‌ role of the individual​​ particle sizes and shapes​​​‌ on the macroscopic structures​ generated at the population​‌ level, we will consider​​ another approach where the​​​‌ particle density distribution for​ the mean-field limit is​‌ structured in space and​​ sizes. In current works​​​‌ (to be submitted), we​ showed that under reasonable​‌ assumptions for the interaction​​ kernel ψr,​​​‌s, the limit​ PDE describing the particle​‌ distribution μ(t​​,x,r​​​‌) (depending on time,​ space and radius) is​‌ of the type:

∂​​ t μ ( t​​​‌ , x , r​ ) - x​‌ · μ ( t​​ , x , r​​​‌ ) x ∫​ + ψ r​‌ , s * x​​ μ ( t ,​​​‌ x , s )​ d s - σ​‌ Δ x μ (​​ t , x ,​​​‌ r ) = 0​ . 3

Proving the​‌ convergence of the particle​​ system to the limit​​​‌ PDE with the added​ radial structure in the​‌ density distribution is challenging​​ and is a work​​​‌ in collaboration with Marc​ Hoffman (Université Paris Dauphine).​‌

3.1.3 Scaling limits

MUSCLEES​​ permanent members involved: Sophie​​​‌ Hecht, Benoît Perthame, Diane​ Peurichard, Nastassia Pouradier Duteil​‌

In order to link​​ the mesoscopic and the​​​‌ macroscopic model it is​ common to consider a​‌ scaling limit. Depending of​​ the variable of the​​​‌ system the scaling can​ vary (small particle compared​‌ to space, slow division​​ compared to the mechanical​​​‌ interaction, etc).

Meso-Macro: the​ limit of small particles​‌ – compressible case

Going​​ back to the mesoscopic​​​‌ equation (3)​ structured in size and​‌ space, we will consider​​ a scaling where the​​​‌ size of the particles​ becomes small compared to​‌ the space itself, while​​ keeping the interaction of​​​‌ order 1 (compressible limit).​ Under these scaling assumptions,​‌ we can formally compute​​ that the equation becomes:​​

t n (​​​‌ t , x ,‌ r ) - ∇‌​‌ x · n (​​ t , x ,​​​‌ r ) α‌ r , s ∇‌​‌ x n ( t​​ , x , s​​​‌ ) d s -‌ σ Δ x n‌​‌ ( t , x​​ , r ) =​​​‌ 0 with α r‌ , s = ∫‌​‌ ψ r , s​​ ( x ) d​​​‌ x ,

where the‌ particle distribution is now‌​‌ denoted by n(​​t,x,​​​‌r). The‌ tools to rigorously derive‌​‌ the macroscopic equation requires​​ compacity for the density.​​​‌ Thanks to the diffusion‌ term we can easily‌​‌ find space compacity, and​​ in the case where​​​‌ σ=0,‌ energy estimates can allow‌​‌ to recover the result.​​ The difficulty for the​​​‌ convergence resides in finding‌ the compacity according to‌​‌ the size variable density.​​ A recent idea allowed​​​‌ us to circumvent this‌ problem. We now aim‌​‌ to extend the result​​ when considering particle growth​​​‌ and division. In order‌ to do this we‌​‌ will focus on the​​ fact that the equation​​​‌ is a mixed between‌ a reaction diffusion equation‌​‌ and a growth-fragmentation equation.​​

Meso-macro: The incompressible limit​​​‌

Another limiting process that‌ can be considered is‌​‌ the so-called `incompressible limit',​​ where the pressure of​​​‌ the system is scaled‌ to become singular. A‌​‌ possible way to study​​ such regime is to​​​‌ work directly at the‌ continuum (macroscopic) level and‌​‌ consider the continuous equation​​

t n (​​​‌ t , x )‌ - x ·‌​‌ n ( t ,​​ x ) x​​​‌ p ( n (‌ t , x )‌​‌ = 0 ,

where​​ p represents the pressure​​​‌ of the system depending‌ of the density, the‌​‌ incompressible limit consists in​​ rendering p singular. A​​​‌ classical example is the‌ choice p(n‌​‌)=γγ​​-1nγ​​​‌-1 with γ‌+.‌​‌ This type of limit​​ has been widely studied​​​‌ in the past decade‌ 28, 29,‌​‌ 62 and still provides​​ interesting and difficult problems.​​​‌ For one species we‌ can note the case‌​‌ where the velocity of​​ the system in the​​​‌ Brinkman case allows a‌ rotational component. In the‌​‌ multiple-species case we can​​ consider the case where​​​‌ the motility rate of‌ the species are different.‌​‌

Meso-Macro: the link between​​ compressible and incompressible limits​​​‌

This part of the‌ project will be devoted‌​‌ to the study of​​ the link between the​​​‌ two types of limits‌ considered previously, namely the‌​‌ compressible and incompressible limits​​ of mesoscopic models. To​​​‌ this aim, we will‌ consider as starting point‌​‌ multiphase flow models for​​ tumor growth based on​​​‌ mixture theory, well studied‌ by members of the‌​‌ teams. According to the​​ mixture theory, a tissue​​​‌ is modeled as a‌ multiphase flow (different types‌​‌ of cells, liquid, molecules)​​ through a porous media​​​‌ (extra-cellular matrix). In mathematical‌ terms, this leads to‌​‌ strongly nonlinear degenerate parabolic​​​‌ Cahn-Hilliard equations 148for​ the cell density φ​‌(t,x​​) as

t​​​‌ φ ( t ,​ x ) + div​‌ [ φ ( t​​ , x ) M​​​‌ ( φ ( t​ , x ) )​‌ ν ( t​​ , x ) ]​​​‌ = 0 , b​ l a c k​‌ ν = V​​ ( φ ) +​​​‌ δ Δ φ ,​

where M represents the​‌ mobility, V describes the​​ interactions between cells, and​​​‌ δ is the surface​ tension parameter. Our aim​‌ is to derive such​​ equations from mesoscopic (kinetic)​​​‌ models and to understand​ relations between compressible and​‌ incompressible models.

Cells may​​ also change their phenotype.​​​‌ Migration, invasion and the​ epithelial-mesanchymal transition (EMT) are​‌ basic principles of the​​ way cells can initiate​​​‌ a collective movement in​ a living tissue as​‌ described above. This is​​ particularly important for the​​​‌ initialisation of metastases in​ cancer. With the Inserm​‌ team, Laboratoire de Biologie​​ du Cancer et Thérapeutique,​​​‌ Saint-Antoine hospital, we will​ develop a model of​‌ invasion through membranes in​​ breast cancer.

3.2 Axis​​​‌ 2 – Stochastic models​ for biological systems

MUSCLEES​‌ permanent members involved: Benoît​​ Perthame, Philippe Robert

This​​​‌ line of research investigates​ models where a stochastic​‌ component, the so-called, and​​ somewhat ambiguous notion, “noise”​​​‌ of the biological literature,​ plays an important role.​‌ This is for example​​ the case for gene​​​‌ expression in bacterial cells,​ see 155, or​‌ in some neural networks​​ to represent the occurrence​​​‌ of spiking events, see​ 157. The stochastic​‌ framework is due to​​ dynamics of binding/unbinding of​​​‌ pairs of macro-molecules within​ biological cells. It can​‌ be also when a​​ small subset of enzymes​​​‌ has an important impact​ on the dynamic of​‌ the macromolecules, so that​​ the classical law of​​​‌ mass action is not​ anymore relevant to represent​‌ the system. This is​​ a quite different perspective​​​‌ from classical mathematical biological​ models for population processes​‌ where, essentially, a macroscopic​​ view is used, with​​​‌ branching processes in particular.​

Scaling approaches are used​‌ to investigate these models.​​ The scaling parameter being​​​‌ either the total number​ of interacting macromolecules, the​‌ number of cells, or​​ the factor of the​​​‌ time-scale of fast processes​ ... Functional laws of​‌ large numbers, functional central​​ limit theorems, and averaging​​​‌ principles are the main​ technical results which can​‌ be proved to have​​ a qualitative description of​​​‌ these systems.

3.2.1 Regulation​ Mechanisms of Gene Expression​‌

MUSCLEES permanent members involved:​​ Philippe Robert

The central​​​‌ dogma of molecular biology​ states that the genetic​‌ information flows only in​​ one way, from DNA​​​‌ to RNAs, and to​ proteins. The production of​‌ proteins is a central​​ process of biological cells.​​​‌ It can be described​ as a two-step process.​‌ In the first step,​​ macro-molecules polymerases produce RNAs​​​‌ with genes of the​ DNA. This is the​‌ transcription step. The second​​ step is the production​​​‌ of proteins itself from​ mRNAs, messenger RNAs,​‌ a subset of RNAs,​​ with macro-molecules ribosomes.​​ This is the translation​​​‌ step. An additional feature‌ of this process is‌​‌ that it is consuming​​ an important fraction of​​​‌ energy resources of the‌ cell, to build chains‌​‌ of amino-acids or chains​​ of nucleotides in particular.​​​‌ See 54, 146‌, 155.

In‌​‌ the context of prokaryotic​​ cells, like bacterial cells​​​‌ or archaeal cells. The‌ cytoplasm of these cells‌​‌ is not as structured​​ as eukaryotic cells, like​​​‌ mammalian cells for example,‌ so that most of‌​‌ the macro-molecules of these​​ cells can potentially collide​​​‌ with each other. This‌ key biological process can‌​‌ be, roughly, described as​​ resulting of multiple encounters/collisions​​​‌ of several types of‌ macro-molecules of the cell:‌​‌ polymerases with DNA, ribosomes​​ with mRNAs, or​​​‌ proteins with DNA, ...‌

The fact that the‌​‌ cytoplasm of a bacterial​​ cell is a disorganized​​​‌ medium has important implications‌ on the internal dynamics‌​‌ of these organisms. Numerous​​ events are triggered by​​​‌ random events associated to‌ thermal noise. When the‌​‌ external conditions are favorable,​​ these cells can nevertheless​​​‌ multiply via division at‌ a steady pace. A‌​‌ central question is of​​ understanding how the cell​​​‌ adapts to different environments‌ (scarce resources or rich‌​‌ environment).

Important regulation mechanisms​​ of gene expression of​​​‌ bacterial cells are achieved‌ with RNAs. Up to‌​‌ now little is known​​ on the efficiency of​​​‌ this type of regulation‌ from a quantitative point‌​‌ of view. The ambitious​​ goal is of designing​​​‌ and investigating stochastic models‌ integrating the transcription and‌​‌ translation steps as well​​ as the flows of​​​‌ amino-acids within the cell.‌ One of the difficulties‌​‌ is the number of​​ different chemical species involved:​​​‌ genes, RNAs, tRNAs, sRNAs,‌ rRNAs, proteins, Amino-acids, ppGppp,‌​‌ RelA, ...All of them​​ having an important role​​​‌ in this regulation. A‌ scaling approach is investigated‌​‌ to study these multi-dimensional​​ Markov processes. This is​​​‌ a collaboration with Vincent‌ Fromion of the laboratory‌​‌ BioSys "Biology of systems"​​ of Inrae. The main​​​‌ goal of these studies‌ is to evaluate the‌​‌ efficiency of these regulation​​ mechanisms in the cell​​​‌ for the adaptation to‌ changes of environment: switching‌​‌ times, impact of the​​ variation of the flows​​​‌ of amino-acids, ..., and‌ the dependence on the‌​‌ production rates of ppGppp,​​ RelA and sRNAs among​​​‌ others.

3.2.2 Stochastic Chemical‌ Reaction Networks

MUSCLEES permanent‌​‌ members involved: Philippe Robert​​

The goal of the​​​‌ research project of this‌ section is of investigating‌​‌ a generalization of the​​ law of mass action​​​‌ for biological systems.

For‌ example, if three chemical‌​‌ species 𝒜, ℬ​​ and 𝒞 are involved​​​‌ in a chemical reaction‌ of the type,

𝒜‌​‌ + 𝒞​​ , 4

the classical​​​‌ law of mass action‌ states that the concentration‌​‌ xM(t​​) of the chemical​​​‌ specy M at time‌ t satisfies the relation‌​‌

d x C (​​ t ) d t​​​‌ = k x A‌ ( t ) x‌​‌ B ( t )​​ .

The ODE in​​​‌ this case is a‌ quadratic functional of the‌​‌ state vector. In a​​​‌ deterministic context, the famous​ results by Horn, Johnson​‌ and Feinberg give, for​​ some specific topologies, a​​​‌ satisfactory description of the​ stable states of these​‌ networks. See 98 for​​ example. It turns that​​​‌ this description is suitable​ for systems for which​‌ the orders of magnitude​​ of the different chemical​​​‌ species are comparable and​ that the stochastic components​‌ merely vanish. These assumptions​​ are nevertheless not true​​​‌ in some biological settings,​ when, for example, reactions​‌ are driven by a​​ small number of enzymes​​​‌ but with a large​ reaction rate.

As already​‌ mentioned, due to dynamics​​ of binding/unbinding of pairs​​​‌ of macro-molecules within biological​ cells, it is natural​‌ to consider models of​​ chemical reaction networks for​​​‌ which collisions of chemical​ species occur in a​‌ random way. In the​​ above example, it will​​​‌ be assumed that a​ given couple of A​‌ and B particles will​​ collide at rate k​​​‌, so that if​ XM(t​‌) is the number​​ of particles of type​​​‌ M at time t​, then, at time​‌ t, a particle​​ of type C is​​​‌ created at rate k​XA(t​‌)XB(​​t). The​​​‌ process (XA​(t),​‌XB(t​​),Xc​​​‌(t))​ is a Markov process,​‌ if we assume that​​ there are external arrivals​​​‌ of A and B​ particles, it is natural​‌ to study the convergence​​ in distribution of this​​​‌ Markov process. There are​ several conjectures in this​‌ domain.

Up to now​​ there are few results​​​‌ in such a random​ context. The reference 41​‌ shows, by using the​​ results of the deterministic​​​‌ case that the invariant​ distribution has a product​‌ form expression for a​​ specific set of topologies.​​​‌ A challenging question is​ of extending stability results​‌ for networks for which​​ no such product formula​​​‌ holds. New tools, such​ as scaling techniques, have​‌ to be developed to​​ study these important problems.​​​‌

3.2.3 Neural Networks

MUSCLEES​ permanent members involved: Benoît​‌ Perthame, Philippe Robert

This​​ application domain of this​​​‌ line of research is​ described in the subsection​‌ “Neuroscience” of Section 4.1​​.

Interacting Hawkes processes​​​‌

When the number of​ nodes of a neural​‌ network is fixed (i.e.​​ not large), one of​​​‌ the challenging questions is​ of determining the asymptotic,​‌ temporal, behavior of a​​ neural network composed of​​​‌ inhibitory and excitatory neural​ cells. In general mathematical​‌ models of neural networks​​ assume excitatory nodes. A​​​‌ classical example is the​ self-excitatory neural cell, the​‌ integrate and fire model.​​ However, experiments have shown​​​‌ that inhibitory cells play​ a key role in​‌ the procedures of learning.​​ See 173 for example.​​​‌

A typical, simple, evolution​ of a node i​‌ of the network ℛ​​ could be of the​​​‌ form

d X i​ ( t ) =​‌ - X i (​​ t ) d t​​​‌ + j ∈​ { i​‌ } W j i​​ ( t - )​​ 𝒩 j ( d​​​‌ t ) - X‌ i ( t -‌​‌ ) 𝒩 i (​​ d t ) d​​​‌ Z i ( t‌ ) = - γ‌​‌ Z i ( t​​ ) d t +​​​‌ 𝒩 i ( d‌ t ) , d‌​‌ W i j (​​ t ) = B​​​‌ i Z i (‌ t - ) 𝒩‌​‌ j ( d t​​ ) + B j​​​‌ Z j ( t‌ - ) 𝒩 j‌​‌ ( d t )​​ - δ W j​​​‌ i ( t )‌ d t ,

where‌​‌ Biℝ​​, Bi>​​​‌0 if i is‌ excitatory and inhibitory otherwise.‌​‌

  • Xi(​​t) is the​​​‌ membrane potential of i‌ at time t;‌​‌
  • Wij​​(t) is​​​‌ the synaptic weight of‌ the link i-‌​‌j at time t​​;
  • 𝒩i​​​‌(dt)‌ is a point process‌​‌ with intensity β(​​Xi(t​​​‌)), it‌ is associated to the‌​‌ spike train of i​​;
  • Zi​​​‌(t) encodes‌ the past spiking activity‌​‌ of node i at​​ time t.

The​​​‌ asymptotic of the matrix‌ of synaptic weights (‌​‌Wij(​​t)) when​​​‌ t gets large is‌ the main quantity of‌​‌ interest. Up to now​​ there are few theoretical​​​‌ results to determine the‌ conditions under which a‌​‌ given link is asymptotically​​ “weak”, when its weight​​​‌ converges to 0, or‌ “strong” when it grows‌​‌ without bound.

Mean-field neural​​ networks

For large neural​​​‌ networks as described before,‌ mean-field limits have been‌​‌ established in a number​​ of situations. The resulting​​​‌ probability distributions satisfy nonlinear‌ PDEs which can be‌​‌ of Integrate&Fire type, renewal​​ type or combinations. The​​​‌ specific non-linearities raise severe‌ difficulties in terms of‌​‌ analysis and numerics, as​​ global existence vs finite​​​‌ blow-up, asymptotic analysis, understanding‌ of synchronisation or convergence‌​‌ to steady state. ŁMotivated​​ either by their mathematical​​​‌ interest of questions asked‌ by biologists, we will‌​‌ continue our analysis of​​ this large class of​​​‌ problems (see, e.g., 111‌) in several directions:‌​‌

  • analyze the current​​ models introduced in biophysics​​​‌ (N. Brunel) to take‌ into account spike-triggered adaptation.‌​‌ The difficulty here is​​ the degeneracy of the​​​‌ equations, which leads to‌ several long term problems‌​‌ involving a PhD thesis,​​
  • define solutions of​​​‌ structured equations (see Section‌ 3.3) with infinite‌​‌ number of variables, in​​ relations to Wold processes​​​‌ (in the spirit described‌ above for Hawkes processes,‌​‌ a short term programm),​​
  • explain anti-phase synchronisation​​​‌ in networks à la‌ Wilson-Cowan vs experimental observations.‌​‌ A collaboration with D.​​ Avitabile and D. Salort​​​‌ has begun and results‌ are encouraging.

3.3 Axis‌​‌ 3 – Theoretical analysis​​ of nonlinear partial differential​​​‌ equations (PDE) modelling various‌ structured population dynamics

MUSCLEES‌​‌ permanent members involved: Luca​​ Alasio, Jean Clairambault, Benoît​​​‌ Perthame, Nastassia Pouradier Duteil‌

Since the seminal paper‌​‌ by McKendrick for medical​​​‌ applications 26, to​ account for relevant heterogeneity​‌ in the variables under​​ study (most often populations​​​‌ of individuals such as​ proteins, cells, animal species,​‌ etc.), continuous models in​​ biology rely on equations​​​‌ structured by different variables,​ age, size, physiological trait...​‌ The interest of studying​​ these equations stems from​​​‌ the mathematical structure of​ these equations (which are​‌ neither conservative, nor self-adjoint),​​ their non-linearities and the​​​‌ complex behaviour of solutions.​

3.3.1 Adaptive phenotype-structured cell​‌ population dynamics

MUSCLEES permanent​​ members involved: Jean Clairambault,​​​‌ Benoît Perthame, Nastassia Pouradier​ Duteil

Initially developed for​‌ adaptive dynamics in theoretical​​ ecology and cell population​​​‌ biology models in 79​ and in  81,​‌ phenotype-structured equations are here​​ studied in the context​​​‌ of cell populations confronted​ to a changing environment,​‌ in particular in the​​ case of cancer and​​​‌ its treatments. Some of​ these models, developed within​‌ the former Inria team,​​ have been reviewed in​​​‌ the survey 70.​ A more general and​‌ extended recent state of​​ the art on phenotype-structured​​​‌ population dynamics is reported​ in 120.

Our​‌ research will focus on​​ the analysis of such​​​‌ phenotype-structured equations, and more​ particularly, on their long-time​‌ behavior, of which little​​ is known. Indeed, the​​​‌ different mathematical terms such​ as advection (modeling cell​‌ differentiation), diffusion (modeling epimutations)​​ and non-local source terms​​​‌ (modeling population growth and​ phenotype selection) tend to​‌ have antagonistic effects. One​​ of the main mathematical​​​‌ challenges consists of understanding​ the effect of coupling​‌ such phenomena on the​​ long-time behavior of the​​​‌ solution.

Interacting cell populations:​ Tumour-immune interactions

Preferred models​‌ rely on structured equations​​ of the nonlocal Lotka-Volterra​​​‌ type with exchanges of​ bidirectional inhibitory messages between​‌ the two populations in​​ the form of weighted​​​‌ integrals acting as added​ death terms in the​‌ logistic part of the​​ net proliferation rate (i.e.,​​​‌ nonlocal death term in​ the net rate `birth​‌ minus death'). The heterogeneous​​ tumour cell population density​​​‌ n(t,​x) is structured​‌ according to a tumour​​ malignancy continuous phenotype x​​​‌, here identified to​ `stemness'. Focusing for the​‌ sake of this presentation​​ on adaptive immunity, the​​​‌ effector cells, at contact​ with tumour cells, T-cell​‌ population density (​​t,y)​​​‌ and the naive cells,​ present in lymphoid organs,​‌ T-cell population density p​​(t,y​​​‌), unique source​ term of the effector​‌ T-cell population (​​t,y)​​​‌, are structured according​ to an anti-tumour efficacy​‌ phenotype y. The​​ action of Antigen Presenting​​​‌ Cells (APCs), which instruct​ naive T-cells with the​‌ tumour aggressiveness phenotype x​​ is represented below by​​​‌ the weighted integral χ​(t,y​‌). The model​​ runs as follows:

∂​​​‌ n t (​ t , x )​‌ = R ( x​​ , ρ ( t​​​‌ ) ) - μ​ ( x ) φ​‌ ( t , x​​ ) n ( t​​​‌ , x ) ∂​ t (​‌ t , y )​​ = p ( t​​ , y ) -​​​‌ ν ( y )‌ ρ ( t )‌​‌ 1 + h .​​ I C I (​​​‌ t ) + k‌ 1 ( t‌​‌ , y ) ,​​ p t​​​‌ ( t , y‌ ) = α χ‌​‌ ( t , y​​ ) p ( t​​​‌ , y ) -‌ k 2 p 2‌​‌ ( t , y​​ ) , 5

with​​​‌ total tumour cell mass‌ at time t

ρ‌​‌ ( t ) =​​ 0 1 n​​​‌ ( t , x‌ ) d x ,‌​‌

and

φ ( t​​ , x ) =​​​‌ 0 1 ψ‌ ( x , y‌​‌ ) ( t​​ , y ) d​​​‌ y , χ (‌ t , y )‌​‌ = 0 1​​ ω ( x ,​​​‌ y ) n (‌ t , x )‌​‌ d x , ω​​ ( x , y​​​‌ ) = 1 s‌ e - | x‌​‌ - y | /​​ s , ψ (​​​‌ x , y )‌ = 1 s 1‌​‌ e - | x​​ - y | /​​​‌ s 1 .

We‌ study this system in‌​‌ the framework of the​​ PhD thesis of Zineb​​​‌ Kaid at Tlemcen University,‌ Algeria, and of a‌​‌ collaboration with Camille Pouchol​​ at Université Paris-Cité. The​​​‌ first question concerns the‌ large time behaviour of‌​‌ the system, depending in​​ particular on functions μ​​​‌(x) (sensitivity‌ of tumour cells to‌​‌ the action of T-cells)​​ and ν(y​​​‌) (sensitivity of T-cells‌ to PD-ligands), without treatment.‌​‌ We also study its​​ behaviour with added constant​​​‌ control ICI‌ (for Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors,‌​‌ see 4.2, Tumour-immune​​ cell interactions), aiming in​​​‌ particular at representing reversal‌ from escape to extinction‌​‌ or equilibrium in the​​ cancer cell population. Some​​​‌ analytical results on phenotype‌ concentration in x have‌​‌ been reached already in​​ the case where φ​​​‌=φ(t‌) is independent of‌​‌ x (then representing more​​ innate, due to NK-lymphocytes,​​​‌ than adaptive immunity), however‌ the general case remains‌​‌ to be fully explored.​​ Adding the effect of​​​‌ time-scheduled immunotherapies (in particular‌ anti-PD1 immune checkpoint inhibitors‌​‌ ICI(​​t)) and​​​‌ their optimisation, following the‌ optimal control methodology of‌​‌ 152, will be​​ the ultimate object of​​​‌ this study. We may‌ also include small parameters,‌​‌ e.g. in the initial​​ distributions, and study the​​​‌ limiting constrained Hamilton-Jacobi equation‌ (see below).

Asymptotics: population‌​‌ convergence, trait divergence and​​ trait concentration

Plasticity, and​​​‌ `bet hedging' in cancer‌ have been modelled, in‌​‌ the framework of Frank​​ Ernesto Alvarez Borges's PhD​​​‌ thesis at Paris-Dauphine University,‌ by a phenotype-structured reaction-advection-diffusion‌​‌ equation 40 in which​​ the structure variables are​​​‌ viability, fecundity - with‌ a trade-off condition between‌​‌ them - and plasticity,​​ this last variable tuning​​​‌ in a nondecreasing mode‌ a Laplacian that represents‌​‌ nongenetic instability of the​​ other two phenotype variables.​​​‌ The asymptotics of the‌ model, which has been‌​‌ inspired by the Bouin-Calvez​​​‌ cane toad equation, yields​ phenotypic divergence between viability​‌ and fecundity traits, while​​ the plasticity trait asymptotically​​​‌ decreases. The main equation,​ where z=(​‌x,y,​​θ) with x​​​‌=viability, y=fecundity, θ​=plasticity, runs as:

∂​‌ t n + ∇​​ · { V n​​​‌ - A ( θ​ ) n }​‌ = ( r (​​ z ) - d​​​‌ ( z ) ρ​ ( t ) )​‌ n ,

where

(​​ V n - A​​​‌ ( θ ) ∇​ n ) · 𝐧​‌ = 0 for all​​ z D​​​‌

and

n ( 0​ , z ) =​‌ n 0 ( z​​ ) for all z​​​‌ D = Ω​ × [ 0 ,​‌ 1 ] , with​​ Ω : = {​​​‌ C ( x ,​ y ) K​‌ } ,

defining a​​ trade-off between traits x​​​‌ and y.

This​ model, applied with the​‌ aim to investigate the​​ emergence of dimorphism in​​​‌ trait-monomorphic cell populations, is​ intended to represent both​‌ `bet hedging' in cancer​​ populations exposed to cellular​​​‌ stress, and emergence of​ multicellularity in evolution/development, in​‌ the perspective of the​​ atavistic theory of cancer​​​‌ (see above Sec 4.2​). This reaction-advection-diffusion setting​‌ explores the frequent and​​ reversible phenomenon of epimutations​​​‌ (due in particular to​ the reversible graft of​‌ methyl and acetyl radicals​​ on DNA and histones,​​​‌ changing the expression of​ genes without altering the​‌ DNA by any mutation​​ in the sequence of​​​‌ bases) in very plastic​ cancer cell populations -​‌ and also, in the​​ early stages of animal​​​‌ development from a zygote​ to a multicellular individual,​‌ when evolving cell populations​​ are also plastic, i.e.,​​​‌ frequently capable of differentiations,​ de-differentiations and transdifferentiations, all​‌ reversible phenomena - in​​ isogenic cell populations, i.e.,​​​‌ without mutations. How such​ (usually costly, responding to​‌ life-threatening cellular stress) reversible​​ phenomena may, under prolonged​​​‌ environmental evolutionary pressure, lead​ to rare mutations yielding​‌ - usually locally in​​ Cartesian space - new​​​‌ strains actually found in​ tumours, is to the​‌ best of our knowledge​​ a completely open domain​​​‌ of research. In principle,​ transitions from frequent reversible​‌ epimutations to rare established​​ mutations could naturally be​​​‌ studied by piecewise deterministic​ Markov processes (PDMPs). Using​‌ the framework of constrained​​ Hamilton-Jacobi equations mentioned below​​​‌ is another possibility, developed​ in the next paragraph.​‌

The constrained Hamilton-Jacobi equation.​​

For phenotypically structured equations​​​‌ representing large populations under​ the pressure of selection,​‌ it has been established​​ that a class of​​​‌ asymptotic limits are the​ constrained Hamilton-Jacobi equations 147​‌, 65. This​​ is the case for​​​‌ the rare mutations limit​ or for highly concentrated​‌ initial data in models​​ as (5).​​​‌ In that case, and​ including mutations, the problem​‌ is to find the​​ solution S(t​​​‌,x),​ and the Lagrange multipliers​‌ (ρ(t​​),φ(​​​‌t)) such​ that

t S​‌ ( t , x​​ ) = R (​​ x , ρ (​​​‌ t ) , φ‌ ( t ) )‌​‌ + | S​​ ( t , x​​​‌ ) | 2 ,‌ max x S (‌​‌ t , x )​​ = 0 , ∀​​​‌ t 0 .‌

In this framework, an‌​‌ open question is to​​ understand how this limit​​​‌ equation is able to‌ represent the transition from‌​‌ monomorphic (the maximum of​​ S(t,​​​‌·) is achieved‌ at a single point)‌​‌ to dimorphic populations (the​​ maximum of S(​​​‌t,·)‌ is achieved at two‌​‌ points). Is this as​​ smooth as observed in​​​‌ numerical simulations including mutations‌ or does branching emerge‌​‌ from a small, but​​ growing mutant population?

3.3.2​​​‌ Around graphon dynamics

MUSCLEES‌ permanent members involved: Nastassia‌​‌ Pouradier Duteil

As introduced​​ in Section 3.1.1,​​​‌ a possible way to‌ describe infinite-dimensional non-exchangeable particle‌​‌ systems is the so-called​​ graphon equation (2​​​‌). In this equation,‌ the particles' non-exchangeable nature‌​‌ comes from the dependence​​ of the interaction function​​​‌ ϕ on the particles'‌ “continuous index” s:‌​‌ often, ϕ(s​​,s',​​​‌x(t,‌s')-‌​‌x(t,​​s))=​​​‌σ(s,‌s')ϕ‌​‌˜(x(​​t,s'​​​‌)-x(‌t,s)‌​‌), where the​​ function σ, known​​​‌ as “graphon”, encodes the‌ graph relation between the‌​‌ continuous particles. Whereas in​​ Section 3.1.1, we​​​‌ focus on deriving the‌ graph limit equation as‌​‌ a mesoscopic limit of​​ particle systems, here we​​​‌ propose to analyse further‌ this graph-limit framework, and‌​‌ to use it to​​ investigate open problems (more​​​‌ specifically, in control theory)‌ that have so far‌​‌ eluded the community in​​ other frameworks.

Graphon Control​​​‌ for Consensus.

One of‌ the main questions regarding‌​‌ the finite-dimensional particle system​​ (1) involves​​​‌ understanding its large-time asymptotics,‌ and, more specifically, finding‌​‌ necessary and sufficient conditions​​ on the underlying network​​​‌ (encoded in the functions‌ ϕij(‌​‌xj-x​​i)=σ​​​‌ijϕ˜‌(xj-‌​‌xi))​​ for convergence to consensus.​​​‌ This is a highly‌ non-trivial problem, even if‌​‌ sufficient conditions are known​​ (for instance, connectedness of​​​‌ the underlying graph). Related‌ to this problem, many‌​‌ communities are interested in​​ controlling system (1​​​‌) in order to‌ achieve consensus. Generally, the‌​‌ control is introduced as​​ an additive term u​​​‌i, so that‌ (1) becomes:‌​‌ x˙i(​​t)=1​​​‌Ni=‌1Nϕi‌​‌j(xj​​(t)-​​​‌xi(t‌))+u‌​‌i(t)​​. This amounts to​​​‌ influencing each individual's trajectory‌ (or that of a‌​‌ selection of individuals, referred​​ to as “leaders”) in​​​‌ order to drive the‌ group to the desired‌​‌ state. However, here, we​​​‌ propose to embrace a​ different approach and act​‌ instead on the network​​ itself, that is on​​​‌ the coefficients σi​j. Due to​‌ the combinatorial complexity of​​ the problem in its​​​‌ discrete setting (1​), we will instead​‌ study the continuous graphon​​ dynamics (2)​​​‌ and consider the following​ control problem: Which interaction​‌ functions σ(s​​,s')​​​‌ allow to reach consensus​ most efficiently? This work​‌ is conducted in collaboration​​ with Nathalie Ayi, Laurent​​​‌ Boudin and Emmanuel Trélat​ of Sorbonne University's Jacques-Louis​‌ Lions Laboratory.

Measure theoretic​​ generalisation of graphon dynamics.​​​‌

Another description of system​ (2) would​‌ involve introducing a particle​​ density μ(t​​​‌,x,s​) describing the probability​‌ of finding particle with​​ continuous index s at​​​‌ position x at time​ t. Given a​‌ reference measure ω∈​​𝒫(I)​​​‌ encoding the individual statuses​ of the initial distribution​‌ of agents, we define​​ measure graphons as Cauchy​​​‌ problems of the form​

t μ (​‌ t , x ,​​ s ) + ∇​​​‌ x · v (​ t , μ (​‌ t , · ,​​ · ) , x​​​‌ , s ) μ​ ( t , x​‌ , s ) =​​ 0 ,

with μ​​​‌(0,·​,·)=​‌μ0𝒫​​(I) satisfying​​​‌ πI#μ​0=ω (​‌πI# denoting​​ the projection onto the​​​‌ first marginal), and v​:[0,​‌T]×𝒫​​(I×ℝ​​​‌d)×I​×d is​‌ a non-local velocity field.​​ If the reference measure​​​‌ is given by ω​(s)=​‌1Ni​​=1Nδ​​​‌(iN-​s), one​‌ recovers a discrete particle​​ system of the form​​​‌ (1). On​ the other hand, if​‌ the reference measure is​​ given by the Lebesgue​​​‌ measure dλ on​ I, μ0​‌ models a continuum of​​ agents with evenly distributed​​​‌ weights. The flexibility of​ this modeling approach is​‌ that it can allow​​ us to model situations​​​‌ in which agents are​ given different weights, for​‌ instance ω(s​​)=ψ(​​​‌s)dλ​(s),​‌ for some function ψ​​. It also allows​​​‌ to model a crowd​ composed of leaders and​‌ followers, for instance with​​ ω(s)​​​‌=1N∑​i=1N​‌δ(s-​​iN)+​​​‌dλ(s​). The first​‌ aim of this project,​​ conducted in collaboration with​​​‌ Benoît Bonnet (LAAS-CNRS, Université​ de Toulouse) will be​‌ to prove the well-posedness​​ of such an equation,​​​‌ which is not straightforward​ as we impose no​‌ regularity of the vector​​ field v with respect​​​‌ to the continuous index​ s. We will​‌ also extend this model​​ to describe population transfers,​​ by introducing a source​​​‌ term in the right-hand‌ side.

3.3.3 Analysis of‌​‌ non-local advection-diffusion models for​​ active particles

MUSCLEES permanent​​​‌ members involved: Luca Alasio‌

Systems of self-propelled interacting‌​‌ particles provide an individual-based​​ description of the motion​​​‌ of agents ranging from‌ bacteria to colloidal surfers‌​‌ 143, 167.​​ Different approaches to the​​​‌ derivation of macroscopic equations‌ from particle dynamics have‌​‌ been considered, and the​​ corresponding limit PDEs exhibit​​​‌ a variety of possible‌ structures and behaviours 60‌​‌. This work is​​ concerned with the analytical​​​‌ study of some of‌ the above-mentioned PDE models,‌​‌ focusing on regularity and​​ convergence to stationary states.​​​‌ The simplest example is‌ given by the following‌​‌ non-local advection-diffusion equation:

∂​​ t f + Pe​​​‌ div ( 1 -‌ ρ ) f 𝐞‌​‌ ( θ ) =​​ D e Δ f​​​‌ + θ 2‌ f , 6

where‌​‌ ρ(t,​​x)=∫​​​‌02πf‌(t,x‌​‌,θ)d​​θ is the angle-independent​​​‌ density and 𝐞(‌θ)=(‌​‌cosθ,sin​​θ), with​​​‌ periodic boundary conditions both‌ in the space variable‌​‌ x(0​​,2π)​​​‌2 and the angle‌ variable θ(‌​‌0,2π​​). The constant​​​‌ parameters Pe ℝ‌ and De>‌​‌0 are called the​​ Péclet number and spatial​​​‌ diffusion coefficient, respectively.‌ Further details and a‌​‌ preliminary existence theory can​​ be found in 61​​​‌. In collaboration with‌ Simon Schulz (SNS Pisa)‌​‌ and Jessica Guerand (U.​​ Montpellier), we have proven​​​‌ regularity properties, the Harnack‌ inequality, and exponential convergence‌​‌ to stationary states for​​ weak solutions of equation​​​‌ (6). We‌ apply De Giorgi's method‌​‌ and differentiate the equation​​ with respect to the​​​‌ time variable iteratively to‌ show that weak solutions‌​‌ become smooth away from​​ the initial time. This​​​‌ strategy requires that we‌ obtain improved integrability estimates‌​‌ in order to cater​​ for the presence of​​​‌ the non-local drift. The‌ instantaneous smoothing effect observed‌​‌ for weak solutions is​​ shown to also hold​​​‌ for very weak solutions‌ arising from merely distributional‌​‌ initial data; the proof​​ of this result relies​​​‌ on a uniqueness theorem‌ à la Michel Pierre‌​‌ for low-regularity solutions. The​​ convergence to stationary states​​​‌ is proved using the‌ method of contractive stochastic‌​‌ semigroups (Doeblin–Harris approach), taking​​ advantage of the aforementioned​​​‌ Harnack inequality. This is‌ the first step towards‌​‌ the study of more​​ sophisticated models, for example​​​‌ we are interested in‌ the following:

t‌​‌ f + Pe div​​ ( 1 - ρ​​​‌ ) f 𝐞 (‌ θ ) = D‌​‌ e div ( 1​​ - ρ ) ∇​​​‌ f + f ∇‌ ρ + θ‌​‌ 2 f , 7​​

where the diffusion terms​​​‌ may degenerate to zero.‌ Its microscopic dynamics corresponds‌​‌ to a discrete jump​​ process in position and​​​‌ a continuous Brownian motion‌ in angle. The numerical‌​‌ exploration in 60 shows​​​‌ interesting phase separation effects​ which connote further analytical​‌ challenges.

3.3.4 Analysis of​​ systems with cross-diffusion

MUSCLEES​​​‌ permanent members involved: Luca​ Alasio

Cross-diffusion systems are​‌ related to several models​​ in Mathematical Biology and​​​‌ in Kinetic Theory, for​ example the SKT model​‌ in Population Dynamics 163​​, tumour growth models​​​‌ 73, and multi-species​ agent-based models 33.​‌ In collaboration with M.​​ Bruna, S. Fagioli and​​​‌ S. Schulz, we have​ been studying a family​‌ of PDE systems with​​ dominant degenerate diffusion, plus​​​‌ cross-diffusion and drift terms.​ Existence, uniqueness, stability and​‌ long-time asymptotics for related​​ systems with standard diffusion​​​‌ have been established in​ the literature, however the​‌ case of degenerate diffusion​​ is considerably harder and​​​‌ requires the development of​ new techniques. For example,​‌ a class of systems​​ with degenerate diffusion has​​​‌ been recently studied taking​ advantage of their gradient​‌ flow structure (in the​​ Wasserstein sense) 107,​​​‌ 64. This structural​ condition is not always​‌ satisfied and we aim​​ to develop alternative approaches​​​‌ under less restrictive assumptions.​ This is possible thanks​‌ to the combination of​​ functional analytic techniques (compactness,​​​‌ lower semi-continuity), Lyapunov functionals,​ and fixed point results.​‌ Study of the long-time​​ asymptotics and stationary states​​​‌ is ongoing. The next​ steps include further exploration​‌ of the connections between​​ degenerate-parabolic and hyperbolic systems.​​​‌ Splitting methods constitute a​ promising research direction, leading​‌ to challenging questions on​​ suitable BV estimates for​​​‌ the solution. We also​ consider the behaviour of​‌ solutions when one species​​ is “frozen”, i.e. it​​​‌ does not evolve in​ time. Such species acts​‌ as a spatially heterogeneous​​ obstacle to the evolution​​​‌ of the other components.​ Finally, efficient model comparison​‌ requires new continuous dependence​​ results allowing the study​​​‌ of non-local terms such​ as interaction potentials describing​‌ collective behaviour (in the​​ absence of strong parabolicity).​​​‌

3.4 Axis 4 –​ Mathematical epidemiology

MUSCLEES permanent​‌ members involved: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman,​​ Benoît Perthame

Epidemiology is​​​‌ “the study of the​ spread of diseases, in​‌ space and time, with​​ the objective to trace​​​‌ factors that are responsible​ for, or contribute to,​‌ their occurrence" 80.​​ We address here this​​​‌ issue with a specific​ control-theoretic flavor: we are​‌ interested not only on​​ modeling of infectious diseases​​​‌ 42, 110,​ 59, but also​‌ control and observation issues.​​ Two different directions of​​​‌ research are developed below,​ corresponding to the two​‌ topics described in Section​​ 4.3.

3.4.1 Vector-borne​​​‌ diseases

MUSCLEES permanent members​ involved: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman, Benoît​‌ Perthame

Modeling, analysis and​​ control design of release​​​‌ strategies in metapopulation setting​

In order to take​‌ into account the disturbing​​ effects of migration of​​​‌ mosquitoes between treated and​ untreated areas, we plan​‌ to study multi-site configurations,​​ in meta-population approach. A​​​‌ meta-population is `a set​ of local populations within​‌ some larger area, where​​ typically migration, from one​​​‌ local population to at​ least some other patches,​‌ is possible' 103.​​ The meta-population models are​​​‌ systems of differential equations​ defined on graphs whose​‌ vertices represent the different​​ patches, and whose edges​​ specify the population transfers​​​‌ 44. So far,‌ such setting has been‌​‌ used mainly to model​​ human movements 48,​​​‌ 57, the latter‌ being usually responsible for‌​‌ disease transport at a​​ much greater distance than​​​‌ mosquitoes. While most studies‌ focus on the analysis‌​‌ of epidemiological models according​​ to the values of​​​‌ their parameters, fewer study‌ the issues related to‌​‌ disease control through elaborated​​ actions, specified through either​​​‌ open- or closed-loop (i.e.‌ based on measurement) strategies.‌​‌ We will adopt this​​ perspective to define effective​​​‌ methods of release of‌ sterile males, or of‌​‌ mosquitoes infected on purpose​​ by the bacterium Wolbachia​​​‌.

We consider a‌ class of controlled meta-population‌​‌ models under the general​​ form

x ˙ i​​​‌ = F i (‌ x i , x‌​‌ S , i )​​ x i - (​​​‌ ( L I‌ ) x ) i‌​‌ + m i (​​ t ) , x​​​‌ ˙ S , i‌ = Λ i (‌​‌ t ) + F​​ S , i (​​​‌ x i , x‌ S , i )‌​‌ x i - (​​ ( L S ⊗​​​‌ I ) x S‌ ) i + m‌​‌ S , i (​​ t ) , 8​​​‌

i=1,‌,n.‌​‌ For studying e.g. the​​ Sterile Insect Technique (see​​​‌ 56), xi‌ and xS,‌​‌i are vectors whose​​ components represent the numbers​​​‌ of wild and sterile‌ mosquitoes in the patch‌​‌ i, according to​​ their sex and life​​​‌ stage. The matrix-valued functions‌ Fi,F‌​‌S,i represent​​ globally the birth and​​​‌ death processes as they‌ occur locally in patch‌​‌ i, including the​​ effects of interaction between​​​‌ the two populations (during‌ mating and early development),‌​‌ which allows to envision​​ reduction or extinction of​​​‌ the targeted population. The‌ n×n-matrices‌​‌ L,LS​​ are Laplacian matrices that​​​‌ model the displacement of‌ the mosquitoes from one‌​‌ patch to the others,​​ and external migrations are​​​‌ modeled as additive perturbations‌ mi,m‌​‌S,i.​​

The rate of release​​​‌ of sterile males in‌ patch i per time‌​‌ unit is Λi​​(t)≥​​​‌0. Generally speaking,‌ our objective is to‌​‌ derive release strategies ensuring​​ elimination or control of​​​‌ the population under certain‌ level in some of‌​‌ the targeted patches, and​​ fulfilling adequate constraints (due​​​‌ e.g. to limited production‌ rate). This amounts to‌​‌ determine the number of​​ sterile males to release​​​‌ in these specific subdomains,‌ but also possibly in‌​‌ connected subdomains playing the​​ role of `buffer zones'.​​​‌ The basic reproduction number,‌ which must be kept‌​‌ low to avoid epidemic​​ burst, is related to​​​‌ the linearized behavior of‌ the system in the‌​‌ vicinity of the disease-free​​ trajectory. Seeing migration as​​​‌ a structured perturbation of‌ this linear system, we‌​‌ intend to analyze the​​ robustness of thresholds defined​​​‌ based on this number,‌ and to propose control‌​‌ laws aiming at allocating​​​‌ the releases in a​ complex, heterogeneous, metapopulation model,​‌ so that they reduce​​ the epidemiological risk in​​​‌ the worst perturbation configuration.​ We plan to exploit​‌ the peculiarities of the​​ positive systems to tackle​​​‌ these robust control issues​ 164, 93,​‌ 72.

Optimization of​​ killing and replacement policies​​​‌ in heterogeneous contexts

Most​ mathematical modeling of killing​‌ and replacement strategies, as​​ the use of the​​​‌ bacterium Wolbachia, focus​ on spatially homogeneous systems​‌ and propose to model​​ the time dynamics of​​​‌ mosquito populations thanks to​ the study of differential​‌ systems. In this setting,​​ the influence of the​​​‌ releases on the time​ dynamics of mosquito populations​‌ has already been extensively​​ studied (see e.g. 39​​​‌ for SIT (Sterile Insect​ Technique) and 99,​‌ 97 for replacement strategy​​ by Wolbachia). However,​​​‌ for practical applications, it​ is important to take​‌ into account the space​​ variables and other phenomena​​​‌ like seasonality, heterogeneities, migration...​ Moreover, the use of​‌ optimal control theory in​​ coordination with actors in​​​‌ the field should be​ very interesting to improve​‌ the efficiency of the​​ strategies and to minimize​​​‌ their cost.

The study​ of the dynamics taking​‌ into account the spatial​​ variable has started only​​​‌ recently. For the replacement​ strategy a first simple​‌ model of the spatial​​ spread of Wolbachia was​​​‌ proposed by Barton &​ Turelli in 52.​‌ In their simplified approach,​​ the total population is​​​‌ assumed to be constant​ and the dynamics of​‌ the proportion of infected​​ mosquitoes u[​​​‌0,1]​ is governed by a​‌ bistable reaction-diffusion equation. Using​​ such a simple one-dimensional​​​‌ model, a first attempt​ to study the influence​‌ of spatial heterogeneities in​​ the spread has been​​​‌ proposed in 137;​ in particular, it has​‌ been proved that strong​​ variations in the densities​​​‌ of wild mosquitoes, due​ for instance to vegetation,​‌ may block replacement. Up​​ to our knowledge this​​​‌ is the only study​ of this kind for​‌ replacement strategy.

Our aim​​ here is to perform​​​‌ well-fitted killing or sterile​ insect strategies so that​‌ blocking phenomenon occurs. In​​ a mathematical language, we​​​‌ consider the following bistable​ reaction-diffusion equation

t​‌ u - x​​ x u = g​​​‌ ( u ) -​ μ ( x )​‌ u 1 0 <​​ x < L in​​​‌ ( 0 , ∞​ ) × 9​‌

where g is a​​ bistable reaction term (such​​​‌ as g(u​):=u​‌(1-u​​)(u-​​​‌θ) for example),​ and the killing term​‌ μ(x)​​10<x​​​‌<L represents a​ killing strategy with a​‌ rate μ(x​​) over (0​​​‌,L).​

When μ(x​‌)=C is​​ constant over (0​​​‌,L),​ it has been proved​‌ in 38 that if​​ C is large enough,​​​‌ that is, if one​ performs a sufficiently sharp​‌ killing strategy in a​​ localized area, then there​​ exists a heteroclinic steady​​​‌ state connecting 1 to‌ 0, that is, a‌​‌ blocking phenomenon occurs. We​​ then have two questions​​​‌ that come up very‌ naturally : one concerning‌​‌ how to optimize this​​ strategy, and a second​​​‌ concerning how to extend‌ these results to higher‌​‌ dimensions.

In particular the​​ two-dimensional problem is very​​​‌ relevant for field interventions‌ where one would have‌​‌ to protect a certain​​ area (e.g. a village)​​​‌ from a wave of‌ mosquitoes arriving from an‌​‌ infected area (e.g. a​​ swamp). Beyond the construction​​​‌ of a static barrier‌ in the two-dimensional setting,‌​‌ it would be interesting​​ to show the effectiveness​​​‌ of a rolling carpet‌ strategy (generalizing the results‌​‌ of 38) to​​ expand a mosquito free​​​‌ area and progressively clear‌ the mosquito population in‌​‌ a region (for instance​​ a whole island or​​​‌ a pre-defined intervention region).‌

In order to optimize‌​‌ the killing strategies, we​​ need to determine what​​​‌ is the best μ‌, among the class‌​‌ of admissible death rates​​ satisfying 0μ​​​‌C, guaranteeing‌ the existence of a‌​‌ heteroclinic solution connecting 0​​ to 1, and with​​​‌ minimal integral 0‌Lμ? Does‌​‌ it exist? Is it​​ "bang-bang" (that is, μ​​​‌=0 or C‌ almost everywhere)? This problem‌​‌ has recently been solved​​ when there is no​​​‌ constraint on the support‌ (that is, L=‌​‌+) in​​ 30. We want​​​‌ to address it when‌ L<+∞‌​‌ and with direct methods,​​ enabling us to consider​​​‌ more general dependence with‌ respect to the growth‌​‌ rate.

In a second​​ step, we would like​​​‌ to optimize the sterile‌ male strategy. The mathematical‌​‌ model for this strategy​​ is

t u​​​‌ - x x‌ u = u u‌​‌ + μ ( x​​ ) 1 0 <​​​‌ x < L g‌ ( u ) in‌​‌ ( 0 , ∞​​ ) × ,​​​‌ 10

that is, μ‌(x) represents‌​‌ our input of sterile​​ males, that decreases the​​​‌ fecundity.

We aim at‌ using our recent progress‌​‌ on similar topics in​​ order to solve these​​​‌ questions 91, 127‌, 138.

Optimisation‌​‌ of release strategies in​​ time-varying setting - seasonality​​​‌

We now want to‌ take into account seasonality‌​‌ (i.e. rainfall, humidity and​​ temperature variations) in our​​​‌ models, since it is‌ known to play a‌​‌ key role in the​​ dynamics of mosquito populations.​​​‌

Some weather dependent mosquito‌ models have been developed,‌​‌ mainly with Temperature-dependent parameters​​ (see for instance 90​​​‌, 66 and references‌ therein) and very few‌​‌ with temperature and rainfall-dependent​​ parameters (see 169 and​​​‌ references therein). However, in‌ general, these last models‌​‌ are quite complex: they​​ relied on statistical approaches,​​​‌ and on the user's‌ subjective choices, such that‌​‌ the calibration (of many​​ parameters), with respect to​​​‌ the environmental parameters, is‌ not generic and might‌​‌ not be able to​​ provide a unique set​​​‌ of valuable values. We‌ firmly believe that simple‌​‌ (but not too simple)​​​‌ models can rapidly provide​ useful and reliable information​‌ to help field experts​​ to manage vector control​​​‌ campaigns.

We will first​ adapt the Barton-Turelli model​‌ 52 in order to​​ take into account seasonality​​​‌ effects. This leads to​ the equation

u t​‌ - u x x​​ = μ ( t​​​‌ ) g ( u​ ) ,

where g​‌ is a bistable reaction​​ term and μ is​​​‌ T-periodic and​ positive. Alikakos, Bates and​‌ Chen 36 proved the​​ existence and attractivity of​​​‌ pulsating traveling waves, that​ is, time-global solutions of​‌ the form u(​​t,x)​​​‌=U(x​-ct,​‌t) with U​​(-,​​​‌t)=1​, U(+​‌,t)​​=0, and​​​‌ tU(​z,t)​‌ is T-periodic​​ for all z∈​​​‌, under some​ hypothesis on the non-existence​‌ and stability of intermediate​​ steady states, that we​​​‌ believed to be satisfied​ in our framework.

Ding​‌ and Matano 83,​​ 82 recently proved that​​​‌ the solutions of the​ Cauchy problem always converges​‌ as t+​​ for compactly supported​​​‌ initial data. Moreover, Polacik​ described further 151 the​‌ basins of attraction of​​ the steady states. Namely,​​​‌ consider an initial datum​ 1[-L​‌,L] at​​ time t0 (more​​​‌ general families of initial​ data could be considered),​‌ then there exists a​​ critical size L=​​​‌L*(t​0) such that​‌ the solution of the​​ Cauchy problem converges to​​​‌ 1 at large times​ if L>L​‌*(t0​​), while it​​​‌ converges to 0 if​ L<L*​‌(t0)​​.

We will then​​​‌ investigate the dependence of​ this critical size L​‌*(t0​​) with respect to​​​‌ t0 and try​ to characterize the best​‌ time of the year​​ to release Wolbachia infected​​​‌ mosquitoes, that is, the​ t0 minimizing L​‌*(t0​​). This is​​​‌ a difficult problem, since​ L*(t​‌0) is defined​​ implicitly. First, we believe​​​‌ we could characterize the​ quantity L*(​‌t0) through​​ some adjoint function by​​​‌ using some Pontryagin maximum​ principle style arguments. Second,​‌ such a characterization might​​ help to construct a​​​‌ relevant algorithm in order​ to investigate this problem​‌ numerically. Lastly, we could​​ investigate the following related​​​‌ problem: maximize ℝ​u(t0​‌+T,x​​)dx with​​​‌ respect to u(​t0) in​‌ a given class of​​ functions. This problem has​​​‌ been addressed in the​ homogeneous framework by Nadin​‌ and Toledo 138.​​

3.4.2 Infectious diseases

MUSCLEES​​​‌ permanent members involved: Pierre-Alexandre​ Bliman

Using reinfections for​‌ identifiability and observability

While​​ the loss of immunity​​​‌ has been modeled and​ studied in the framework​‌ of compartmental models, the​​ phenomena of reinfection, and​​ particularly the counting of​​​‌ the number of reinfections,‌ have been little studied‌​‌ to date. Dynamics induced​​ by reinfections with different​​​‌ strains 43, 31‌, in presence of‌​‌ vaccination of incomplete eficiency​​ 45 or with partial​​​‌ and temporary immunity 102‌ have been studied. A‌​‌ modified SIRS system was​​ proposed in 109 with​​​‌ an infinite set of‌ differential equations capable of‌​‌ counting the number of​​ reinfections, that we extended​​​‌ and studied in 96‌1. In the‌​‌ simple case of an​​ SIS model, this consists​​​‌ in `unfolding' the system‌

S ˙ = μ‌​‌ N - β S​​ I N + γ​​​‌ I - μ S‌ , I ˙ =‌​‌ β S I N​​ - ( γ +​​​‌ μ ) I ,‌ 11

where N(‌​‌t) represents the​​ total population S(​​​‌t)+I‌(t),‌​‌ in

S ˙ i​​ = γ I i​​​‌ - 1 - β‌ S i I N‌​‌ - μ S i​​ , I ˙ i​​​‌ = β S i‌ I N - (‌​‌ γ + μ )​​ I i , i​​​‌ 1 , 12‌

with here I(‌​‌t):=​​i1​​​‌Ii(t‌), N(‌​‌t):=​​i1​​​‌(Si(‌t)+I‌​‌i(t)​​) and by convention​​​‌ γR0(‌t):=‌​‌μN(t​​). This `microscopic'​​​‌ interpretation of the `macroscopic'‌ behavior in (11‌​‌) keeps track of​​ the number of reinfections,​​​‌ accounted for by the‌ index i.

We‌​‌ have shown 96 that​​ revealing this underlying structure​​​‌ allows to access many‌ information on the structure‌​‌ of the infection numbers​​ in the population at​​​‌ endemic equilibrium, and enriches‌ drastically the capacity to‌​‌ identify and observe system​​ (11). Our​​​‌ plan is to extend‌ this work and study‌​‌ the effects of disease​​ characteristics (susceptibility, infectivity, waning​​​‌ immunity...) depending upon the‌ past number of infections,‌​‌ on the dynamics of​​ the epidemics. In particular,​​​‌ one is interested in‌ understanding what knowledge on‌​‌ these quantities can be​​ gained by appropriate measurements.​​​‌ This topic is part‌ of a more general‌​‌ reflection that we intend​​ to pursue, on the​​​‌ observability and identifiability issues‌ in epidemiology. Seroprevalence data‌​‌ are other nonstandard data​​ of which we plan​​​‌ to study the benefit.‌

Multi-strain problems: modelling and‌​‌ analysis

The Covid-19 pandemic​​ has revived, by enriching​​​‌ and renewing them, many‌ questions relating to understanding‌​‌ the dynamics of infectious​​ diseases and the means​​​‌ of combating them 85‌. Rapidly, the evolution‌​‌ of the pandemic has​​ been shaped by two​​​‌ different phenomena: the appearance‌ of variant viruses competing‌​‌ with the `historic' virus;​​ and the progress of​​​‌ the vaccination campaigns. We‌ are interested here in‌​‌ analyzing the corresponding dynamics.​​ Related contributions have been​​​‌ published before the appearance‌ of Covid-19, seeking to‌​‌ characterize endemic behavior in​​​‌ long time 108,​ 141, 51.​‌ The first contributions published​​ after the emergence of​​​‌ Covid-19 100, 47​ (see also 139)​‌ consider, on the contrary,​​ the shorter time scale​​​‌ of an epidemic episode,​ but describe incompletely the​‌ complex cross-immunity (complete or​​ partial, permanent or transient)​​​‌ which however seems crucial.​

We will also be​‌ interested by the interplay​​ of vaccination. Usually the​​​‌ influence of the latter​ is considered on the​‌ long duration of an​​ endemic infection 45,​​​‌ 58. On the​ contrary, our approach here​‌ will be oriented towards​​ the control of an​​​‌ epidemic outbreak. Drawing inspiration​ from the current pandemic,​‌ we will consider a​​ vaccine providing an immunity​​​‌ different for every strain​ of infection, as well​‌ as the possibility of​​ a waning protection.

We​​​‌ will also be interested​ by heterogeneous population models​‌ 87, structured in​​ susceptibility and/or infectivity, or​​​‌ in number of individual​ contacts (for example from​‌ models of `effective contacts',​​ see 130).

Modelling​​​‌ and analysis issues of​ the commutations in complex​‌ urban environments

Modeling in​​ pertinent and efficient way​​​‌ how the spread of​ an infection is influenced​‌ and shaped by the​​ fact that the effective​​​‌ individuals are in fact​ individualized, is a considerable​‌ issue in mathematical epidemiology.​​ The basic deterministic compartmental​​​‌ models, like the SIR​ model, take the step​‌ to consider homogeneous, perfectly​​ mixed, populations, where the​​​‌ probability of encounter between​ two individuals is uniform.​‌ This `gas theory model'​​ is simple, but unrealistic​​​‌ when the size or​ the spatial extension of​‌ the population is large​​ (which is precisely the​​​‌ assumptions permitting to consider​ deterministic models rather than​‌ stochastic ones...). Heterogeneity cannot​​ be ignored.

Alternative points​​​‌ of view exist 110​, 46, 44​‌, which basically transfer​​ the homogeneity and perfect-mixing​​​‌ assumption to sub-populations, defined​ by some structuring trait,​‌ e.g. their age, susceptibility,​​ infectiousness, contact numbers, place​​​‌ of residence, etc. Adopting​ such point of view​‌ amounts in fact to​​ consider perfect mixing of​​​‌ homogeneous sub-populations.

We are​ particularly interested here in​‌ how to render mobility​​, typically urban mobility,​​​‌ whose regular patterns aggregate​ various characteristics, e.g. social​‌ class, age, residence... Usually,​​ modelling mobility is done​​​‌ through an Eulerian description:​ infection is described in​‌ every location, with sub-populations​​ transferred from other places,​​​‌ leading to meta-population setting​ much in the spirit​‌ of (8)​​ (but with only host​​​‌ population). This makes it​ complicated to follow the​‌ individuals of a given​​ group along their displacements,​​​‌ once they have been​ mixed with other groups.​‌ To have this ability,​​ it is natural to​​​‌ consider the groups of​ individuals with a given​‌ infectious status that come​​ from location i and​​​‌ are present at location​ j at time t​‌. This is indeed​​ neither simple, nor economical.​​​‌

In fact a Lagrangian​ setting seems more natural.​‌ We will adopt this​​ view, and focus on​​​‌ the description, and the​ analysis, of epidemic spread​‌ during the perfect mixing​​ of different homogeneous classes​​ of the population, indexed​​​‌ by p𝒫‌. The displacements of‌​‌ any class p∈​​𝒫, are now​​​‌ integrally described by a‌ function lp(‌​‌t) that give​​ the location of sub-population​​​‌ p at time t‌, and each class‌​‌ then evolves according to​​ the presence of the​​​‌ other sub-populations present together‌ at the same point,‌​‌ with whom cross-infection is​​ possible. The effective location​​​‌ of their encounter is‌ quite abstract: physically, it‌​‌ may be as well​​ a public transport system.​​​‌

We want to compare‌ the complexity of the‌​‌ different modelling settings and​​ achieve comparative study of​​​‌ their behavior, with regard‌ to the value of‌​‌ the basic offspring number,​​ the epidemic final size,​​​‌ the level of endemic‌ equilibrium and so on.‌​‌

3.5 Axis 5 –​​ Development and analysis of​​​‌ mathematical models for living‌ systems confronted with experimental‌​‌ data

MUSCLEES permanent members​​ involved: Luca Alasio, Sophie​​​‌ Hecht, Diane Peurichard, Nastassia‌ Pouradier Duteil

3.5.1 Individual-based‌​‌ models for micro-colony growth​​

MUSCLEES permanent members involved:​​​‌ Sophie Hecht, Diane Peurichard‌

Individual-based models allow the‌​‌ description of a population​​ at the microscopic level.​​​‌ These models consider each‌ particle as autonomous entities‌​‌ and define their dynamics​​ according to their local​​​‌ environments. For this reason‌ it is an ideal‌​‌ tool to confront mathematical​​ models and experimental data.​​​‌ In a previous work‌ 89, we have‌​‌ developed a model to​​ study growth of micro-colonies​​​‌ of elongated bacteria such‌ as E. coli. In‌​‌ this paper, bacteria are​​ represented by sphero-cylinders characterized​​​‌ by their length, their‌ orientation and the position‌​‌ of their center of​​ mass. The motion of​​​‌ bacteria is supposed to‌ be only due to‌​‌ steric interaction with their​​ close neighbors to prevent​​​‌ the overlapping of cells‌ during growth and division‌​‌ (passive motion). This repulsion​​ is realized via a​​​‌ potential based on Hertzian‌ theory. Fragmentation occurs when‌​‌ the increment of length​​ of a bacteria reaches​​​‌ a given threshold, distributed‌ according to an experimental‌​‌ law. A key aspect​​ of the paper is​​​‌ to propose a model‌ taking into account asymmetric‌​‌ friction and a non-uniform​​ distribution of mass along​​​‌ the length of bacteria,‌ which impact the movement‌​‌ of particles. These two​​ mechanisms were shown to​​​‌ improve significantly the comparison‌ between experimental data and‌​‌ numerical simulations, yet we​​ failed to reproduce one​​​‌ of the primordial characteristics‌ such as the high‌​‌ density of bacteria in​​ the microcolony (where all​​​‌ the space within the‌ convex envelope of the‌​‌ colony seems occupied). This​​ property is not reproduced​​​‌ to date in the‌ models proposed in the‌​‌ literature 89, 92​​.

A discussion with​​​‌ the experimenter Nicolas Desprat‌ (ABCD biophysics Lab -‌​‌ ENS) highlighted the possible​​ impact of the deformation​​​‌ of bacteria in a‌ micro-colony. After observation, it‌​‌ appears that at the​​ point of inflexion in​​​‌ the colony, bacteria are‌ often curved. The small‌​‌ deformation observed could be​​ the key to the​​​‌ dense character of the‌ colonies and modify their‌​‌ global organisations. It is​​​‌ therefore interesting to consider​ the deformable character of​‌ bacteria in order to​​ best reproduce the organization​​​‌ observed experimentally. To do​ this, many approaches are​‌ possible 106, 129​​. We will consider​​​‌ an individual-based model where​ each bacterium is modeled​‌ by a string of​​ spheres linked with spring​​​‌ and angular spring. This​ description will allow local​‌ bending for the bacterium.​​ We will then test​​​‌ different modelling assumptions in​ order to reproduced as​‌ close as possible observed​​ phenomena during the micro-colony​​​‌ growth.

After deriving the​ new model, we will​‌ study the influence of​​ the different parameters and​​​‌ compare numerical simulations with​ experimental data. This work​‌ will be a collaboration​​ with the biophysics laboratory​​​‌ of Nicolas Desprat, giving​ us access to datasets​‌ of micro-colony of strains​​ of Escherichia coli and​​​‌ Pseudomonas aeruginous growing between​ glass and agarose. On​‌ these datasets, segmentation has​​ been previously performed to​​​‌ track individual bacteria as​ spherocylinder. However, the purpose​‌ of this study requires​​ to identify bacteria as​​​‌ deformable solids. Thus, a​ first step to compare​‌ experimental data to numerical​​ simulations will be to​​​‌ develop new segmentation process,​ adapting techniques existing for​‌ clustered nuclei. In a​​ second part, the comparison​​​‌ will require the development​ of new tools to​‌ better quantify the evolution​​ of the colony. Among​​​‌ the quantifiers we found​ to study the growth​‌ of bacterial structure, we​​ found the one related​​​‌ to the shape of​ the colony. In the​‌ literature, the quantifiers used​​ to characterize the shape​​​‌ often consist in comparing​ the colony to an​‌ ellipse. However, the colonies,​​ although elongated, have shapes​​​‌ that are not necessarily​ ellipsoidal. To develop a​‌ new sophisticated quantifier an​​ idea is to consider​​​‌ the modes of the​ elliptical Fourier transform of​‌ the envelope of a​​ colony in order to​​​‌ characterize its shape 176​. Similar work will​‌ be done on other​​ quantifiers characterising the local​​​‌ organisation, bending, four cell​ array arrangement, etc...

3.5.2​‌ Energy-driven models of tissue​​ organisation and architecture

MUSCLEES​​​‌ permanent members involved: Sophie​ Hecht, Diane Peurichard

This​‌ research axis is in​​ the frame of a​​​‌ long standing collaboration with​ a team of biologists​‌ from RESTORE (Toulouse), which​​ led to the ANR​​​‌ grant ENERGENCE (2023-2026) recently​ awarded to D. Peurichard.​‌ The goal here is​​ to propose a general​​​‌ framework to understand the​ combined role of mechanics​‌ and energy exchanges in​​ tissue development, repair and​​​‌ decline. To our knowledge,​ very few mathematical models​‌ have been proposed for​​ tissue organization combining both​​​‌ energetical and mechanical interactions,​ while numerous evidences suggest​‌ that energy exchanges and​​ mechanical forces can feedback​​​‌ on each other at​ different stages of tissue​‌ life, and that large​​ perturbations of one or​​​‌ the other are associated​ with degeneration and diseases.​‌ Therefore, we propose to​​ build a complete framework​​​‌ to theoretically and numerically​ model the complex interplay​‌ between energy and mechanics​​ at different spatiotemporal scales.​​​‌ We will focus on​ adipose tissue (AT) as​‌ a relevant biological model​​ because its architecture is​​ relatively simple and largely​​​‌ dependent on energy exchanges‌ (food supplies), and as‌​‌ a target with the​​ world-wide development of obesity’s​​​‌ epidemic.

This project will‌ rely on a synthetic‌​‌ approach based on a​​ dual use of mathematical​​​‌ modelling and in-vitro/in-vivo experiments.‌ We will propose a‌​‌ new view of biological​​ tissues as complex ecological/social​​​‌ systems whose architecture emergence‌ is driven by few‌​‌ key determinants, interacting together​​ mechanically and constantly exchanging​​​‌ energy/matter with their environment.‌ We will aim to‌​‌ first develop individual-based models​​ (IBM), which promises exciting​​​‌ theoretical and experimental challenges‌ such as the determination‌​‌ of complex feedback loops​​ between energy intakes and​​​‌ local growth laws, and‌ the study of metastable‌​‌ states and phase transitions​​ applied to changes in​​​‌ energy fluxes, modelling cafeteria‌ diet and food deprivation.‌​‌ The biological calibration of​​ the IBM via in​​​‌ vitro and in vivo‌ experiments (performed at the‌​‌ RESTORE lab) will go​​ through determining how energy​​​‌ is distributed among the‌ different agents and their‌​‌ interactions. A user-friendly interface​​ will also be developed​​​‌ based on the IBM‌ and will be used‌​‌ to resolve some unsolved​​ questions such as how​​​‌ the AT architecture is‌ modified by the amplitude,‌​‌ frequency and length of​​ energy intake modifications.

In​​​‌ a second aspect of‌ the ENERGENCE project, we‌​‌ will tackle the important​​ challenges contained in the​​​‌ derivation of a Continuum‌ Model (CM) from our‌​‌ IBM, in order to​​ obtain a computationally efficient​​​‌ CM containing as much‌ as possible the mechanisms‌​‌ of the microscale. Numerous​​ technical and conceptual barriers​​​‌ will have to be‌ lifted in this more‌​‌ theoretical part of the​​ project, due to the​​​‌ nature of our IBM,‌ the presence of correlations‌​‌ between the agents at​​ the microscale and the​​​‌ complex mechanical and energetical‌ feedback loops. If successful,‌​‌ this model will be​​ the first continuum description​​​‌ of two immiscible fluids‌ composed of cells and‌​‌ (anisotropic) fiber elements obtained​​ from an agent-based description,​​​‌ and promises exciting new‌ and invaluable insights into‌​‌ how specific microscopic effects​​ translate at the macroscale.​​​‌ Our CM will rely‌ on the complete and‌​‌ valid IBM and, if​​ successful, will enable to​​​‌ study the interplay between‌ energy balance and whole‌​‌ tissue architecture during a​​ lifespan and at the​​​‌ organ scale (long-term and‌ large-scale effects).

The impacts‌​‌ of the highly interdisciplinary​​ ANR project ENERGENCE are​​​‌ twofold. On the biological‌ viewpoint, the energy/mechanics coupling‌​‌ view of tissue emergence​​ and changes will provide​​​‌ a new understanding of‌ aging at different spatio-temporal‌​‌ scales that will pave​​ the way for new​​​‌ rejuvenative therapies to treat‌ age-related dysfunctions, and also‌​‌ impact the tissue engineering​​ field in which metabolism​​​‌ remains often overlooked. On‌ the mathematical viewpoint, the‌​‌ ENERGENCE project will provide​​ involved numerical treatments and​​​‌ innovative sensitivity analysis methods‌ for IBM, and tackle‌​‌ important theoretical challenges related​​ to the derivation of​​​‌ continuous biphasic fluid models‌ from IBM, promising exciting‌​‌ new understanding of the​​ micro- macro- link. Although​​​‌ focused on adipose tissue,‌ the theory and the‌​‌ mathematical modelling developed in​​​‌ this project will be​ general enough to apply​‌ to other biological systems​​ such as muscle tissues​​​‌ and, if successful, will​ constitute the basis for​‌ collaborations with other European​​ research teams through the​​​‌ building of an ERC​ Synergy.

The ENERGENCE project​‌ involves several members of​​ our project team MUSCLEES​​​‌ and will be completely​ integrated in the team​‌ activities: the development and​​ parametric analysis of Agent-Based​​​‌ Models will rely on​ the expertise of S.​‌ Hecht together with D.​​ Peurichard, the challenges of​​​‌ deriving PDE models from​ IBM will be completely​‌ integrated in Axis 1​​ of the team (together​​​‌ with S. Hecht, N.​ Pouradier-Duteil, B. Perthame), and​‌ the analysis of the​​ resulting PDE models will​​​‌ be enriched by the​ results of the team​‌ in Axes 2 and​​ 3. By combining biological​​​‌ experiments and mathematical modelling​ to study the multi-scale​‌ and temporal effects of​​ metabolism and mechanics, the​​​‌ ENERGENCE project will be​ one of the most​‌ applicative activities of MUSCLEES,​​ and, if successful, will​​​‌ represent a significant step​ forward to understand the​‌ emergence of metastable organized​​ structures in living matter.​​​‌

3.5.3 A traffic model​ for the interkinetic nuclear​‌ migration (IKNM)

MUSCLEES permanent​​ members involved: Sophie Hecht​​​‌

In the past years,​ members of MUSCLEES have​‌ studied the cell cycle​​ with age structured transport​​​‌ equations 68, 55​. These models considered​‌ the transition between the​​ different phases of the​​​‌ cell cycle depending of​ the cell age. However,​‌ recent works 104 have​​ highlighted that the transition​​​‌ between these phases are​ likely to be impacted​‌ by the moving positions​​ of the nuclei. Thus,​​​‌ we will introduce a​ space structured model in​‌ order to consider the​​ influence of the movement​​​‌ of nuclei on the​ cell cycle and its​‌ transition.

As mentioned in​​ section 4.2, in​​​‌ pseudo-stratified epithelium, nuclei undergo​ IKNM during the cell​‌ cycle. Namely, nuclei in​​ the phase G2 move​​​‌ toward the apical membrane​ to divide while nuclei​‌ in G1 move in​​ the opposite direction to​​​‌ return in the depth​ of the tissue. The​‌ nuclei in S do​​ not have a clear​​​‌ direction in their motion.​ This phenomenon can be​‌ viewed as a one-dimensional​​ traffic problem. Therefore we​​​‌ will model this system​ with a 3 species,​‌ bidirectional PDE system. The​​ transition between the phases​​​‌ will be modeled by​ reaction terms and boundary​‌ conditions. We will study​​ the new system of​​​‌ equations and answer the​ classical question of existence​‌ and uniqueness. Additionally we​​ will focus on the​​​‌ long time behaviour, understanding​ the range of parameters​‌ leading to a slowdown​​ of growth with realistic​​​‌ distributions of the nuclei​ in the different cell​‌ phases.

The model will​​ be compared to experimental​​​‌ data provided by Jean-Paul​ Vincent's laboratory in the​‌ Francis Crick Institute (Epithelial​​ Cell Interactions Laboratory). Existing​​​‌ data of the distribution​ of the nuclei in​‌ the different phases in​​ the apical/basal axis at​​​‌ different times of development​ will allow to tune​‌ the different parameters of​​ the model. The model​​ will then allow us​​​‌ to test hypothesis proposed‌ in a previous work‌​‌ 104 where we developed​​ a microscopic model. In​​​‌ this paper, we conjectured‌ a mechanism to explain‌​‌ the transition between G1​​ and S phase but​​​‌ were limited in the‌ test due to the‌​‌ small number of nuclei​​ we could consider due​​​‌ to computational cost. The‌ new model we proposed‌​‌ would allow a further​​ study of the influence​​​‌ of this mechanism.

3.5.4‌ Models for collective behavior‌​‌ in gregarious fish

MUSCLEES​​ permanent members involved: Nastassia​​​‌ Pouradier Duteil

Many living‌ systems exhibit fascinating dynamics‌​‌ of collective behavior during​​ locomotion, from bacterial colonies​​​‌ to human crowds. The‌ emergence of such complex‌​‌ spatio-temporal patterns can be​​ described using local, short-range​​​‌ interactions between nearest neighbours.‌ Fish schools are a‌​‌ typical example of this​​ kind of self-organization: in​​​‌ order to perceive the‌ position or kinematics of‌​‌ close neighbors, fish rely​​ essentially on vision and​​​‌ sensing of hydrodynamic disturbances.‌ However, the role of‌​‌ each of these senses​​ is not clearly elucidated​​​‌ today. Our objective is‌ to model the visual‌​‌ interaction within a group​​ of animals experiencing a​​​‌ dynamic visual disturbance (temporal‌ variation of the ambient‌​‌ light intensity). Previous experiments​​ have revealed a correlation​​​‌ between illumination and group‌ cohesion, measured in terms‌​‌ of geometric parameters (polarization,​​ rotational moment, nearest-neighbour distance).​​​‌

In collaboration with a‌ team of experimental physicists‌​‌ of the PMMH laboratory​​ of ESPCI and Sorbonne​​​‌ University, we aim to‌ study this behaviour using‌​‌ mathematical models of collective​​ motion. Numerical simulations could​​​‌ elucidate the influence of‌ illumination on the field‌​‌ of view of the​​ fish (distance or angle​​​‌ of the cone of‌ vision), and the role‌​‌ of density in the​​ emergence or not of​​​‌ strong rotational motion when‌ increasing light intensity. The‌​‌ model used will be​​ a variation of the​​​‌ Persistant Turning Walker model,‌ a system of coupled‌​‌ ordinary differential equations in​​ which each fish's angular​​​‌ velocity evolves in time‌ due to alignement with‌​‌ its closest neighbors, attraction​​ towards the group, and​​​‌ random perturbations.

3.5.5 Mathematical‌ models of retinal biochemistry‌​‌

MUSCLEES permanent members involved:​​ Luca Alasio, Benoît Perthame,​​​‌ Philippe Robert

Modelling the‌ canonical visual cycle.

The‌​‌ visual cycle is the​​ process allowing rod cells​​​‌ to return to the‌ dark state after exposure‌​‌ to light. The main​​ biochemical contributors are: (1)​​​‌ isomers of vitamin A‌, which is the‌​‌ essential photosensitive molecules 113​​. They interact with​​​‌ RPE enzymes and they‌ are transported back to‌​‌ the rod, where they​​ recombine with opsins; (2)​​​‌ rhodopsins (densely packed membrane‌ proteins), consist of an‌​‌ opsin, embedded in the​​ lipid bilayer of cell​​​‌ membranes, forming a pocket‌ where vitamin A lies;‌​‌ all-trans retinal dissociates after​​ photo-excitation 136; (3)​​​‌ enzymes, binding proteins and‌ membrane transporters responsible for‌​‌ the main steps of​​ the visual cycle (further​​​‌ details in 113).‌ The current “gold standard”‌​‌ in terms of mathematical​​ description of the visual​​​‌ cycle was established in‌ 115, where Lamb‌​‌ and Pugh derived a​​​‌ simplified ODE system for​ the evolution of the​‌ concentration of rhodopsin. The​​ only two unknowns in​​​‌ their model are total​ concentrations of opsin and​‌ of 11-cis-retinal (no space​​ dependence). The specific geometry​​​‌ of photoreceptors requires a​ more sophisticated model to​‌ represent the visual cycle​​ accurately. The derivation of​​​‌ new models for AMD​ and STGD will have​‌ the model in 35​​ as starting point. Our​​​‌ model refinement will provide​ an improved description of​‌ all-trans-retinal diffusivity, which is​​ hydrophobic and can diffuse​​​‌ freely into the aqueous​ cytoplasm only in presence​‌ of a suitable binder.​​ On the other hand,​​​‌ all-trans-retinal can diffuse on​ the lipid membrane discs.​‌ We plan to derive​​ effective equations independent of​​​‌ single membrane discs (starting​ from the homogenisation results​‌ in 101). The​​ non-uniform distribution of rhodopsins​​​‌ and illumination will reflect​ into non-uniform and/or stochastic​‌ terms at the the​​ level of membrane discs.​​​‌

Modelling the formation of​ A2E.

A2E is a​‌ toxic byproduct of the​​ visual cycle. We plan​​​‌ to study both individual-based​ models and macroscopic differential​‌ equations representing the condensation​​ of retinal near membrane​​​‌ discs. We plan to​ strengthen our collaboration with​‌ C. Schwarz (U. Tubingen)​​ with regards to new​​​‌ measurements from two-photon ophthalmoscopy.​ We plan to derive​‌ a stochastic model for​​ the evolution of the​​​‌ concentration of A2E in​ membrane discs, outer segments​‌ and RPE cells. Two​​ molecules of vitamin A​​​‌ are needed for A2E​ production, hence quadratic reaction​‌ terms are expected. Rescaling​​ the model in time​​​‌ appears to be necessary​ since the probability of​‌ formation of A2E is​​ low and accumulation takes​​​‌ place over long time​ scales (years). This relates​‌ to the long–time asymptotic​​ analysis, with a possible​​​‌ reformulation in terms of​ ODEs/PDEs and coupling with​‌ our model of the​​ visual cycle. Accumulation of​​​‌ A2E in RPE cells​ is a consequence of​‌ phagocytosis of outer segments,​​ thus it will be​​​‌ useful to couple our​ model with those obtained​‌ in 121 for retinal​​ metabolic regulation. The starting​​​‌ point will be a​ numerical exploration, setting the​‌ base for parameter tuning.​​

3.5.6 Modelling the Retinal​​​‌ Pigment Epithelium in Age-Related​ Macular Degeneration

MUSCLEES permanent​‌ members involved: Luca Alasio,​​ Benoît Perthame

Biomedical context.​​​‌

We visually perceive the​ world in a way​‌ that is heavily dependent​​ on sophisticated and delicate​​​‌ biochemical mechanisms, and their​ disruption has a detrimental​‌ impact on a human's​​ life. Age-related Macular Degeneration​​​‌ (AMD) affects the centre​ of the visual field​‌ and it has become​​ increasingly prevalent in our​​​‌ ageing society, thus causing​ a spike of academic​‌ and pharmaceutical interest. Globally,​​ there will be nearly​​​‌ 300 million AMD patients​ by 2040 175,​‌ resulting in a major​​ public health problem (we​​​‌ focus on dry, non-neovascular​ AMD, not on the​‌ wet, vascular type). Interdisciplinary​​ collaboration is crucial in​​​‌ order to deepen the​ understanding of AMD; we​‌ are currently working with​​ M. Paques (H. Quinze-Vingts,​​​‌ SU) and his group,​ L. Almeida (CNRS, LJLL).​‌ We focus on the​​ layer of retinal pigment​​ epithelium (RPE) in the​​​‌ retina.

The RPE cell‌ layer supports photoreceptors providing‌​‌ nutrients, contributing to the​​ visual cycle and to​​​‌ phagocytosis of outer segments‌ 133. RPE cells‌​‌ enable photoreceptor cell renewal,​​ which is essential because​​​‌ outer segments contain high‌ levels of unsaturated lipids,‌​‌ 53 subject to oxidation​​ in the presence of​​​‌ light, as well as‌ other (potentially harmful) photo-reactive‌​‌ molecules 116, 63​​. Our goals include:​​​‌ (1) modelling RPE senescence,‌ discontinuity and degeneration in‌​‌ AMD; (2) studying the​​ actin cable dynamics for​​​‌ the closure of small‌ lesions; (3) exploring the‌​‌ hypothesis of myosin inhibition​​ and senescence to explain​​​‌ large lesions; (4) exploring‌ the links with drusen‌​‌ formation and A2E accumulation,​​ which have been connected​​​‌ to macular degeneration and‌ other lesions 165,‌​‌ as well as changes​​ in RPE cell morphology​​​‌ and organisation 168.‌

Modelling and simulation of‌​‌ the RPE mosaic in​​ AMD.

As AMD progresses,​​​‌ the tissue deteriorates and‌ larger, permanent lesions can‌​‌ occur. We are working​​ under the hypothesis that​​​‌ the discontinuity enlargement is‌ related to the cumulative‌​‌ effect of the tissue​​ bio-mechanics and retraction forces​​​‌ of each cell around‌ the lesions. RPE cells‌​‌ do not typically reproduce​​ and, in normal conditions,​​​‌ if one of them‌ dies the neighbours expand‌​‌ to fill the gap​​ to maintain the tissue​​​‌ integrity. We will model‌ the formation of lesions‌​‌ and explore how RPE​​ dysfunction, oxidative stress, and​​​‌ chronic inflammation contribute to‌ the development and growth‌​‌ of lesions. The model​​ will include the evolution​​​‌ and impact of varying‌ lesion sizes, as well‌​‌ as the role of​​ drusen. A suitable starting​​​‌ point for the model‌ derivation are the so-called‌​‌ multi-phase thresholding scheme (first​​ introduced for one phase​​​‌ by Merriman, Bence and‌ Osher in 1992), representing‌​‌ the tensions and the​​ actin cable dynamics through​​​‌ motion by mean curvature‌ (see e.g. 132,‌​‌ 95). A complementary​​ modelling approach is related​​​‌ to a new family‌ of structured models obtained‌​‌ by S. Hecht and​​ D. Peurichard involving both​​​‌ position and radius variables‌ for each cell.

The‌​‌ group of Prof. Michel​​ Paques (Hopital National de​​​‌ la vision Quinze-Vingts) is‌ performing experiments and collecting‌​‌ data from high resolution​​ in-vivo and ex-vivo retinal​​​‌ imaging, in animals and‌ humans 144. These‌​‌ include histological markings allowing​​ to detail the size​​​‌ and morphology of each‌ cell of the retinal‌​‌ pigment epithelium that can​​ be used for a​​​‌ direct comparison with in‌ silico models. AMD can‌​‌ be studied at different​​ space and time scales.​​​‌ The connection between different‌ scales will be modelled‌​‌ taking into account several​​ contributing factors, including the​​​‌ following: (1) regions of‌ hypo- and hyper- contracted‌​‌ cells will be studied​​ in relation to myosin​​​‌ dysfunction; (2) feedback between‌ inflammatory host response and‌​‌ accumulation of molecular damage​​ 160; (3) migration​​​‌ of peripheral RPE cells‌ to compensate for the‌​‌ loss of central RPE​​ cells due to ageing​​​‌ 78; (4) detrimental‌ effects of excessive concentrations‌​‌ of all-trans retinal and​​​‌ A2E 166, 32​, 122; (5)​‌ distinction between normal ageing​​ effects, senescence, and pathological​​​‌ formation of drusen 131​.

4 Application domains​‌

  • Section 4.1 explores general​​ questions related to the​​​‌ Emergence of collective phenomena​;
  • Section 4.2 considers​‌ special occurrences of these​​ questions in the context​​​‌ of Living biological tissues​, particularly for tissue​‌ growth and development and​​ cancer cell proliferation;
  • Section​​​‌ 4.3 presents Mathematical models​ for epidemic spread.​‌

These three sections are​​ of course not airtight,​​​‌ and multiple links can​ be drawn between them.​‌ Indeed, Section 4.2 is​​ concerned with Living biological​​​‌ tissues, whose behaviour​ by nature also contain​‌ aspects of collective dynamics​​ (Section 4.1). Similarly,​​​‌ collective behaviour is present​ in the epidemiological issues​‌ developed in Section 4.3​​. We have in​​​‌ mind to exploit and​ deepen the corresponding ties,​‌ between different topics and​​ between the team members.​​​‌

4.1 Emergence of collective​ phenomena

How do globally​‌ organized patterns emerge in​​ a system driven only​​​‌ by local interactions? Such​ behavior is ubiquitous in​‌ many systems, and understanding​​ the emergence of patterns​​​‌ has numerous applications in​ biological or social networks,​‌ cells' organization in tissues,​​ and neurosciences. Collective dynamics​​​‌ models have been developed​ to explain the emergence​‌ of global patterns in​​ a population from local​​​‌ interaction rules between neighboring​ agents — a fascinating​‌ effect called “self-organization” (see​​ 49, 74,​​​‌ 77, 105,​ 171 and references within).​‌ This general topic breaks​​ down in several more​​​‌ precise subjects.

Biological and​ social networks

Collective phenomena​‌ can emerge from local​​ interactions in biological and​​​‌ social networks. Social animals​ tend to organize themselves​‌ into highly coherent groups,​​ such as schools of​​​‌ fish, bird flocks, swarms​ of insects, herds of​‌ sheep, or even human​​ crowds. Much research is​​​‌ currently undertaken in various​ scientific communities (including biologists,​‌ sociologists, computer scientists and​​ mathematicians) to understand how​​​‌ and why certain types​ of collective behavior (such​‌ as flocking 74,​​ alignment 171, or​​​‌ consensus 105) are​ observed. Despite this surge​‌ of interest, many questions​​ remain open and our​​​‌ research aims to address​ some of them. In​‌ particular, can the emergence​​ of global behavior such​​​‌ as consensus be predicted​ from initial conditions? Are​‌ there sufficient or necessary​​ conditions on the interaction​​​‌ network ensuring convergence to​ a coherent asymptotic state?​‌

Bacterium colony growth

Bacteria​​ are unicellular organisms, whose​​​‌ biomass exceeds that of​ all other living organisms,​‌ and on which our​​ survival is dependent. In​​​‌ the human body, the​ number of bacteria almost​‌ equals the one of​​ cells. Despite the fact​​​‌ that most of the​ bacteria are harmless, some​‌ pathogenic strains are the​​ cause of infectious diseases​​​‌ such as tuberculosis, cholera,​ bacterial meningitis, and salmonella​‌ among others. It makes​​ it essential to understand​​​‌ in which way bacteria​ multiply and disrupt the​‌ normal functions of our​​ bodies. Numerous studies have​​​‌ been done to grasp​ how a bacterium, from​‌ a single organism, develops​​ into organized micro-colonies and​​ biofilm structures 89,​​​‌ 92. Still, some‌ phenomena are not explained.‌​‌ At early stages of​​ the development, going from​​​‌ one bacterium to a‌ structured micro-colony, we will‌​‌ investigate mechanisms leading to​​ poorly understood properties, such​​​‌ as the elongated shape‌ of the colonies, the‌​‌ four cell arrays arrangement​​ and the high density​​​‌ 161. At latter‌ stages of development, we‌​‌ will question the impact​​ of these microscopic phenomena​​​‌ on macroscopic structures.

Cell‌ population dynamics: the classic‌​‌ homogeneous case

Self-organization is​​ often observed in cell​​​‌ population dynamics, both within‌ a single cell population‌​‌ or between two or​​ more distinct populations. Interestingly,​​​‌ the forward and backward‌ epithelial-mesenchymal cellular transitions (EMT-MET),‌​‌ which play a crucial​​ role in embryonic development,​​​‌ tissue repair and cancer‌ metastasis, can be modeled‌​‌ either as a transition​​ between three homogeneous cell​​​‌ populations (epithelial, mesenchymal and‌ hybrid), or as the‌​‌ evolution of a single​​ heterogeneous cell population, structured​​​‌ by an epithelial-to-mesenchymal phenotype.‌ In order to achieve‌​‌ self-organization, cell populations often​​ display local communication strategies,​​​‌ whether it be within‌ a cell population or‌​‌ between different cell types.​​ For instance, chemotaxis refers​​​‌ to the directed movement‌ of cells in response‌​‌ to a chemical gradient​​ produced by neighbouring cells​​​‌ (Keller-Segel-type models). Mechanosensing is‌ another well-established cell-cell communication‌​‌ strategy, that relies simply​​ on mechanical constraints. Communication​​​‌ between cells can also‌ be driven by the‌​‌ secretion and subsequent binding​​ of ligands, as​​​‌ in the case of‌ the EMT-MET 170.‌​‌

When considering interactions between​​ several cell populations, interactions​​​‌ may be mutualistic as‌ in the case of‌​‌ cancer cell populations and​​ trophic healthy cell populations​​​‌ (breast cancer and adipocytes‌ 153, or leukaemic‌​‌ cells and supporting somatic​​ cells 140 for instance),​​​‌ or cells can be‌ in competition (in particular‌​‌ tumour-immune interactions 37,​​ 119). This latter​​​‌ aspect will continue to‌ be one of our‌​‌ present objectives in modelling​​ cancer cell populations. We​​​‌ will address it in‌ the sequel in the‌​‌ adapted framework of heterogeneous​​ cell populations.

Cell population​​​‌ dynamics: heterogeneous cell populations‌ and trait-structured models

One‌​‌ of the main challenges​​ when modeling a single​​​‌ cell population is to‌ take into account the‌​‌ biological variability, aka intrinsic​​ heterogeneity, of the​​​‌ population. A now classic‌ way of modelling, introduced‌​‌ in adaptive dynamics, firstly​​ in theoretical ecology, then​​​‌ in cell population dynamics,‌ is to use continuous‌​‌ trait (or phenotype)-structured population​​ dynamics settings.

How to​​​‌ deal with them depends‌ on the heterogeneity question‌​‌ at stake and on​​ the choice of traits​​​‌ used to structure an‌ adaptive cell population: should‌​‌ they be well-identified biological​​ molecules or gene expression​​​‌ determinants, (e.g., specific to‌ a given drug and‌​‌ a given population under​​ drug exposure 154)?​​​‌ Or should they be‌ hidden, but general and‌​‌ linked to cell fates,​​ in other words potentials​​​‌ to develop such and‌ such a trait or‌​‌ phenotype 40, 69​​, 71, 114​​​‌, 162, as‌ in theoretical ecology models‌​‌ (viability, fecundity, plasticity of​​​‌ individuals)?

Due to the​ lack of measurable markers​‌ of relevant biological variability​​ (i.e., heterogeneity) recorded in​​​‌ continuous time from experimental​ teams, we are often​‌ bound to stick to​​ their more hidden and​​​‌ abstract version. However, this​ will certainly never free​‌ us from keeping watch​​ over incoming biological developments​​​‌ amenable to at least​ partly identify possible molecular​‌ markers of such a​​ priori abstract phenotypes.

Of​​​‌ note, in the framework​ of adaptive structured cell​‌ population dynamics, emergence of​​ phenotypes is always reversible​​​‌. Which means that,​ according to changes in​‌ the cell population environment,​​ new phenotypes may appear,​​​‌ and they can equally​ disappear if the environment​‌ changes. In other words,​​ we address the question​​​‌ of cell differentiations,​ not mutations, recalling that​‌ cell differentiations occur in​​ an isogenic cell population,​​​‌ not modifying its genome,​ only gene expressions due​‌ to the action of​​ epigenetic enzymes, whereas mutations​​​‌ change the genome by​ modifying its constituting base​‌ pairs in the sequences​​ ATGC.

Some of the​​​‌ questions that we aim​ to address by means​‌ of mathematical modelling by​​ structured population models, in​​​‌ particular in the context​ of the EMT-MET (reversible​‌ phenotype transition) and phenotype​​ divergence (reversible evolution between​​​‌ phenotype monomorphism and dimorphism)​ are the following: Can​‌ different cell phenotypes co-exist​​ at the same time​​​‌ in a population, and​ if only some of​‌ them persist, which are​​ they? What effect do​​​‌ growth and death of​ the population have on​‌ the phenotype distribution of​​ the population? What effect​​​‌ do growth and environmental​ changes have on transient​‌ phenomena, such as the​​ hysteretic behaviour observed in​​​‌ the Epithelial-Mesenchymal Transition, and​ on asymptotic behaviour of​‌ the cell populations? What​​ role can be attributed​​​‌ to phenotype plasticity in​ such transient or established​‌ phenomena?

Neuroscience

In neuroscience,​​ learning and memory are​​​‌ usually associated with long-term​ changes of connection strength​‌ between neurons. In this​​ context, synaptic plasticity refers​​​‌ to the set of​ mechanisms driving the dynamics​‌ of neuronal connections, called​​ synapses and represented by​​​‌ a scalar value, the​ synaptic weight. A​‌ Spike-Timing Dependent Plasticity (STDP)​​ rule is a biologically-based​​​‌ model representing the time​ evolution of the synaptic​‌ weight as a functional​​ of the past spiking​​​‌ activity of adjacent neurons.​

There is a rich​‌ mathematical literature on biological​​ neural networks but mainly​​​‌ when the connectivity of​ the network is fixed,​‌ i.e. when the synaptic​​ weights are constant. In​​​‌ a series of articles​ 157, 158,​‌ 156, 172,​​ a new, general, mathematical​​​‌ framework to study the​ phenomenon of synaptic plasticity​‌ associated to STDP rules​​ has been introduced and​​​‌ analyzed for a system​ composed of two neuronal​‌ cells connected by a​​ single synapse whose weight​​​‌ is time-varying.

Experiments show​ that long-term synaptic plasticity​‌ evolves on a much​​ slower timescale than the​​​‌ cellular mechanisms driving the​ activity of neuronal cells.​‌ A scaling model has​​ been introduced and limiting​​​‌ results have been proved.​ The central result obtained​‌ is an averaging principle​​ for the stochastic process​​ associated to the synaptic​​​‌ weight.

We plan to‌ investigate mathematical models of‌​‌ plastic synapticity in a​​ more general network. The​​​‌ question is of determining‌ under which conditions the‌​‌ coordinates of the matrix​​ of synaptic weights of​​​‌ a given subset S‌ of cells grow without‌​‌ bound or not. This​​ property can be expressed​​​‌ by the fact that‌ the cells of S‌​‌ exhibit a collective behavior.​​

A difficult modelling problem​​​‌ in this context is‌ of having a priori‌​‌ two scaling parameters with​​ two different types of​​​‌ convergence: Averaging principles or‌ mean-field approximations.

  1. The factor‌​‌ of the time-scale of​​ fast cellular processes;

    The​​​‌ main assumption is that‌ the timescale of the‌​‌ time evolution of the​​ synaptic weights is slow.​​​‌ This is the framework‌ of 156. This‌​‌ scaling leads to a​​ possible averaging principle.

  2. The​​​‌ number of nodes of‌ the network.

    A given‌​‌ neural cell receives an​​ input from a large​​​‌ number of cells and‌ to each of them‌​‌ is associated a synaptic​​ weight. This scaling, with​​​‌ appropriate symmetry properties of‌ the topology, may give‌​‌ a mean-field approximation of​​ the network.

Both of​​​‌ these parameters should be‌ large, and are a‌​‌ priori uncorrelated. A central​​ question is to determine​​​‌ how possible scaling results‌ can give an insight‌​‌ on the plastic synapticity​​ at the level of​​​‌ such a network.

4.2‌ Living biological tissues

Pseudo-stratified‌​‌ epithelial tissue development

Understanding​​ how tissue growth and​​​‌ development is regulated is‌ crucial in biology. Both‌​‌ proliferation and regulation of​​ cells' growth are fundamental​​​‌ for the development of‌ healthy tissues in animals‌​‌ and plants. Pseudo-stratified epithelium​​ tissues are composed of​​​‌ narrow and elongated cells‌ arranged in a packed‌​‌ one-layer tissue. The positions​​ of the nuclei are​​​‌ variable along the depth‌ of the tissue. Each‌​‌ cell is connected to​​ the so-called basal and​​​‌ apical surface. During development,‌ each cell follows a‌​‌ series of events leading​​ to cell division. This​​​‌ process, known as the‌ cell cycle, is composed‌​‌ of four steps: G1,​​ where the cell prepares​​​‌ for DNA replication; S,‌ where the DNA is‌​‌ replicated; G2, where the​​ cell prepares to divide;​​​‌ and mitosis M, where‌ the cell divides. In‌​‌ pseudostratified epithelia, the nuclei​​ move along the apical/basal​​​‌ axis during the inter-kinetic‌ phases G1 and G2‌​‌ 27. This motion​​ is called inter-kinetic nuclear​​​‌ migration (IKNM). The IKNM‌ has become a point‌​‌ of interest in the​​ past years with numerous​​​‌ studies being published 112‌. Some of the‌​‌ questions we will aim​​ to answer with the​​​‌ development and analysis of‌ mathematical models are the‌​‌ following. Are the motions​​ in G1 and G2​​​‌ active or passive motions?‌ How is the IKNM‌​‌ impacted by the increase​​ of crowding during the​​​‌ tissue development? Which mechanism‌ allows the transition of‌​‌ the cell in the​​ different phases of the​​​‌ cell cycle?

Energy driven‌ development of tissue architecture‌​‌

One of the main​​ socio-economic challenges in the​​​‌ twenty-first century is to‌ ensure that increasing lifespan‌​‌ is accompanied by the​​​‌ prevention of decline to​ achieve similar or greater​‌ increases in health. Organized​​ architecture that supports organ​​​‌ function emerges rapidly and​ locally during the first​‌ period of life (during​​ development), where the extracellular​​​‌ matrix (ECM) plays a​ key role by giving​‌ rise to the mechanical​​ macrostructure. This 3D architecture​​​‌ is then globally maintained​ during the maturity period,​‌ before progressively declining corresponding​​ to degeneration and loss​​​‌ of functions. Throughout all​ these steps, the evolving​‌ architecture and its constant​​ turn-over is powered by​​​‌ energy exchanges through metabolism.​ Numerous evidences suggest that​‌ energy exchanges and mechanical​​ forces can feedback on​​​‌ each other and that​ large perturbations of one​‌ or the other are​​ associated with degeneration and​​​‌ diseases. Therefore, understanding the​ dynamics of biological tissues​‌ at different spatiotemporal scales​​ requires to account simultaneously​​​‌ for energy exchanges and​ mechanical considerations, a view​‌ that is currently lacking​​. We will aim​​​‌ to bridge this gap​ by taking a particular​‌ focus on the complex​​ interplay between metabolism and​​​‌ mechanics in tissue development​ and ageing via the​‌ dual use of mathematical​​ modelling and in vitro/in​​​‌ vivo experiments.

Living tissues​ as multiphase flows

At​‌ the continuum (macroscopic) level,​​ a living tissue might​​​‌ be seen as a​ multiphase flow (different types​‌ of cells, liquid, molecules)​​ through a porous media​​​‌ (extra-cellular matrix), a view​ encompassed in the so-called​‌ mixture theory (see 75​​). In mathematical terms,​​​‌ this leads to strongly​ nonlinear degenerate parabolic Cahn-Hilliard​‌ (PDE) equations 148.​​ Although widely used in​​​‌ the literature to describe​ the mechanical properties of​‌ living tissues, it remains​​ unclear how these continuum​​​‌ models (at the population​ level) can be obtained​‌ from a mechanical description​​ at the cell level.​​​‌ We will take an​ interest in the derivation​‌ of such models from​​ mesoscopic (kinetic) models, in​​​‌ order to understand the​ relation between compressible and​‌ incompressible porous-medium models.

Tumour-immune​​ cell interactions and immunotherapies​​​‌

In a model of​ tumour-immune cell interactions under​‌ development, the behaviour of​​ interacting heterogeneous cell populations​​​‌ is described by a​ set of coupled PDEs​‌ of the nonlocal Lotka-Volterra​​ type. The cell population​​​‌ densities are structured by​ a continuous trait (aka​‌ phenotype) standing for malignancy​​ identified to a potential​​​‌ of de-differentiation (so-called `stemness'),​ in tumour cells, and,​‌ similarly, a continuous trait​​ representing anti-tumour aggressiveness in​​​‌ immune cells. As modern​ immunotherapeutic drugs, in particular​‌ Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors,​​ have recently been introduced​​​‌ as boosters of such​ aggressiveness, i.e., of cancer​‌ cell kill by T-lymphocytes,​​ and even more recently​​​‌ also by NK-lymphocytes, their​ impact on tumour-immune interactions​‌ is represented in the​​ present model under development​​​‌ by a target in​ the effector lymphocyte population.​‌ Questions at stake are:​​ Can we model in​​​‌ a relevant way and​ mathematically analyse these interactions​‌ between cell populations, so​​ as to obtain a​​​‌ qualitative description of the​ so-called immunoediting, that​‌ is known to yield​​ extinction, equilibrium or escape​​​‌ in the tumour cell​ population? Can we show​‌ `proof of concept' situations​​ in which the impact​​ of immunotherapies can reverse​​​‌ tumour escape towards extinction,‌ or at least equilibrium?‌​‌ Can we design theoretical​​ optimised strategies to deliver​​​‌ time-scheduled immunotherapies to attain‌ this goal? Can we‌​‌ analyse these interactions and​​ their therapeutic control by​​​‌ immunotherapies in terms of‌ concentration (or not) of‌​‌ the traits?

Phenotypic divergence​​ in cancer and in​​​‌ the emergence of multicellularity‌

The question of understanding‌​‌ the cancer disease from​​ an integrative physiology and​​​‌ long-time evolution point of‌ view has stimulated many‌​‌ authors for quite a​​ long time. In this​​​‌ respect, the atavistic theory‌ of cancer, presented in‌​‌ 76, 174,​​ proposes that tumours represent,​​​‌ roughly speaking, a reverse‌ evolution to a previous,‌​‌ incoherent, disorganised and very​​ plastic state of multicellularity​​​‌ in animals, which the‌ authors call Metazoa 1.0‌​‌. This theory involves​​ a billion year-long evolutionary​​​‌ perspective of the emergence‌ of multicellularity from collections‌​‌ of unicellular beings to​​ the first organised animals,​​​‌ so-called Urmetazoa 135.‌ Phenotypic divergence under environmental‌​‌ constraints is involved in​​ both evolutionary/developmental and cancer​​​‌ biology. In the former,‌ it is the fundamental‌​‌ phenomenon by which cell​​ differentiation yields new cell​​​‌ types with emerging functions,‌ leading in particular to‌​‌ multicellular beings such as​​ animals (aka metazoa). In​​​‌ the latter, the process‌ of bet hedging in‌​‌ cancer is a response​​ to cellular stress to​​​‌ describe the multiple fates‌ of a plastic cancer‌​‌ cell population as a​​ fail-safe strategy to face​​​‌ deadly insults, e.g., due‌ to anticancer drugs. The‌​‌ question of phenotypic divergence​​ in an isogenic cell​​​‌ population is thus crucial.‌ We will address it‌​‌ by phenotype-structured PDEs of​​ the reaction-advection-diffusion type 40​​​‌, 69, 71‌, 114, 162‌​‌, and explore what​​ mechanisms (mutations, differentiation, selection)​​​‌ are responsible for concentration‌ of the population around‌​‌ a unique phenotype (a​​ singleton in phenotypic space);​​​‌ or, on the contrary,‌ for continuous or discrete‌​‌ heterogeneity of the population,​​ the discrete cases being​​​‌ represented by discrete sets‌ of phenotypes, cases among‌​‌ which divergence stricto sensu​​, leading to a​​​‌ doubleton (phenotypic dimorphism), is‌ the simplest one.

Visco-elastic‌​‌ description of the Retinal​​ Pigment Epithelium (RPE).

A​​​‌ further modelling effort is‌ necessary in order to‌​‌ capture both biological and​​ mechanical features of the​​​‌ RPE monolayer, with specific‌ attention to topological changes‌​‌ such as lesion formation,​​ closure and fusion. A​​​‌ visco-elastic description of the‌ tissue has been developed‌​‌ in collaboration with the​​ group of Prof. M.​​​‌ Paques at Hôpital National‌ des Quinze-Vingts (Paris Eye‌​‌ Imaging). We are confidently​​ working towards new results​​​‌ in terms of analysis,‌ simulation, and qualitative adherence‌​‌ to experimental data. The​​ main goal is to​​​‌ support and integrate ophthalmological‌ research, contributing to the‌​‌ prediction of the evolution​​ of atrophic lesions during​​​‌ the progression of Age-Related‌ Macular Degeneration. Recent advances‌​‌ have been made in​​ the study of the​​​‌ connection between microscopic and‌ macroscopic models for the‌​‌ RPE tissue, but this​​ point of view is​​​‌ still in an early‌ phase. In the spirit‌​‌ of describing tissue ageing,​​​‌ new models structured with​ radius or senescence variables​‌ are being constructed and​​ analysed.

4.3 Mathematical models​​​‌ for epidemic spread

The​ still lasting pandemic of​‌ Covid-19, coming after the​​ pandemic of H1N1 (2009)​​​‌ and outbreaks of other​ severe infectious diseases such​‌ as SRAS, MERS and​​ Ebola fever, as well​​​‌ as the spread of​ viruliferous mosquitoes in temperate​‌ regions of the world​​ and the increase of​​​‌ the corresponding health risk,​ tragically illustrates the importance​‌ of emerging and reemerging​​ infectious diseases. As noticed​​​‌ by the epidemiologist S.​ Morse 134, “most​‌ emergent viruses are zoonotic,​​ with natural animal reservoirs​​​‌ a more frequent source​ of new viruses than​‌ is the sudden evolution​​ of a new entity.​​​‌ The most frequent factor​ in emergence is human​‌ behavior that increases the​​ probability of transfer of​​​‌ viruses from their endogenous​ animal hosts to man".​‌ This increase is likely​​ to continue in the​​​‌ near future, due to​ destruction of ecosystems by​‌ deforestation, urbanization, industrial agriculture​​ and economic globalization 159​​​‌, requiring new efforts​ for understanding the spread​‌ of infectious diseases and​​ for improving their control.​​​‌

Vector-borne epidemics

Every year,​ around 700,000 deaths are​‌ due to diseases transmitted​​ by (female) mosquitoes, like​​​‌ malaria, yellow fever, dengue,​ Zika, chikungunya, Nile virus...​‌ They are indeed the​​ most dangerous animals for​​​‌ humankind. For many of​ these diseases, no efficient​‌ remedy or vaccine presently​​ exists, and an essential​​​‌ strategy to control vector-borne​ disease outbreaks consists in​‌ the control of mosquito​​ vector populations that transmit​​​‌ these diseases (Aedes​ species for the diseases​‌ previously cited).

The insecticides,​​ which have non-specific actions​​​‌ and strongly affect biodiversity,​ are now recognized as​‌ a highly unsatisfying solution,​​ and innovative methods of​​​‌ biological control are being​ searched for and tested.​‌ Among these, the sterile​​ or incompatible insect techniques​​​‌ (SIT/IIT) and replacement strategies​ (Wolbachia) attract​‌ strong attention. SIT is​​ based on the release​​​‌ of male insects after​ their sterilization (traditionally by​‌ means of irradiation): sterile​​ males will mate with​​​‌ wild females without producing​ any offspring, reducing or​‌ suppressing the wild population.​​ The sterile insects are​​​‌ not self-replicating and, therefore,​ cannot become established in​‌ the environment. On the​​ other hand, Wolbachia is​​​‌ a natural intracellular bacterial​ symbiont, maternally transmitted to​‌ offspring. Some of its​​ strains cause a drastic​​​‌ decrease in the capacity​ to transmit dengue, zika​‌ or chikungunya of the​​ mosquitoes, directly (by interfering​​​‌ with their vector competence)​ or indirectly (by shortening​‌ lifespan, etc.). Contrary to​​ SIT, this offers theoretically​​​‌ a permanent protection against​ the outbreaks.

The application​‌ in the field of​​ these promising techniques to​​​‌ control mosquitoes is not​ easy, and models are​‌ a useful tool to​​ study the various issues​​​‌ at stake, and to​ propose and scale control​‌ strategies. In particular, it​​ is important to take​​​‌ into account the spatial​ extension (and possible heterogeneities)​‌ of the operation and​​ other aspects like the​​​‌ seasonality, migration from outside​ the treated domain, release​‌ of mosquitoes imperfectly treated,​​ effects of the treatment​​ on the epidemic risk​​​‌ and so on. The‌ uncertainties on the biological‌​‌ processes and the imprecision​​ of the measures make​​​‌ the whole issue quite‌ intricate, and we intend‌​‌ to see what control​​ science has to say​​​‌ to solve the related‌ problems.

Infectious diseases

The‌​‌ progress of the pandemic​​ of Covid-19 has highlighted​​​‌ on a scale never‌ seen before the complexity‌​‌ and intricateness of the​​ factors that shape the​​​‌ spread of an epidemic,‌ from the biological aspects‌​‌ at various scales (from​​ virus to world population),​​​‌ to the economic, social‌ and politic aspects, without‌​‌ forgetting the many feedback​​ loops binding them2​​​‌. Our interest is‌ to participate to the‌​‌ understanding and disentanglement of​​ the important factors, to​​​‌ the design and analysis‌ of relevant mathematical models,‌​‌ and to their use​​ to shape adequate control​​​‌ strategies.

For the accomplishment‌ of this task, we‌​‌ plan to take advantage​​ of a reservoir of​​​‌ tools and ideas from‌ control theory, in addition‌​‌ to the more classical​​ techniques developed in mathematical​​​‌ epidemiology. This is a‌ point in common with‌​‌ our other topic of​​ interest previously mentioned, the​​​‌ vector-borne diseases. First, we‌ will routinely consider control‌​‌ issues — not only​​ in the sense of​​​‌ controlling a disease, but‌ using the term as‌​‌ in “control theory”. The​​ control inputs we will​​​‌ encounter represent the available‌ “means of action” on‌​‌ the epidemic, typically vaccination​​ campaigns or social distancing​​​‌ measures (or sterile mosquito‌ releases in the case‌​‌ of vector-borne diseases previously​​ mentioned). Constraints on the​​​‌ intensity of the input‌ variables like the duration‌​‌ of lockdown periods are​​ pertinent (total number of​​​‌ released mosquitoes for the‌ control of vector-borne diseases),‌​‌ but also on the​​ state variables, e.g. on​​​‌ a maximal room occupancy‌ rate in Intensive Treatment‌​‌ Units (maximal number of​​ female mosquitoes, to limit​​​‌ both nuisance and epidemiological‌ risk in the vector-borne‌​‌ diseases context). Optimal control​​ involves non-conventional cost functions,​​​‌ such as the peak‌ of infectious people (peak‌​‌ of female mosquito population...)​​ or the time spent​​​‌ above a given value,‌ which do not lead‌​‌ to Bolza problem. Robustness​​ issues are also important​​​‌ in this context where‌ the reality is imperfectly‌​‌ described by approximate models.​​

Second, we will pay​​​‌ particular attention to the‌ models, the data and‌​‌ their cross-relations. Contrary​​ to the engineering sciences,​​​‌ where models come from‌ a combination of general‌​‌ principles and empirical laws,​​ there is no such​​​‌ situation in mathematical epidemiology.‌ In fact, it is‌​‌ not fully clear what​​ are the key phenomena​​​‌ and quantities that influence‌ decisively such complex situations,‌​‌ and thus deserve to​​ be included in a​​​‌ model. On the other‌ hand, the data themselves‌​‌ are imprecise and questionable,​​ due to reasons that​​​‌ range from the evolving‌ biological reality and our‌​‌ imperfect knowledge, to the​​ characteristics of the data​​​‌ collection process by the‌ Health system. In this‌​‌ context, we will be​​ specially interested in questions​​​‌ of observability and identifiability‌ (“given a model of‌​‌ the system and specific​​​‌ input-output experiments supposed error​ free, is it possible​‌ to determine uniquely the​​ actual system state value​​​‌ and the parameters of​ the model ?"), and​‌ of observation and identification​​, their realization counterparts​​​‌ (“given a model observable​ or identifiable, how to​‌ practically estimate the state​​ or parameter values ?").​​​‌

5 Social and environmental​ responsibility

5.1 Footprint of​‌ research activities

All members​​ of the team decided​​​‌ to carefully review his​ or her trip policy​‌ (especially by air), in​​ order to reduce carbon​​​‌ footprint.

5.2 Social responsibilities​ within the community

Several​‌ members of MUSCLEES are​​ active in the “Pôle​​​‌ écoute” of the Jacques-Louis​ Lions laboratory.

Nastassia Pouradier​‌ Duteil is part of​​ the mentoring program of​​​‌ Ecole Polytechnique for PhD​ students organized by “Association​‌ Femmes et Sciences”.

Sophie​​ Hecht is part of​​​‌ the comité invitations courtes​ in LJLL

Diane Peurichard​‌ is member of the​​ comission d'évaluation (CE) Inria,​​​‌ member of the comission​ des emplois scientifiques (CES)​‌ Inria Paris, member of​​ the comité de suivi​​​‌ doctoral (CSD) Inria Paris​

Diane Peurichard is part​‌ of the mentoring program​​ for high school female​​​‌ students via the associations​ Animath and Femmes et​‌ mathématiques

6 Highlights of​​ the year

6.1 Awards​​​‌

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman was the​ winner of 2025 European​‌ Control Conference Best Paper​​ Award, for his paper​​​‌ “Basic Offspring Number and​ Robust Feedback Design for​‌ the Biological Control of​​ Vectors by Sterile Insect​​​‌ Release Technique.”

7 Latest​ software developments, platforms, open​‌ data

7.1 Latest software​​ developments

7.1.1 tissueMORPH

  • Keywords:​​​‌
    Systems Biology, Computational biology,​ Physiology, Mechanistic modeling
  • Functional​‌ Description:
    tissueMORPH is a​​ software that permits 2D​​​‌ agent-based simulations of tissue​ morphogenesis and regeneration/wound healing.​‌ Simulation platform enabling to​​ perform simulations of systems​​​‌ composed of individual cells​ (disks) growing and interacting​‌ in a dynamical fiber​​ network (composed of cross-linked​​​‌ fibers - segments). The​ platform enables to explore​‌ the mechanisms of tissue​​ construction (morphogenesis) and tissue​​​‌ reparation after injury (regeneration/wound​ healing) . The software​‌ includes many modules specifically​​ tailored to support the​​​‌ simulation and analysis of​ virtual tissues including 2D​‌ visualization and image processing​​ tools. Cell and fiber​​​‌ network parameters can be​ independently varied which facilitates​‌ specific simulations and allows​​ for detailed analyses of​​​‌ growth dynamics and links​ between matrix mechanical properties​‌ and tissue construction/reconstruction. Applications:​​ adipose tissues morphogenesis, tissue​​​‌ reparation, wound healing, muscles,​ dynamical fiber networks.
  • Publications:​‌
  • Contact:​​​‌
    Diane Peurichard
  • Participant:
    6​ anonymous participants

7.2 Open​‌ data

8 New results​​

8.1 Axis 1 –​​​‌ Multiscale study of interacting​ particle systems

Participants: Nastassia​‌ Pouradier Duteil, Diane​​ Peurichard, Sophie Hecht​​​‌, Benoit Perthame,​ Angelina Jammart.

8.1.1​‌ Scaling limits

Participants: Sophie​​ Hecht, Benoit Perthame​​​‌, Diane Peurichard.​

From a nonlocal mean-field​‌ to a porous medium​​ system without self-diffusion

Systems​​​‌ describing the long-range interaction​ between individuals have attracted​‌ a lot of attention​​ in the last years,​​​‌ in particular in relation​ with living systems. These​‌ systems are quadratic, written​​ under the form of​​ transport equations with a​​​‌ nonlocal self-generated drift. In‌ 124, we established‌​‌ the localisation limit, that​​ is the convergence of​​​‌ nonlocal to local systems,‌ when the range of‌​‌ interaction tends to 0.​​ These theoretical results are​​​‌ sustained by numerical simulations.‌ The major new feature‌​‌ in our analysis is​​ that we do not​​​‌ need diffusion to gain‌ compactness, but we rely‌​‌ on a full rank​​ assumption on the interaction​​​‌ kernels. In turn, we‌ prove existence of weak‌​‌ solutions for the resulting​​ system, a cross-diffusion system​​​‌ of quadratic type.

Scaling‌ limits for a model‌​‌ with growth, division and​​ cross-diffusion

Originally motivated by​​​‌ the morphogenesis of bacterial‌ microcolonies, we explore in‌​‌ 7 models through different​​ scales for a spatial​​​‌ population of interacting, growing‌ and dividing particles. We‌​‌ start from a microscopic​​ stochastic model, write the​​​‌ corresponding stochastic differential equation‌ satisfied by the empirical‌​‌ measure, and rigorously derive​​ its mesoscopic (mean-field) limit.​​​‌ We then take an‌ interest in the localization‌​‌ limit without growth and​​ fragmentation. Under smoothness and​​​‌ symmetry assumptions for the‌ interaction kernel, we then‌​‌ obtain entropy estimates, which​​ provide us with a​​​‌ localization limit at the‌ macroscopic level. Finally, we‌​‌ perform a thorough numerical​​ study in order to​​​‌ compare the three modeling‌ scales.

As perspectives of‌​‌ the two previous works,​​ current development in the​​​‌ frame of the PhD‌ of N. Martinez Tomas‌​‌ (octo 2025, oct 2028,​​ co-directed with S. Hecht,​​​‌ D. Peurichard and A.‌ Trescases (IMT, Toulouse)) include‌​‌ (i) pattern analysis of​​ structured population models of​​​‌ spherical particles (derived in‌ 7), (ii) rigorous‌​‌ derivation of the micro​​ to macroscale for nonconservative​​​‌ systems (growth and fragmentation)‌ and (iii) derivation and‌​‌ analysis of macroscopic models​​ for anisotropic particles.

From​​​‌ a nonlinear kinetic equation‌ to a volume-exclusion chemotaxis‌​‌ model via asymptotic preserving​​ methods

In 8,​​​‌ we took an interest‌ in the connection between‌​‌ nonlinear kinetic equations and​​ volume-exclusion chemotaxis. We first​​​‌ showed, by formal arguments,‌ that volume-exclusion chemotactic equations‌​‌ can be obtained as​​ the diffusion limit of​​​‌ nonlinear kinetic equations, where‌ both the transport term‌​‌ and the turning operator​​ are density-dependent. We then​​​‌ numerically study this diffusive‌ limit via an asymptotic‌​‌ preserving scheme based on​​ a micro-macro decomposition. By​​​‌ properly discretizing the nonlinear‌ term implicitly-explicitly in an‌​‌ upwind manner, the scheme​​ produces accurate approximations also​​​‌ in the case of‌ strong chemosensitivity. We show,‌​‌ via detailed calculations, that​​ the scheme is asymptotic​​​‌ preserving and bound preserving‌ and show numerically an‌​‌ energy dissipation property, which​​ are essential for practical​​​‌ applications. We extend this‌ scheme to two dimensional‌​‌ kinetic models and we​​ validate its efficiency by​​​‌ means of 1D and‌ 2D numerical experiments of‌​‌ pattern formation in biological​​ systems.

8.1.2 Collective motion​​​‌ of non-exchangeable particle systems‌

Participants: Nastassia Pouradier Duteil‌​‌, Angelina Jammart.​​

Many living systems exhibit​​​‌ fascinating dynamics of collective‌ behavior during locomotion, from‌​‌ bacterial colonies to human​​ crowds. The celebrated Cucker-Smale​​​‌ model describes the dynamics‌ of a group of‌​‌ interacting particles, whose velocities​​​‌ evolve in time according​ to alignment dynamics. The​‌ particles are said to​​ be exchangeable (or identical)​​​‌ if the dynamics does​ not depend explicitely on​‌ their labels. In the​​ opposite exchangeable case, the​​​‌ Cucker-Smale system is known​ to exhibit a flocking​‌ behaviour, that is the​​ asymptotic alignment of all​​​‌ the individual agent velocities,​ under a “fat-tail” condition​‌ on the interaction kernel,​​ see for instance the​​​‌ surveys. These results were​ extended to the non-exchangeable​‌ case in several works,​​ under some additional conditions​​​‌ on the communication weights.​ The internship of Angelina​‌ Jammart , co-supervised by​​ Nastassia Pouradier Duteil and​​​‌ Benoît Bonnet-Weill, consisted in​ extending the existing results​‌ of convergence to flocking​​ for the microscopic system,​​​‌ in particular for time-dependent​ coefficients with positive scrambling​‌, with some time-integral​​ condition.

8.1.3 Multiscale analysis​​​‌ of a kinetic equation​ for mechanotaxis

Participants: Benoit​‌ Perthame.

In 24​​, we present a​​​‌ new kinetic equation for​ cell migration driven by​‌ mechanical interactions with the​​ substrate, an effect not​​​‌ previously captured in kinetic​ models, and essential for​‌ explaining observed collective behaviors​​ such as those in​​​‌ bacterial colonies. The model​ introduces an acceleration term​‌ that accounts for the​​ dynamics of motile cells​​​‌ undergoing mechanotaxis, where extracellular​ signals modulate the forces​‌ arising from cell-substrate interactions.​​ From this formulation, we​​​‌ derive a family of​ macroscopic limit equations and​‌ analyze their principal properties.​​ In particular, we examine​​​‌ linear stability and pattern​ formation ability through theoretical​‌ analysis, supported by numerical​​ simulations.

8.1.4 Incompressible limit​​​‌ of porous media equation​ with chemotaxis and growth​‌

Participants: Benoit Perthame.​​

In 15, we​​​‌ revisit the problem of​ proving the incompressible limit​‌ for the compressible porous​​ media equation with Newtonian​​​‌ drift and growth. The​ question is motivated by​‌ models of living tissues​​ development including chemotaxis. We​​​‌ extend the problem, already​ treated by the authors​‌ and several other contributions,​​ in using a simplified​​​‌ approach, in treating dimensions​ two or higher, and​‌ in incorporating the pressure​​ driven growth term. We​​​‌ also complete the analysis​ with stronger estimates on​‌ the pressure gradient. The​​ major difficulty is to​​​‌ prove the strong convergence​ of the pressure gradient​‌ which is obtained here​​ by a new observation​​​‌ on an algebraic relation​ involving the pressure gradient​‌ for weak limits.

8.1.5​​ Deriving sub-diffusion equations

Participants:​​​‌ Benoit Perthame.

Sub-diffusion​ equations are used in​‌ a large range of​​ applications including fluids, plasma​​​‌ physics and biology. Their​ mathematical analysis is advanced​‌ even if a much​​ larger literature addresses super-diffusions.​​​‌ In 25, we​ provide the microscopic mechanism​‌ and rigorous derivation of​​ sub-diffusions when the waiting​​​‌ time distribution of particles​ follows an age-structured equation​‌ and jumps occur at​​ each renewal. The major​​​‌ difficulty to recover sub-diffusions,​ unlike normal diffusions, is​‌ that the assumption of​​ long waiting time implies​​​‌ lack of integrability for​ the age equilibrium. This​‌ prevents to establish strong​​ a priori estimates. Here,​​​‌ the Laplace transform plays​ the role that Fourier​‌ transform plays for the​​ more traditional case of​​ fast diffusions.

8.2 Axis​​​‌ 2 – Stochastic models‌ for biological and chemical‌​‌ systems

Participants: Philippe Robert​​.

Stochastic Chemical Reaction​​​‌ Networks with Discontinuous Limits‌ and AIMD processes

In‌​‌ 118 we study a​​ class of stochastic chemical​​​‌ reaction networks (CRNs) for‌ which chemical species are‌​‌ created by a sequence​​ of chain reactions. We​​​‌ prove that under some‌ convenient conditions on the‌​‌ initial state, some of​​ these networks exhibit a​​​‌ discrete-induced transitions (DIT) property:‌ isolated, random, events have‌​‌ a direct impact on​​ the macroscopic state of​​​‌ the process. If this‌ phenomenon has already been‌​‌ noticed in several CRNs,​​ in auto-catalytic networks in​​​‌ the literature of physics‌ in particular, there are‌​‌ up to now few​​ rigorous studies in this​​​‌ domain. A scaling analysis‌ of several cases of‌​‌ such CRNs with several​​ classes of initial states​​​‌ is achieved. The DIT‌ property is investigated for‌​‌ the case of a​​ CRN with four nodes.​​​‌ We show that on‌ the normal timescale and‌​‌ for a subset of​​ (large) initial states and​​​‌ for convenient Skorohod topologies,‌ the scaled process converges‌​‌ in distribution to a​​ Markov process with jumps,​​​‌ an Additive Increase/Multiplicative Decrease‌ (AIMD) process. This asymptotically‌​‌ discontinuous limiting behavior is​​ a consequence of a​​​‌ DIT property due to‌ random, local, blowups of‌​‌ jumps occurring during small​​ time intervals. With an​​​‌ explicit representation of invariant‌ measures of AIMD processes‌​‌ and time-change arguments, we​​ show that, with a​​​‌ speed-up of the timescale,‌ the scaled process is‌​‌ converging in distribution to​​ a continuous deterministic function.​​​‌ The DIT property analyzed‌ in this paper is‌​‌ connected to a simple​​ chain reaction between three​​​‌ chemical species and is‌ therefore likely to be‌​‌ a quite generic phenomenon​​ for a large class​​​‌ of CRNs. Joint work‌ with Lucie Laurence (University‌​‌ of Berne).

Analysis of​​ Stochastic Chemical Reaction Networks​​​‌ with a Hierarchy of‌ Timescales

In 117 we‌​‌ investigate a class of​​ stochastic chemical reaction networks​​​‌ with n1‌ chemical species S1‌​‌, ..., Sn​​, and whose complexes​​​‌ are only of the‌ form kiS‌​‌i, i=​​1,..., n,​​​‌ where (ki‌) are integers. The‌​‌ time evolution of these​​ CRNs is driven by​​​‌ the kinetics of the‌ law of mass action.‌​‌ A scaling analysis is​​ done when the rates​​​‌ of external arrivals of‌ chemical species are proportional‌​‌ to a large scaling​​ parameter N. A​​​‌ natural hierarchy offast processes,‌ a subset of the‌​‌ coordinates of (X​​i(t)​​​‌), is determined‌ by the values of‌​‌ the mapping i↦​​ki. We​​​‌ show that the scaled‌ vector of coordinates i‌​‌ such that ki​​=1 and the​​​‌ scaled occupation measure of‌ the other coordinates are‌​‌ converging in distribution to​​ a deterministic limit as​​​‌ N gets large. The‌ proof of this result‌​‌ is obtained by establishing​​ a functional equation for​​​‌ the limiting points of‌ the occupation measure, by‌​‌ an induction on the​​​‌ hierarchy of timescales and​ with relative entropy functions.​‌ Joint work with Lucie​​ Laurence (University of Berne).​​​‌

Stochastic Models of Resource​ Allocation in Chemical Reaction​‌ Networks

In 22 we​​ investigate a stochastic model​​​‌ of a chemical reaction​ network with three types​‌ of chemical species ℛ​​, and 𝒰​​​‌ that interact to transform​ a flow of external​‌ resources, the chemical species​​ 𝒬, to produce​​​‌ a product, the chemical​ species 𝒫r.​‌ A regulation mechanism involving​​ the sequestration of the​​​‌ chemical species when​ the flow of resources​‌ is too low is​​ investigated. The original motivation​​​‌ of the study is​ of analyzing the qualitative​‌ properties of a key​​ regulation mechanism of gene​​​‌ expression in biological cells,​ the stringent response.​‌

A scaling analysis of​​ a Markov process in​​​‌ 5 representing the​ state of the chemical​‌ reaction network is achieved.​​ It is shown that,​​​‌ depending on the parameters​ of the model, there​‌ are, quite surprisingly, three​​ possible asymptotic regimes. To​​​‌ each of them corresponds​ a stochastic averaging principle​‌ with a fast process​​ expressed in terms of​​​‌ a network of M​/M/∞​‌ queues. One of these​​ regimes, the optimal sequestration​​​‌ regime, does not seem​ to have been identified​‌ up to now. Under​​ this regime, the input​​​‌ flow of resources is​ low but the state​‌ of the network is​​ still acceptable in terms​​​‌ of unused macro-molecules, showing​ the remarkable efficiency of​‌ this regulation mechanism. The​​ technical proofs of the​​​‌ main convergence results rely​ on a combination of​‌ coupling arguments, technical estimates​​ of the solutions of​​​‌ SDEs, of sample paths​ of fast processes in​‌ particular, and the stability​​ properties of some non-linear​​​‌ dynamical systems in ℝ​2. Joint work​‌ with Vincent Fromion (INRAE)​​ and Jana Zaherddine (INRIA-Paris).​​​‌

8.3 Axis 3 –​ Theoretical analysis of nonlinear​‌ partial differential equations (PDE)​​ modelling various structured population​​​‌ dynamics

Participants: Jean Clairambault​, Benoît Perthame,​‌ Nastassia Pouradier Duteil,​​ Lia Sela.

8.3.1​​​‌ Structured Continuity Equations in​ Fibred Wasserstein Spaces

Participants:​‌ Nastassia Pouradier Duteil.​​

In 19, in​​​‌ collaboration with Benoît Bonnet-Weill,​ we developed a comprehensive​‌ ODE-theory for structured continuity​​ equations in fibred measure​​​‌ spaces, which refer to​ a class of heterogeneous​‌ continuity equations arising as​​ the macroscopic approximation of​​​‌ nonexchangeable particle systems. After​ investigating in depth the​‌ topologies induced by the​​ so-called fibred and classical​​​‌ Wasserstein metrics over such​ probability spaces, we studied​‌ both local and nonlocal​​ structured continuity equations over​​​‌ fibred Wasserstein spaces. We​ notably established quantitative Cauchy-Lipschitz​‌ and qualitative Carathéodory-Peano well-posedness​​ results for the latter,​​​‌ along with precise correspondences​ between the latter and​‌ classical Lagrangian dynamics and​​ continuity equations. In keeping​​​‌ with what has long​ been known for exchangeable​‌ particle systems, we provided​​ a general meanfield approximation​​​‌ result for solutions of​ structured continuity equations, along​‌ with a quantitative variant​​ thereof under practically reasonable​​​‌ regularity assumptions on the​ driving field and initial​‌ data.

8.3.2 An integrative​​ phenotype-structured partial differential equation​​ model for the population​​​‌ dynamics of epithelial-mesenchymal transition‌

Participants: Nastassia Pouradier Duteil‌​‌.

In 9,​​ in the framework of​​​‌ Jules Guilberteau's PhD thesis‌ (defended in 2023), we‌​‌ developed a collaboration with​​ a team of system's​​​‌ biologists at the Indian‌ Institute of Science of‌​‌ Bangalore to study epithelial-mesenchymal​​ cell transition using a​​​‌ structured PDE model. Phenotypic‌ heterogeneity along the epithelial-mesenchymal‌​‌ (E-M) axis contributes to​​ cancer metastasis and drug​​​‌ resistance. Recent experimental efforts‌ have collated detailed time-course‌​‌ data on the emergence​​ and dynamics of E-M​​​‌ heterogeneity in a cell‌ population. However, it remains‌​‌ unclear how different possible​​ processes interplay in shaping​​​‌ the dynamics of E-M‌ heterogeneity: a) intracellular regulatory‌​‌ interaction among biomolecules, b)​​ cell division and death,​​​‌ and c) stochastic cell-state‌ transition (biochemical reaction noise‌​‌ and asymmetric cell division).​​ Here, we proposed a​​​‌ Cell Population Balance (Partial‌ Differential Equation (PDE)) based‌​‌ model that captures the​​ dynamics of cell population​​​‌ density along the E-M‌ phenotypic axis due to‌​‌ abovementioned multi-scale cellular processes.​​ We demonstrated how population​​​‌ distribution resulting from intracellular‌ regulatory networks driving cell-state‌​‌ transition gets impacted by​​ stochastic fluctuations in E-M​​​‌ regulatory biomolecules, differences in‌ growth rates among cell‌​‌ subpopulations, and initial population​​ distribution. Further, we revealed​​​‌ that a linear dependence‌ of the cell growth‌​‌ rate on the population​​ heterogeneity is sufficient to​​​‌ recapitulate the faster in‌ vivo growth of orthotopic‌​‌ injected heterogeneous E-M subclones​​ reported before experimentally. Overall,​​​‌ our model contributes to‌ the combined understanding of‌​‌ intracellular and cell-population levels​​ dynamics in the emergence​​​‌ of E-M heterogeneity in‌ a cell population.

8.3.3‌​‌ Modelling phenotypic divergence in​​ cancer and in the​​​‌ emergence of multicellularity by‌ phenotype-structured equations of cell‌​‌ population dynamics

Participants: Jean​​ Clairambault, Lia Sela​​​‌.

Phenotype divergence and‌ cooperation.

The question of‌​‌ understanding the cancer disease​​ from an integrative physiology​​​‌ and long-time evolution point‌ of view has stimulated‌​‌ many authors for quite​​ a long time. In​​​‌ this respect, the atavistic‌ theory of cancer -‌​‌ to which we do​​ not limit our point​​​‌ view, but which offers‌ a coherent framework for‌​‌ our theoretical developments -​​ proposes that tumours represent,​​​‌ roughly speaking, a reverse‌ evolution to a previous,‌​‌ incoherent, disorganised and very​​ plastic state of multicellularity​​​‌ in animals, which the‌ authors call Metazoa 1.0.‌​‌ This theory involves a​​ billion year-long evolutionary perspective​​​‌ of the emergence of‌ multicellularity from collections of‌​‌ unicellular beings to the​​ first organised animals, so-called​​​‌ Urmetazoa. Phenotypic divergence under‌ environmental constraints is involved‌​‌ in both evolutionary/developmental and​​ cancer biology. In the​​​‌ former, it is the‌ fundamental phenomenon by which‌​‌ cell differentiation yields new​​ cell types with emerging​​​‌ functions, leading in particular‌ to multicellular beings such‌​‌ as animals (aka metazoa).​​ In the latter, the​​​‌ process of bet hedging‌ in cancer is a‌​‌ response to cellular stress​​ to describe the multiple​​​‌ fates of a plastic‌ cancer cell population as‌​‌ a fail-safe strategy to​​ face deadly insults, e.g.,​​​‌ due to anticancer drugs.‌ The question of phenotypic‌​‌ divergence in an isogenic​​​‌ cell population is thus​ crucial. We addressed it​‌ in 40 by phenotype-structured​​ PDEs of the reaction-advection-diffusion​​​‌ type, and explore what​ mechanisms (mutations, differentiation, selection)​‌ are responsible for concentration​​ of the population around​​​‌ a unique phenotype (a​ singleton in phenotypic space);​‌ or, on the contrary,​​ for continuous or discrete​​​‌ heterogeneity of the population,​ the discrete cases being​‌ represented by discrete sets​​ of phenotypes, cases among​​​‌ which divergence stricto sensu,​ leading to a doubleton​‌ (phenotypic dimorphism), is the​​ simplest one. To this​​​‌ principle of phenotype divergence​ was added in 94​‌ a point of view​​ on cooperation between divergent​​​‌ cell species, following prisoner’s​ dilemma settings, largely due​‌ to Frank Ernesto Alvarez​​ Borges - it was​​​‌ a chapter of his​ PhD thesis, defended in​‌ December 2023 under the​​ supervision of Stephane Mischler,​​​‌ Dauphine University. This point​ of view, as mentioned​‌ above, applies to both​​ cancer and the constitution​​​‌ of animal multicellularity in​ evolutionary biology. To clarify​‌ the connections between these​​ two fields of research​​​‌ - often mentioned in​ the scientific literature on​‌ cancer, seldom developed -,​​ the notion of animal​​​‌ body plan (Bauplan, plan​ corporel/organisationnel) is studied in​‌ a popularisation paper (in​​ French, with English abstract)​​​‌ 67. The question​ of interactions between phenotype-structured​‌ cell populations has given​​ rise to the PhD​​​‌ thesis of Lia Sela,​ begun in October 2024,​‌ supervised by Emmanuel Trelat​​ (LJLL), Jean Clairambault and​​​‌ Jean-Philippe Foy (CRSA, INSERM,​ St Antoine Hospital), in​‌ the framework of the​​ Programme Doctoral Interdisciplinaire en​​​‌ Cancerologie (PDIC) of Sorbonne​ University. The two cell​‌ populations considered are oral​​ epithelial cells, subject to​​​‌ possible - but not​ mandatory - cancerisation on​‌ the one hand, and​​ on the other hand,​​​‌ populations of resident macrophages​ in the oral cavity.​‌ The simplified continuous phenotypes​​ considered in a first​​​‌ step are a global​ malignancy one for epithelial​‌ cells, and a M2/M1​​ axis characterisation for macrophages.​​​‌

The model has been​ presented by Lia Sela​‌ to a theoretical biology​​ conference in November (J-BIOT​​​‌ 2025, Grenoble). In parallel,​ an article, stepping from​‌ the nucleus published in​​ French (see above 67​​​‌) in 2024, has​ been submitted in 2025​‌ 21. It is​​ meant to settle the​​​‌ grounds of the model​ studied in the framework​‌ of Lia Sela's PhD​​ thesis by extending the​​​‌ classical body plan to​ the notion of a​‌ complete program of animal​​ construction, specific of a​​​‌ given species, plausibly designed​ and maintained in each​‌ tissue, among others, by​​ macrophages, proposed to be​​​‌ the constituents of a​ cohesion watch of the​‌ tissue, a cohesion which​​ is locally disrupted in​​​‌ cancer by lack of​ control on differentiation of​‌ the tissue cells.

8.3.4​​ Analysis of non-local advection-diffusion​​​‌ models for active particles​

Participants: Luca Alasio.​‌

Existence and regularity results.​​

In connection with section​​​‌ 3.3.3 of the Research​ Program, further results have​‌ been obtained in the​​ study of maroscopic models​​​‌ for the evolution of​ the density of active​‌ particles in a periodic​​ setting. Such density depends​​ on tie, space and​​​‌ angle, where the latter‌ is considered as a‌​‌ structure variable. In collaboration​​ with S. Schulz (Université​​​‌ de Versailles Saint-Quentin) 34‌, we studied regularity‌​‌ and uniqueness of weak​​ solutions of a degenerate​​​‌ parabolic equation, arising as‌ the limit of a‌​‌ stochastic lattice model of​​ self-propelled particles. The angle-average​​​‌ of the solution appears‌ as a coefficient in‌​‌ the diffusive and drift​​ terms, making the equation​​​‌ nonlocal. We prove that,‌ under unrestrictive non-degeneracy assumptions‌​‌ on the initial data,​​ weak solutions are smooth​​​‌ for positive times. Our‌ method rests on deriving‌​‌ a drift-diffusion equation for​​ a particular function of​​​‌ the angle-averaged density and‌ applying De Giorgi's method‌​‌ to show that the​​ original equation is uniformly​​​‌ parabolic for positive times.‌ We employ a Galerkin‌​‌ approximation to justify rigorously​​ the passage from divergence​​​‌ to non-divergence form of‌ the equation, which yields‌​‌ improved estimates by exploiting​​ a cancellation. By imposing​​​‌ stronger constraints on the‌ initial data, we prove‌​‌ the uniqueness of the​​ weak solution, which relies​​​‌ on Duhamel's principle and‌ gradient estimates for the‌​‌ periodic heat kernel to​​ derive L estimates​​​‌ for the angle-averaged density.‌ We are working towards‌​‌ the extension of such​​ results to other models,​​​‌ including those derived in‌ recent years by M.‌​‌ Bruna (University of Oxford)​​ and collaborators (see 125​​​‌).

8.3.5 On a‌ relaxed Cahn-Hilliard tumour growth‌​‌ model with single-well potential​​ and degenerate mobility

Participants:​​​‌ Benoit Perthame.

In‌ 20, we consider‌​‌ a phase-field system modelling​​ solid tumour growth. This​​​‌ system consists of a‌ Cahn-Hilliard equation coupled with‌​‌ a nutrient equation. The​​ former is characterised by​​​‌ a degenerate mobility and‌ a singular potential. Both‌​‌ equations are subject to​​ suitable reaction terms which​​​‌ model proliferation and nutrient‌ consumption. Chemotactic effects are‌​‌ also taken into account.​​ Adding an elliptic regularisation,​​​‌ depending on a relaxation‌ parameter , in the‌​‌ equation for the chemical​​ potential, we prove the​​​‌ existence of a weak‌ solution to an initial‌​‌ and boundary value problem​​ for the relaxed system.​​​‌ Then, we let go‌ to zero, and we‌​‌ recover the existence of​​ a weak solution to​​​‌ the original system.

8.3.6‌ Mathematical analysis of macroscopic‌​‌ models for neurons

Participants:​​ Benoit Perthame.

This​​​‌ section summarizes the recent‌ results obtained in the‌​‌ analysis of various macroscopic​​ models for neuronal dynamics.​​​‌

Wasserstein contraction for the‌ stochastic Morris-Lecar neuron model‌​‌

In 10, we​​ are interested in studying​​​‌ long-time and large-population emerging‌ properties in a simplified‌​‌ toy model for neuron​​ dynamics. From a mathematical​​​‌ perspective, we study the‌ long-time behaviour of a‌​‌ degenerate reflected diffusion process.​​ Using coupling arguments, the​​​‌ flow is proven to‌ be a contraction of‌​‌ the Wasserstein distance for​​ long times, which implies​​​‌ the exponential relaxation toward‌ a (non-explicit) unique globally‌​‌ attractive equilibrium distribution. The​​ result is extended to​​​‌ a McKean-Vlasov type non-linear‌ variation of the model,‌​‌ when the mean-field interaction​​ is sufficiently small. The​​​‌ ergodicity of the process‌ results from a combination‌​‌ of deterministic contraction properties​​​‌ and local diffusion, the​ noise being sufficient to​‌ drive the system away​​ from non-contractive domains.

Strongly​​​‌ nonlinear age structured equation,time-elapsed​ model and large delays​‌

In 11, we​​ study the time-elapsed model​​​‌ for neural networks, a​ nonlinear age structured equation​‌ where the renewal term​​ describes the network activity​​​‌ and influences the discharge​ rate, possibly with a​‌ delay due to the​​ length of connections. We​​​‌ solve a long standing​ question, namely that an​‌ inhibitory network without delay​​ will converge to a​​​‌ steady state and thus​ the network is desynchonised.​‌ Our approach is based​​ on the observation that​​​‌ a non-expansion property holds​ true. However a non-degeneracy​‌ condition is needed and,​​ besides the standard one,​​​‌ we introduce a new​ condition based on strict​‌ nonlinearity. When a delay​​ is included, and following​​​‌ previous works for Fokker-Planck​ models, we prove that​‌ the network may generate​​ periodic solutions. We introduce​​​‌ a new formalism to​ establish rigorously this property​‌ for large delays. The​​ fundamental contraction property also​​​‌ holds for some other​ age structured equations and​‌ systems

A Fokker-Planck equation​​ with superlinear drift at​​​‌ infinity for Integrate-and-Fire model​

The Integrate-and-Fire model is​‌ a Fokker-Planck equation arising​​ in neuroscience. It describes​​​‌ the evolution of the​ probability density of the​‌ neuronal membrane potential and​​ fitting has shown that​​​‌ the inclusion of a​ em superlinear drift provides​‌ the most realistic description.​​ To make sense of​​​‌ this, we propose in​ 23 to set the​‌ equation on the full​​ line, the neural activity​​​‌ being described by the​ flux at infinity. This​‌ framework serves as a​​ model extension of the​​​‌ classical Noisy Integrate-and-Fire model,​ with a fixed firing​‌ potential. We first establish​​ the well-posedness of the​​​‌ solution, establish the boundary​ condition at infinity which​‌ is the major difficulty.​​ Then, state rigorously the​​​‌ entropy dissipation property. Finally,​ using Doeblin's method, we​‌ prove the exponential convergence​​ of the solution toward​​​‌ the unique stationary state​ in full generality.

8.4​‌ Axis 4 – Mathematical​​ epidemiology

Participants: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman​​​‌, Marcel Fang,​ Manon de la Tousche​‌, Morgane Doukhan.​​

8.4.1 Biological control of​​​‌ vectors

Participants: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman​, Manon de la​‌ Tousche, Morgane Doukhan​​.

Feasibility and optimization​​​‌ results for elimination by​ mass-trapping in a metapopulation​‌ model

Having in mind​​ the issue of control​​​‌ of insects vectors or​ insects pests, we considered​‌ in 6 a metapopulation​​ model with patches linearly​​​‌ interconnected, and explore the​ global effects of the​‌ (on purpose) increase of​​ mortality in some of​​​‌ them. Based on previous​ results by Y. Takeuchi​‌ et al., we showed​​ that under appropriate conditions,​​​‌ the sign of the​ stability modulus of the​‌ Jacobian of the system​​ at the origin determines​​​‌ the asymptotic behaviour of​ the solutions. If it​‌ is non-positive, then the​​ population becomes extinct in​​​‌ every patch. Conversely, if​ it is positive, then​‌ there exists a unique​​ nonnegative equilibrium, which is​​​‌ positive and globally asymptotically​ stable. In the latter​‌ case, given a subset​​ of 'controlled' patches where​​ human intervention is allowed,​​​‌ through mass-trapping for instance,‌ we studied whether the‌​‌ introduction of additional linear​​ mortality in some of​​​‌ them can result in‌ population elimination in every‌​‌ patch. We characterized this​​ possibility by an algebraic​​​‌ property on the Jacobian‌ at the origin of‌​‌ a so-called residual system.​​ We then assessed the​​​‌ minimal globally asymptotically stable‌ equilibrium that may be‌​‌ attained in this way,​​ and when elimination is​​​‌ possible, we studied the‌ optimization problem consisting in‌​‌ achieving this task while​​ minimizing a certain cost​​​‌ function, chosen as a‌ nondecreasing and convex function‌​‌ of the mortality rates​​ added in the controlled​​​‌ patches. We showed that‌ such minimization problem admits‌​‌ a global minimizer, which​​ is unique in the​​​‌ relevant cases. An interior‌ point algorithm was proposed‌​‌ to compute the numerical​​ solution.

Sterile Insect Technique​​​‌ in a n-patch system‌ with Allee effect and‌​‌ mass trapping: modeling, analysis​​ and simulations

The sterile​​​‌ insect technique (SIT) is‌ a biological control method‌​‌ aimed at reducing or​​ eliminating populations of pests​​​‌ or disease vectors. This‌ technique involves releasing sterilised‌​‌ insects which, by mating​​ with wild individuals, will​​​‌ reduce the target population.‌ In 18, we‌​‌ took into account the​​ spatial dimension by modelling​​​‌ the pest/vector population as‌ being distributed over several‌​‌ plots, with wild insects​​ and sterile insects migrating​​​‌ between these plots. The‌ main objective was to‌​‌ identify the critical plots​​ for intervention, using the​​​‌ network connectivity and potential‌ intervention constraints.

Using results‌​‌ from monotone systems theory,​​ we first derived a​​​‌ sufficient condition guaranteeing the‌ elimination of the wild‌​‌ population through SIT, which​​ relies on the sign​​​‌ of the Perron value‌ of a certain Metzler‌​‌ matrix. When an Allee​​ effect is naturally present,​​​‌ releases are finite in‌ time, and an upper‌​‌ bound of the control​​ time is provided. We​​​‌ then formulated an optimisation‌ problem aimed at minimising‌​‌ the total daily number​​ of sterile insects released​​​‌ to ensure population elimination.‌ We focused in particular‌​‌ on the oriental fruit​​ fly, which significantly impacts​​​‌ mango orchards in La‌ Réunion.

Through numerical simulations,‌​‌ we illustrated our theoretical​​ results and study different​​​‌ scenarios, including some where‌ releases are limited to‌​‌ certain orchards. Indeed, when​​ implementing SIT in the​​​‌ field, some owners may‌ be reluctant to allow‌​‌ releases on their property.​​ We also considered additional​​​‌ control by mass trapping,‌ which can affect the‌​‌ sterile insects entering trapped​​ areas, and showed that​​​‌ although it increases the‌ critical number of sterile‌​‌ insects to be released​​ daily, it reduces the​​​‌ duration of the SIT‌ program. Mass trapping may‌​‌ thus decrease the total​​ number of sterile insects​​​‌ released over the entire‌ elimination program.

Basic offspring‌​‌ number and robust feedback​​ design for the biological​​​‌ control of vectors by‌ sterile insect release technique‌​‌

Sterile Insect Technique (SIT)​​ is a promising control​​​‌ method against insect pests‌ and insect vectors. It‌​‌ consists in releasing males​​ previously sterilized in laboratory,​​​‌ in order to reduce‌ or eliminate a specific‌​‌ wild population. We studied​​​‌ in 12 the implementation​ by feedback control of​‌ SIT-based elimination campaign of​​ Aedes mosquitoes. We provided​​​‌ state-feedback and output-feedback control​ laws and establish their​‌ convergence, as well as​​ their robustness properties. In​​​‌ this design procedure, a​ pivotal role is played​‌ by the average number​​ of secondary female insects​​​‌ produced by a single​ female insect, called basic​‌ offspring number, and by​​ the use of properties​​​‌ of monotone systems. Illustrative​ simulations were provided.

Feedback​‌ design for biological control​​ by the sterile insect​​​‌ release technique exploiting monotone​ system theory

The Sterile​‌ Insect Technique (SIT) is​​ a promising control method​​​‌ against insect pests and​ insect vectors. It consists​‌ in releasing males previously​​ sterilized in laboratory, in​​​‌ order to reduce or​ eliminate a specific wild​‌ population. We studied in​​ 3 the implementation of​​​‌ SIT-based elimination campaign of​ Aedes mosquitoes using feedback​‌ control. We provided state-feedback​​ and output-feedback control laws​​​‌ and establish their convergence,​ as well as their​‌ robustness properties. In this​​ design procedure, a pivotal​​​‌ role was played by​ the use of properties​‌ of monotone systems. Simple​​ illustrative simulations were provided.​​​‌

8.4.2 Control of infectious​ diseases

Participants: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman​‌, Marcel Fang,​​ Bernard Cazelles.

Reinfection​​​‌ induced multistability in an​ epidemic model

We considered​‌ in 5 the effects​​ induced on the dynamics​​​‌ of disease transmission by​ differences between primary and​‌ subsequent infections (i.e. reinfections),​​ due e.g. to enhancement​​​‌ or weakening of the​ susceptibility or infectivity. To​‌ this end, an 8-dimensional​​ 'two-stage' SEIRS reinfection model​​​‌ was considered, extending the​ classical 4-dimensional SEIRS model.​‌ We characterized the steady​​ states of the model​​​‌ according to the basic​ reproduction number R0. We​‌ showed that the reinfection​​ induced heterogeneity may cause​​​‌ up to two endemic​ equilibria when 0​‌<1, and​​ up to three endemic​​​‌ equilibria otherwise. Specifically, this​ suggests that the model​‌ may present backward bifurcation​​ for 0=​​​‌1, a feature​ quite important from the​‌ point of view of​​ disease control; and two​​​‌ successive saddle node bifurcations​ for 0<​‌1. Simulations confirmed​​ this situation. The disease​​​‌ persistence of the model​ has been also examined.​‌ Finally, we proved, for​​ two specific SIRI and​​​‌ SEIRE models accounting for​ partial immunity and demography,​‌ the asymptotic convergence of​​ every trajectory to a​​​‌ steady state. Notably, these​ particular cases still admit​‌ up to two endemic​​ equilibria (when R0 ă​​​‌ 1), which makes this​ result non trivial. The​‌ proof is based on​​ an application of Li​​​‌ & Muldowney theory to​ epidemiological systems with multiple​‌ endemic equilibriums.

On the​​ problem of minimizing the​​​‌ epidemic final size for​ SIR model by social​‌ distancing

We revisited in​​ 4 the problem of​​​‌ minimizing the epidemic final​ size in the SIR​‌ model through social distancing​​ of bounded intensity. In​​​‌ the existing literature, this​ problem has been considered​‌ imposing a priori interval​​ structure on the time​​​‌ period when interventions are​ enforced. We showed that​‌ when considering the more​​ general class of controls​​ with an L1​​​‌ constraint on the confinement‌ effort that reduces the‌​‌ infection rate, the support​​ of the optimal control​​​‌ is still a single‌ time interval. This shows‌​‌ that, for this problem,​​ there is no benefit​​​‌ in splitting interventions on‌ several disjoint time periods.‌​‌ However, if the infection​​ rate is known beforehand​​​‌ to change with time‌ once from one value‌​‌ to another one, then​​ we showed that the​​​‌ optimal solution could consist‌ in splitting the interventions‌​‌ in at most two​​ disjoint time periods.

8.5​​​‌ Axis 5 – Development‌ and analysis of mathematical‌​‌ models for biological tissues​​ confronted to experimental data​​​‌

Participants: Nastassia Pouradier Duteil‌, Diane Peurichard,‌​‌ Sophie Hecht, Luca​​ Alasio.

8.5.1 Modeling​​​‌ of milling and schooling‌ in gregarious fish

Participants:‌​‌ Nastassia Pouradier Duteil,​​ Sam Gaborieau.

We​​​‌ have initiated a collaboration‌ with R. Godoy-Diana and‌​‌ B. Thiria of the​​ laboratory PMMH of ESPCI,​​​‌ in order to focus‌ on exploring the effect‌​‌ of two main mechanisms​​ in the collective behavior​​​‌ of gragarious fish (Hemmigramus‌ rhodostomus): (i) the individuals'‌​‌ fields of vision; and​​ (ii) the population's heterogeneity.​​​‌ Both mechanisms are particularly‌ challenging to study exclusively‌​‌ through numerical experiments, which​​ justifies the tight collaboration​​​‌ between the two teams.‌ Together with Benjamin Thiria‌​‌ and Laurent Boudin, we​​ are currently co-supervising a​​​‌ PhD student, Sam Gaborieau,‌ who won an INLIFE‌​‌ fellowship (Initiative sciences aux​​ interfaces du vivent) to​​​‌ study numerically and experimentally‌ the phase transition in‌​‌ fish collective behavior.

8.5.2​​ Modeling of biological tissue​​​‌ emergence and repair

Participants:‌ Diane Peurichard, Sophie‌​‌ Hecht, Pierre-Alexandre Grott​​.

This subsection presents​​​‌ our previous and current‌ activities towards biological tissue‌​‌ modeling using an agent-based​​ formalism. This section is​​​‌ based on a long‌ standing collaboration with the‌​‌ RESTORE laboratory (biological lab​​ in Toulouse), with whom​​​‌ we developed a 2D‌ computational agent based-model (ABM,‌​‌ cf 150), enabling​​ to recapitulate the emergence​​​‌ of complex adipose tissue‌ architectures in 2D via‌​‌ simple physical principles between​​ their core components (cells​​​‌ and fibers). When extended‌ to account for the‌​‌ mechanisms of repair after​​ injury 149, 142​​​‌ (combined in-silico/in-vivo study at‌ the core of the‌​‌ PhD of A. Pacary,​​ 2021-2024, defended december 2024),​​​‌ the model enabled to‌ suggest a new in-vivo‌​‌ validated therapeutic target (ECM​​ cross-linking) and a temporal​​​‌ window of modulation of‌ this parameter to induce‌​‌ regeneration in adult mammals​​ adipose tissues. These studies​​​‌ opened new therapeutic approaches‌ targeting ECM cross-linking to‌​‌ induce tissue regeneration in​​ adult mammals, and positioned​​​‌ our computational model as‌ a solid candidate for‌​‌ digital twinning. We hereby​​ present the current works​​​‌ developed with the RESTORE‌ laboratory around this modeling‌​‌ framework.

Towards the extension​​ to 3D

The PhD​​​‌ of P. Chassonnery (2021-2024,‌ defended december 2024) was‌​‌ devoted to the extension​​ of our 2D modeling​​​‌ framework for biological tissues‌ to 3D, accompanied by‌​‌ modeling, computational and analysis/vizualization​​ challenges. The goal was​​​‌ to explore whether simple‌ mechanical rules between simple‌​‌ geometric agents (spheres appearing​​​‌ and growing in a​ dynamically connected spherocylinders network)​‌ could be sufficient to​​ explain the emergence of​​​‌ complex 3D architectures (clustering​ of cells in lobular​‌ structures surrounded by 2D​​ sheets of fibers). We​​​‌ first focused on the​ extracellular-matrix (ECM), the complex​‌ interconnected three-dimensional network providing​​ structural support for the​​​‌ cells and key for​ tissue healthy functioning. In​‌ 145, we proposed​​ a simple three-dimensional individual​​​‌ based model of interacting​ fibres able to spontaneously​‌ crosslink or unlink to​​ each other and align​​​‌ at the crosslinks. We​ showed that such systems​‌ are able to spontaneously​​ generate different types of​​​‌ architectures, and provided a​ thorough analysis of the​‌ emerging structures, using appropriate​​ visualization tools and quantifiers​​​‌ in three dimensions. The​ most striking result was​‌ that the emergence of​​ ordered structures could be​​​‌ fully explained by a​ single emerging variable: the​‌ number of links per​​ fibre in the network.​​​‌ If validated on real​ tissues, this simple variable​‌ could become an important​​ putative target to control​​​‌ and predict the structuring​ of biological tissues, to​‌ suggest possible new therapeutic​​ strategies to restore tissue​​​‌ functions after disruption, and​ to help in the​‌ development of collagen-based scaffolds​​ for tissue engineering.

We​​​‌ then extended these works​ for building a complete​‌ 3D model for tissue​​ morphogenesis. By letting cells​​​‌ (3D spheres) appear and​ differentiate in our interconnected​‌ 3D network of spherocylinders,​​ we showed that simple​​​‌ mechanical rules could drive​ the emergence of realistic​‌ Adipose Tissue architectures, without​​ the need for complex​​​‌ predetermined genetic programs for​ the biological laws. For​‌ their evolutionary perspectives, we​​ are currently submitting these​​​‌ works to generic multidisciplinary​ journals such as Science​‌ Advances.

Exploring the mechanisms​​ of ageing

Our works​​​‌ on tissue architecture development​ and repair naturally led​‌ to various perspectives in​​ the study of ageing.​​​‌

  • Ageing as a scar:​In the PhD of​‌ P-A Grott (co-direction J.​​ Paupert (RESTORE) and D.​​​‌ Peurichard), we are currently​ exploring whether ageing could​‌ be seen as an​​ accumulation of unperfect tissue​​​‌ repairs induced by repeated​ small lesions. Biologist of​‌ formation, P-A Grott is​​ currently exploring this hypothesis​​​‌ by in-silico experimentations, through​ the use of the​‌ simulation software tissueMORPH developed​​ by the MUSCLEES team​​​‌ (GUI interface embarking computational​ and segmentation tools for​‌ easy tuning of parameters,​​ simulation and analysis for​​​‌ the morphogenesis and repair​ models). Among others, we​‌ are currently exploring the​​ impact of repeated lesions​​​‌ varying their size, frequency​ and location, on the​‌ stability of the overall​​ tissue architectures. In parallel,​​​‌ P-A Grott PhD will​ aim to mechanically characterize​‌ the in-silico tissues by​​ implementation and analysis of​​​‌ mechanical assays compared to​ experimental assays performed at​‌ Université de Montpellier (C.​​ Cavinato). These work will​​​‌ enable to assess the​ global behavior and stability​‌ of our in silico​​ tissues to repeated perturbations,​​​‌ and, if successful, will​ enable to get precious​‌ insights on (i) the​​ connection between a tissue​​​‌ global mechanical state and​ its microarchitecture and (ii)​‌ the link between tissue​​ architectures and their function.​​
  • Accounting for external energy​​​‌ incomes: The previous‌ project approaches the question‌​‌ of ageing in a​​ mechanical angle, questioning the​​​‌ stability of our in-silico‌ tissues to repeated mechanical‌​‌ perturbations. In parallel, we​​ aim to explore another​​​‌ angle where stability is‌ questioned in terms of‌​‌ variations in chemical energy​​ incomes. These questions are​​​‌ at the core of‌ the ENERGENCE project (ANR‌​‌ Synergie MUSCLEES-RESTORE, PI D.​​ Peurichard, 2022-2027), where we​​​‌ aim to include thermodynamically‌ relevant biological rules (cell‌​‌ differentiation, growth, ECM crosslinking)​​ linking tissue growth to​​​‌ external energy exchange. These‌ extensions have been started‌​‌ in the post-doctorate of​​ S. Toste (2024-2025), and​​​‌ are at the core‌ of the post-doctorate of‌​‌ Louis Fostier (feb 2026-feb​​ 2027). If successful, the​​​‌ extended model will allow‌ to question the stability‌​‌ of the spatial architecture​​ by playing on external​​​‌ income fluxes, and the‌ model will serve for‌​‌ exploring various disease states​​ such as obesity.
On​​​‌ the genericity of the‌ model rules for biological‌​‌ tissue modeling

One of​​ the very interesting feature​​​‌ of the model previously‌ described, and calibrated on‌​‌ adipose tissues, is that​​ it contains very generic​​​‌ rules that are not‌ exclusive to these particular‌​‌ tissues. Almost all biological​​ tissues feature an ECM​​​‌ scaffold that provide support‌ for cell differentiation, migration‌​‌ etc, and all biological​​ tissues are organized into​​​‌ specialized niches with proper‌ architecture and function (very‌​‌ elongated and globally aligned​​ structures in teh muscles/tendons,​​​‌ lobular architecture in the‌ liver, network structures for‌​‌ the vascular system and​​ nerves etc). Therefore, a​​​‌ natural question we are‌ currently exploring is whether‌​‌ the AT framework could​​ be easily extended to​​​‌ model other types of‌ tissues. First works in‌​‌ this direction (internship of​​ V. Brulard, summer 2025,​​​‌ co-directed with S. Hecht‌ and D. Peurichard) suggested‌​‌ that the globally aligned​​ structures of the muscle​​​‌ could indeed by reproduced‌ by a simple model‌​‌ of dynamically connected anisotropic​​ agents, and we are​​​‌ currently looking for new‌ internship/PhD candidates to couple‌​‌ these ECM models with​​ differentiated cells. These topics​​​‌ are at the core‌ of the ANR JCJC‌​‌ of S. Hecht (submitted​​ in october 2025), towards​​​‌ the modeling of mucuous‌ membrane architecture.

8.5.3 Modelling‌​‌ the Retinal Pigment Epithelium​​ in Age-Related Macular Degeneration​​​‌

Participants: Luca Alasio,‌ Sophie Hecht, Diane‌​‌ Peurichard, Naoufel Cresson​​, Clara Choukroun.​​​‌

Towards a mechanistic approach‌ to study the growth‌​‌ of lesions.

In agreement​​ with section 3.5.6 of​​​‌ the Research Program, we‌ are collaborating with the‌​‌ group of Prof. M.​​ Pâques at Hôpital National​​​‌ des Quinze-Vingts in order‌ to model the evolution‌​‌ and growth of lesions​​ in dry Age-Related Macular​​​‌ Degeneration. The PhD project‌ of N. Cresson, co-supervised‌​‌ by L. Alasio, Prof.​​ M. Szopos (Université Paris​​​‌ Cité) and M. Pâques‌ (Hôpital National des Quinze-Vingts),‌​‌ is most relevant in​​ this research direction. We​​​‌ have built a macroscopic‌ visco-elastic models reproducing RPE‌​‌ deformations qualitatively, and we​​ are working on a​​​‌ complete simulation pipeline from‌ segmented images to a‌​‌ simulated dynamics over time.Well-posedness​​​‌ analysis of the visco-elastic​ system of PDEs and​‌ the associated free-boundary problem​​ for the atrophic lesion​​​‌ is in progress. We​ continue the study of​‌ efficient and robust methods​​ for numerical simulations, with​​​‌ particular attention to parameter​ calibration and to integration​‌ of clinical data in​​ the model. We obtained​​​‌ convincing preliminary results with​ simulations in FreeFEM of​‌ significant cases involving fusion​​ of lesions, asymmetric growth​​​‌ and foveal sparing. Naoufel​ Cresson has been working​‌ on several aspects of​​ the problem, including modelisation,​​​‌ meshing, simulation, code optimisation,​ numerical analysis, analysis of​‌ PDEs. Clara Choukroun (Ingénieure​​ d'études, Sorbonne Université) joined​​​‌ this project in December​ 2025, giving a notable​‌ contribution in terms of​​ coding and image segmentation.​​​‌

Towards a mechanistic approach​ to study the healthy​‌ RPE.

In order to​​ get a better understanding​​​‌ of Age-Related Macular Degeneration​ it is interesting to​‌ understand how the healthy​​ tissue behaves and which​​​‌ rules control its homeostasis​ over several years (or​‌ even a lifetime). Together​​ with L. Alasio, S.​​​‌ Hecht, M. Szopos, D.​ Peurichard, we are collaborating​‌ with the group of​​ Prof. M. Pâques at​​​‌ Hôpital National des Quinze-Vingts​ towards the development of​‌ a microscopic agent-based model​​ for RPE maintenance and/or​​​‌ ageing. We investigate which​ rules in the model​‌ allow the epithelial tissue​​ to keep its structure​​​‌ isolated cell deaths or​ small scars occur (we​‌ do not consider large​​ lesions at the moment).​​​‌ The project as started​ this year and may​‌ in the future be​​ related to experimentsl results​​​‌ (currently in progress).

8.5.4​ Mathematical models of retinal​‌ biochemistry

Participants: Luca Alasio​​.

Towards better models​​​‌ for the visual cycle.​

In agreement with section​‌ 3.5.5 of the Research​​ Program, we are investigating​​​‌ improved models for the​ dynamics of the visual​‌ cycle in photoreceptors. Since​​ the autumn of 2025,​​​‌ L. Alasio is supervising​ an M2 project involving​‌ E. Bedek (M2 student,​​ ENSTA). The project focuses​​​‌ on simulation and comparison​ of different ODE and​‌ PDE models for the​​ key biochemical steps in​​​‌ the visual cycle. Preliminary​ results obtained in this​‌ context have promoted an​​ ongoing collaboration with Dr.​​​‌ C. Schwarz (University of​ Tubingen) and with Dr.​‌ Ph. Kiser (UC Irvine).​​ Further analysis and experimental​​​‌ results are necessary, but​ the preliminary results are​‌ encouraging. Even in the​​ absence of a complete​​​‌ dataset for the reaction​ kinetics, alternative tools for​‌ model comparison and validation​​ are being examined.

8.5.5​​​‌ Modelling bacterial micro-colony growth​

Participants: Sophie Hecht,​‌ Diane Peurichard.

This​​ project is a collaboration​​​‌ between N Desprat (ABCD​ biophysics Lab - ENS),​‌ S. Hecht, D. Peurichard​​ and the post-doctorate H.​​​‌ Horii (end of contract​ October 2025) funded by​‌ IMPT. We developed an​​ individual-based model where each​​​‌ bacterium is modeled by​ a string of spheres​‌ linked with linear and​​ angular springs. This description​​​‌ allows local bending of​ the individual bacteria. Numerical​‌ simulations have showed that​​ the curvature of the​​​‌ bacteria modify the global​ organisations of the micro-colony​‌ and reproduce the dense​​ organisation we observe experimentally.​​ A characteristic we were​​​‌ focused on, since it‌ controls the capacity of‌​‌ the colony to create​​ a barrier with its​​​‌ environment. The next part‌ of the project is‌​‌ a rigorous comparaison with​​ experimental data on different​​​‌ strains of bacteria.

8.5.6‌ Modelling ovocyte deformation

Participants:‌​‌ Sophie Hecht, Diane​​ Peurichard.

The CIRB​​​‌ lab (Centre interdisciplinaire de‌ recherche en biologie) of‌​‌ the College de France​​ is working on developing​​​‌ a micro-constriction setup to‌ facilitate ovocyte selection for‌​‌ FIV. Together with D.​​ Peurichard, S. Hecht, and​​​‌ L. Barbier (CIRB) we‌ are developing a model‌​‌ to reproduce the deformation​​ of mice ovocyte in​​​‌ AFM and micro-constriction experiments.‌ The objective is to‌​‌ optimise the transition of​​ the experimental setup to​​​‌ human ovocyte study.

9‌ Partnerships and cooperations

9.1‌​‌ International initiatives

9.1.1 STIC/MATH/CLIMAT​​ AmSud projects

BIO-CIVIP
  • Title:​​​‌
    Biological Control of Insect‌ Vectors and Insect Pests‌​‌
  • Program:
    STIC-AmSud
  • Duration:
    2​​ years – (2024-2025)
  • Local​​​‌ supervisor:

    Participants: Pierre-Alexandre Bliman‌, Manon de la‌​‌ Tousche.

    Pierre-Alexandre Bliman​​

  • Partners:
    • Brazil
      • Universidade Federal​​​‌ Fluminense, Niteroi
      • Universidade Estadual‌ Paulista “Júlio de Mesquita‌​‌ Filho”, Câmpus de Botucatu​​
      • Universidade de São Paulo​​​‌
      • Universidade Federal de Rio‌ de Janeiro
      • Fundação Oswaldo‌​‌ Cruz, Rio de Janeiro​​
    • Chile
      • Universidad de Chile,​​​‌ Santiago
      • Universidad Técnica Federico‌ Santa Maria, Valparaiso
    • Colombia‌​‌
      • Universidad Autónoma de Occidente,​​ Cali
      • Universidad del Valle,​​​‌ Cali
    • France
      • Institut de‌ Mathématiques de Bordeaux -‌​‌ UMR 5152
      • Laboratoire Jacques-Louis​​ Lions, UMR 7598
      • Laboratoire​​​‌ de Mathématiques et Applications,‌ UMR 7348
      • Laboratoire d'analyse,‌​‌ géométrie et application, UMR​​ 7539
      • Centres de recherche​​​‌ Inria Paris, Nancy-Grand Est,‌ Lyon
      • CIRAD, Montpellier
      • UMR‌​‌ MISTEA (INRAE/SupAgro), Montpellier
    • Paraguay​​
      • LCCA-NIDTEC, Polytechnic School, National​​​‌ University of Asuncion
  • Inria‌ contact:
    Pierre-Alexandre Bliman
  • Summary:‌​‌
    The project BIO-CIVIP is​​ concerned with the mathematical​​​‌ study of new biological‌ control strategies. It concerns‌​‌ on the one hand​​ insect vectors of important​​​‌ diseases that put at‌ risk considerable portions of‌​‌ the human population, and​​ on the other hand​​​‌ insect pests that damage‌ crops and food production.‌​‌ Generally speaking, biological control​​ methods aim at controlling​​​‌ pests or vectors using‌ other organisms. Building on‌​‌ the similarities of the​​ control methods and the​​​‌ potential synergy between the‌ two fields, our goal‌​‌ is to elaborate and​​ analyze mathematical models adapted​​​‌ to several specific applications‌ of interest, and to‌​‌ evaluate qualitatively and quantitatively​​ different control strategies. Our​​​‌ efforts will aim in‌ particular at understanding the‌​‌ key aspects and parameters​​ of insect vector and​​​‌ pest dynamics in their‌ temporal and spatial spread,‌​‌ testing control principles and​​ concepts, estimating feasibility and​​​‌ robustness, identifying risks and‌ reducing cost.

9.2 International‌​‌ research visitors

9.2.1 Visits​​ to international teams

Sabbatical​​​‌ programme
Nastassia Pouradier Duteil‌
  • Visited institution:
    Universidad de‌​‌ Granada (Espagne)
  • Dates of​​ the stay:
    From Wed​​​‌ Jan 01 2025 to‌ Wed Dec 31 2025‌​‌
  • Summary of the stay:​​
    Nastassia Pouradier Duteil spent​​​‌ the year 2025 at‌ the University of Granada‌​‌ (Spain) in the framework​​ of a Sabbatical Year.​​​‌ This opportunity allowed her‌ to intensify the existing‌​‌ collaboration with David Poyato​​​‌ and initiate a collaboration​ with Julián Cabrera-Nyst, on​‌ the mean-field limits of​​ non-exchangeable particle systems. It​​​‌ also allowed to initiate​ a collaboration with David​‌ Nicholas Reynolds on the​​ collective behavior of non-exchangeable​​​‌ particle systems leading to​ milling or consensus. Ongoing​‌ discussions with Gissell Estrada-Rodriguez,​​ Victor Villegas Moral, Juan​​​‌ Soler and Carlos Pulido​ were also initated during​‌ this stay and will​​ likely lead to research​​​‌ projects.

10 Dissemination

10.1​ Promoting scientific activities

10.1.1​‌ Journal

Philippe Robert is​​ an associate editor of​​​‌ the journal "Stochastic Models".​

Reviewer - reviewing activities​‌

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman has been​​ reviewer for the journals​​​‌ Mathematical Biosciences, Journal of​ Mathematical Biology, Systems and​‌ Control Letters.

Jean Clairambault​​ has been handling editor​​​‌ for Mathematical Modelling of​ Natural Phenomena and for​‌ PLoS Computational Biology, and​​ reviewer for the journals​​​‌ Scientific Reports, npj Systems​ Biology, Cancer Research, J​‌ Math Biol, Cells.

Nastassia​​ Pouradier Duteil has been​​​‌ reviewer for the journals​ Kinetic and Related Models,​‌ Mathematical Control and Related​​ Fields, Foundations of Computational​​​‌ Mathematics, Networks and Heterogeneous​ Media.

Diane Peurichard has​‌ been reviewer for Journal​​ of Mathematical Biology, Physical​​​‌ Review D.

Luca Alasio​ has acted as reviewer​‌ for the following journals:​​ Zeitschrift für angewandte Mathematik​​​‌ und Physik, Artificial Intelligence​ in Vision and Ophthalmology,​‌ SIAM Journal on Mathematical​​ Analysis, Boundary Value Problems,​​​‌ Journal of Differential Equations.​

10.1.2 Invited talks

Pierre-Alexandre​‌ Bliman presented contributions at​​ the conferences Biomath (Sofia,​​​‌ Bulgaria, June) and European​ Control Conference (Thessaloniki, Greece,​‌ July). He also presented​​ seminars at COPPE, Universidade​​​‌ Federal de Rio de​ Janeiro (November)and GT Contrôle​‌ at Laboratoire Jacques-Louis Lions​​ (December).

Jean Clairambault was​​​‌ invited to give a​ talk at the conference​‌ "Second Workshop on Multiscale​​ and Nonlocal Problems in​​​‌ PDEs" on June 19​ and 20, 2025 in​‌ Bari at the Politecnico​​ to celebrate the conclusion​​​‌ of the PRIN 2022​ "Evolution problem involving interacting​‌ scales". He was also​​ invited to give a​​​‌ virtual seminar at the​ "Online conference on Mathematical​‌ modelling in biology and​​ medicine, May 19-23, 2025"​​​‌ organised by Vitaly Volpert,​ and to give a​‌ talk at the "Premières​​ journées de la biologie​​​‌ théorique" (J-BIOT 2025), Nov.​ 24-25, 2025, Grenoble.

Nastassia​‌ Pouradier Duteil was invited​​ to present at the​​​‌ Gazteak Spanish Conference of​ Young Researchers in Mathematics​‌ (Bilbao, Spain), at the​​ workshop “Cabo de Gata​​​‌ PDE days”, (Almeria, Spain),​ at the INdAM workshop​‌ “Differential equations and nonlinear​​ models”, (Rome, Italy), and​​​‌ at the conference “Population​ dynamics: model design, optimization​‌ & control” (Nice, France).​​ She was also invited​​​‌ to give a seminar​ at the Partial Differential​‌ Equations Seminar, University of​​ Granada (Spain).

Diane Peurichard​​​‌ was invited to the​ Workshop for Young Women​‌ in Math Biology (Bonn,​​ germany), the conférence 'Round​​​‌ Meanfield IV: N-body sul​ Canal Grande' (Venise, Italy),​‌ the Theoretical Biology days​​ (JBIOT Grenoble, France), and​​​‌ working seminars in France​ (Nice, Institut Biomécanique, Paris,​‌ Math-bio days, Toulouse)

Luca​​ Alasio gave a presentation​​​‌ in the following events:​ Workshop on Multiscale modeling​‌ of ocular and cardiovascular​​ systems, September 29 to​​ October 3, 2025, at​​​‌ the American Institute of‌ Mathematics, Pasadena, California. Workshop‌​‌ Mathematical Biology: Applications and​​ Analysis, at the Faculty​​​‌ of Mathematics, Informatics and‌ Mechanics of the University‌​‌ of Warsaw, from July​​ 28 to July 31,​​​‌ 2025. Mathematical Biology and‌ Ecology Seminar, Mathematuical Institute,‌​‌ Oxford, June 06 2025.​​ Workshop Recent advances in​​​‌ mathematical modelling for medicine‌ and biology at Laboratoire‌​‌ des Mathematiques Raphael Salem​​ in Rouen, 22nd to​​​‌ 24th of January 2025.‌

Sophie Hecht was invited‌​‌ to the workshop Mathematical​​ Biology: Analysis and Application​​​‌ (Warsaw, Poland), Round Meanfield‌ IV: N-body sul Canal‌​‌ Grande (Venise, Italy) and​​ to the CIMPA summer​​​‌ school Mathematical models in‌ biology and related applications‌​‌ of partial differential equations​​ (La Havana, Cuba)

Philippe​​​‌ Robert has been invited‌ at the University of‌​‌ Casablanca (Morocco) From April​​ 27 to April 29,​​​‌ at the “Stochastic Reaction‌ Networks Workshop” (Politecnico di‌​‌ Torino) from June 16​​ to June 18, and​​​‌ at the University of‌ Berne from November 4‌​‌ to November 7. He​​ gave a summer school​​​‌ at Torgnon (Italy) on‌ stochastic chemical reaction networks‌​‌ from June 9 to​​ June 14.

10.1.3 Scientific​​​‌ expertise

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman has‌ reviewed proposals submitted to‌​‌ the Belgian Fonds national​​ de la recherche scientifique​​​‌ (FNRS).

Diane Peurichard is‌ member of the Commission‌​‌ d’évaluation (CE) Inria, of​​ the Commission des emplois​​​‌ scientifiques (CES) Inria Paris,‌ and of the Comité‌​‌ de suivi doctoral (CSD)​​ Inria Paris.

10.1.4 Research​​​‌ administration

Diane Peurichard is‌ coordinator of the ANR‌​‌ project ENERGENCE. She is​​ also member of the​​​‌ Pôle écoute at LJLL,‌ Sorbonne Université.

Nastassia Pouradier‌​‌ Duteil is coordinator of​​ the ANR project FISH.​​​‌

Luca Alasio is coordinator‌ of the Action Exploratoire‌​‌ RADIOS.

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman is​​ coordinator of the ANR​​​‌ project NOCIME and of‌ the STIC AMSUd project‌​‌ BIO-CIVIP. He is also​​ member of the Pôle​​​‌ écoute at LJLL, Sorbonne‌ Université.

10.2 Teaching -‌​‌ Supervision - Juries -​​ Educational and pedagogical outreach​​​‌

10.2.1 Teaching

Luca Alasio‌ and Naoufel Cresson gave‌​‌ the course Méthodes Variationnelles​​ et EDP (Introduction to​​​‌ PDEs and finite differences)‌ in the context of‌​‌ M1 Mathématiques, Modélisation, Apprentissage,​​ Université Paris Cité (MAP5).​​​‌

Diane Peurichard made a‌ 4h intervention in the‌​‌ M2 program CARe, Toulouse,​​ entitled 'Mathematical modeling of​​​‌ biological systems', aimed at‌ promoting mathematical modeling and‌​‌ simulation to biology students.​​

Diane Peurichard animated a​​​‌ 4h M2 course in‌ the Cell physics M2‌​‌ program at Université de​​ Strasbourg, entitled 'Mathematical modeling​​​‌ of biological systems' aimed‌ at forming physics students‌​‌ to mathematical modelling for​​ biology.

Manon de la​​​‌ Tousche has been teaching‌ assistant in Licence at‌​‌ Sorbonne Université.

Philippe Robert​​ is teaching the master​​​‌ M2 course `Modèles Stochastiques‌ de la Biologie Moléculaire`”‌​‌ at Sorbonne Université.

10.2.2​​ Supervision

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman is​​​‌ PhD co-supervisor of Manon‌ De La Tousche and‌​‌ Morgane Doukhan , together​​ with Yves Dumont (CIRAD).​​​‌

Nastassia Pouradier Duteil has‌ supervised the M2-level internship‌​‌ of A. Savalle.

Diane​​ Peurichard has supervised the​​​‌ post-doctorate of S. Toste‌ (co-supervised with RESTORE, Toulouse)‌​‌ and the post-doctorate of​​​‌ H. Horii (together with​ Sophie Hecht).

Jean Clairambault​‌ is currently co-supervising with​​ Emmanuel Trélat (CAGE Inria​​​‌ team) at LJLL and​ Jean-Philippe Foy at CRSA,​‌ Saint-Antoine Hospital, the PhD​​ thesis of Lia Sela,​​​‌ funded since October 2024​ by a SU PDIC​‌ (Programme Doctoral Interdisciplinaire en​​ Cancérologie) grant.

Nastassia Pouradier​​​‌ Duteil co-supervised the M2​ internship of Angelina Jammart​‌ , and is currently​​ co-supervising her PhD thesis​​​‌ (funded by the ANR​ JCJC “FISH” obtained in​‌ 2024), together with Mario​​ Sigalotti (CAGE Inria team)​​​‌ and Benoît Bonnet-Weill. She​ also co-supervised the M2​‌ internship and is currently​​ co-supervising the PhD thesis​​​‌ of Sam Gaborieau, in​ collaboration with Laurent Boudin​‌ (LJLL, Sorbonne University) and​​ Benjamin Thiria (PMMH, ESPCI).​​​‌

Diane Peurichard supervised the​ post-doctorate of Suney Toste​‌ (2024-2025, ANR ENERGENCE), the​​ post-doctorate of H. Horii​​​‌ (2024-2025, co-supervised with Sophie​ Hecht ), and co-supervised​‌ with Sophie Hecht the​​ M2 internship of V.​​​‌ Brulard (summer 2025). Diane​ Peurichard is currently co-supervising​‌ the PhD of P-A​​ Grott (2025-2028 with J.​​​‌ Paupert, RESTORE), the PhD​ of N. Martinez Tomas​‌ (2025-2028 with Sophie Hecht​​ and A. Trescases (IMT​​​‌ Toulouse)), the post-doctorate of​ Louis Fostier (feb 2026-​‌ feb 2027, ANR ENERGENCE)​​ and will co-supervise the​​​‌ M2 internship of Aurélien​ Astesiano (starting may 2026,​‌ co-supervised with A. Manhart,​​ Vienna Austria).

Luca Alasio​​​‌ is supervising the PhD​ project of Naoufel Cresson,​‌ jointly with Prof. Marcela​​ Szopos (Université Paris Cité)​​​‌ and Prof. Michel Paques​ (Hôpital National des Quinze-Vingts​‌ and Sorbonne Université). Luca​​ Alasio is supervising an​​​‌ M2 project of the​ student Eloi Bedek in​‌ the programme Mathématiques pour​​ les sciences du vivant,​​​‌ at Université Paris Saclay.​

10.2.3 Juries

Nastassia Pouradier​‌ Duteil was a jury​​ member for the thesis​​​‌ of Carlos Pulido, who​ defended in January 2025​‌ at the University of​​ Granada. She was also​​​‌ a reviewer for the​ thesis of Alexis Bejar,​‌ who will defend his​​ thesis in March 2026​​​‌ at the University of​ Granada.

Diane Peurichard (member​‌ of the CE) was​​ member of the instruction​​​‌ jury for the team​ BIOTIC, and was member​‌ of the following selection​​ committees for the 2025​​​‌ campaign:

  • Inria Nice CRCN/ISFP​ 2025 campaign
  • Inria Saclay​‌ CRCN/ISFP 2025 campaign
  • Inria​​ Grenoble CRCN/ISFP 2025 campaign​​​‌
  • Maitre de conférences position​ 2025 at Université de​‌ Bordeaux

Diane Peurichard (member​​ of the commission des​​​‌ emplois scientifiques) was member​ of the jury for​‌ the delegations Inria.

Diane​​ Peurichard was member of​​​‌ the jury for the​ FSMP junior price Maryam​‌ Mirzakhani (link),​​ awarding three womens (in​​​‌ their final year of​ a bachelor's or master's​‌ degree) for their first​​ research work or bibliographical​​​‌ study in mathematics.

Sophie​ Hecht was member of​‌ the selection committee for​​ MCF positions in Brest​​​‌ Université and Université Paris​ Nord.

Pierre-Alexandre Bliman has​‌ been a reviewer of​​ the PhD manuscript `Mathematics​​​‌ and Infectious Diseases: Analysis​ and Application of Compartmental​‌ Models' by Alicja Kubik​​ (Universidad Complutense de Madrid,​​​‌ Facultad de Ciencias Matemáticas,​ March 2025). He was​‌ also reviewer of the​​ PhD manuscript `Modélisation de​​ la Technique de l’Insecte​​​‌ Stérile dans un contexte‌ agricole : examen des‌​‌ facteurs biologiques et techniques​​ susceptibles d’atténuer son efficacité'​​​‌ by Marine Courtois (Université‌ Côte d'Azur, November 2025)‌​‌ and member of the​​ board.

Philippe Robert was​​​‌ a member of the‌ jury of the HDR‌​‌ of Hanène Mohamed (Université​​ de Nanterre) on May​​​‌ 22.

10.2.4 Educational and‌ pedagogical outreach

Sophie Hecht‌​‌ and Diane Peurichard were​​ invited professors at the​​​‌ CIMPA school 'Mathematical models‌ in biology and related‌​‌ applications of partial differential​​ equations', La Havana, Cuba,​​​‌ taking place from 9‌ to 20 june 2025‌​‌ (cf link). In​​ this event, Sophie Hecht​​​‌ presented a 6h master‌ course entitled 'Singular limits‌​‌ arising in mechanical models​​ of tissue growth' and​​​‌ Diane Peurichard did a‌ 6hours Master course entitled‌​‌ 'Simulation and numerical treatment​​ of PDEs in Mathematical​​​‌ Biology'.

10.3 Popularization

10.3.1‌ Productions (articles, videos, podcasts,‌​‌ serious games, ...)

Nastassia​​ Pouradier Duteil is a​​​‌ recurrent host in Nathalie‌ Ayi's podcast “Tête-à-tête chercheuse(s)”,‌​‌ seeking to promote a​​ diversified image of mathematical​​​‌ researchers.

11 Scientific production‌

11.1 Major publications

  • 1‌​‌ articleP.P Degond​​, G.G Dimarco​​​‌, M. A.M‌ A Ferreira and S.‌​‌S Hecht. Modeling​​ ballistic aggregation by time​​​‌ stepping approaches.SIAM‌ Journal on Applied Dynamical‌​‌ Systems24012025​​, 710-743HAL

11.2​​​‌ Publications of the year‌

International journals

Conferences without​ proceedings

  • 12 inproceedingsP.-A.​‌Pierre-Alexandre Bliman. Basic​​ offspring number and robust​​​‌ feedback design for the​ biological control of vectors​‌ by sterile insect release​​ technique.23rd European​​​‌ Control ConferenceThessaloniki, Greece​2025HALback to​‌ text
  • 13 inproceedingsP.-A.​​Pierre-Alexandre Bliman and M.​​​‌Marcel Fang. Reinfection​ induced multistability in an​‌ epidemic model.Biomath​​ 2025 - international conference​​​‌ on Mathematical Methods and​ Models in BiosciencesSofia,​‌ BulgariaJune 2025HAL​​
  • 14 inproceedingsP.-A.Pierre-Alexandre​​​‌ Bliman, M.Manon​ de la Tousche and​‌ Y.Yves Dumont.​​ Feasibility and optimisation of​​​‌ fly elimination by adult​ mass trapping and larval​‌ treatment : a stage-structured​​ metapopulation approach.BIOMATH2025​​​‌ - International Conference on​ Mathematical Methods and Models​‌ in BiosciencesSofia, Bulgaria​​June 2025HAL

Scientific​​​‌ book chapters

  • 15 inbook​Q.Qingyou He,​‌ H.-L.Hai-Liang Li and​​ B.Benoît Perthame.​​​‌ Incompressible limit of porous​ media equation with chemotaxis​‌ and growth.18​​Partial Differential Equations: Waves,​​​‌ Nonlinearities and NonlocalitiesAbel​ SymposiaSpringer Nature Switzerland​‌August 2025, 111-128​​HALDOIback to​​​‌ text

Reports & preprints​

11.3 Cited publications

  • 26‌​‌ articleA.A.G .McKendrick​​. Applications of mathematics​​​‌ to medical problems.‌Proc. Edinburgh Math. Soc.‌​‌541926, 98--130​​back to text
  • 27​​​‌ articleC.C .Norden‌. Pseudostratified epithelia –‌​‌.Journal of Cell​​ Science1302017,​​​‌ 1859--1863back to text‌
  • 28 articleB.B‌​‌ .Perthame, F.F​​ .Quirós and J. ..​​​‌J .L. Vázquez.‌ The Hele--Shaw asymptotics for‌​‌ mechanical models of tumor​​ growth.Arch. Ration.​​​‌ Mech. Anal.2122014‌, 93--127back to‌​‌ text
  • 29 articleB.​​B .Perthame and N.​​​‌N .Vauchelet.. Incompressible‌ limit of a mechanical‌​‌ model of tumour growth​​ with viscosity..Philos.​​​‌ Trans. Roy. Soc. A,‌ Mathematical, physical, and engineering‌​‌ sciences3732015back​​ to text
  • 30 article​​​‌N. S.N. Salehi‌ A. Bressan. On‌​‌ the Optimal Control of​​ Propagation Fronts.preprint​​​‌2022back to text‌
  • 31 articleL. J.‌​‌Laith J. Abu-Raddad and​​ N. M.Neil M.​​​‌ Ferguson. Characterizing the‌ symmetric equilibrium of multi-strain‌​‌ host-pathogen systems in the​​ presence of cross immunity.​​​‌.Journal of Mathematical‌ Biology5055‌​‌ 2005DOIback to​​ text
  • 32 articleA.​​​‌Agustina Alaimo, G.‌ G.Guadalupe García Liñares‌​‌, J. M.Juan​​ Marco Bujjamer, R.​​​‌ M.Roxana Mayra Gorojod‌, S. P.Soledad‌​‌ Porte Alcon, J.​​ H.Jimena Hebe Martínez​​​‌, A.Alicia Baldessari‌, H. E.Hernán‌​‌ Edgardo Grecco and M.​​​‌ L.Mónica Lidia Kotler​. Toxicity of blue​‌ led light and A2E​​ is associated to mitochondrial​​​‌ dynamics impairment in ARPE-19​ cells: implications for age-related​‌ macular degeneration.Archives​​ of Toxicology932019​​​‌, 1401--1415back to​ text
  • 33 articleL.​‌Luca Alasio, M.​​Maria Bruna, S.​​​‌Simone Fagioli and S.​Simon Schulz. Existence​‌ and regularity for a​​ system of porous medium​​​‌ equations with small cross-diffusion​ and nonlocal drifts.​‌Nonlinear Analysis2232022​​, 113064back to​​​‌ text
  • 34 articleL.​ C.Luca CB Alasio​‌ and S. M.Simon​​ M Schulz. Regularity​​​‌ and uniqueness for a​ model of active particles​‌ with angle-averaged diffusions: LCB​​ Alasio and SM Schulz​​​‌.Nonlinear Differential Equations​ and Applications NoDEA32​‌42025, 70​​back to text
  • 35​​​‌ articleL.Luca Alasio​. Towards a new​‌ mathematical model of the​​ visual cycle.2022​​​‌back to text
  • 36​ articleN. D.Nicholas​‌ D. Alikakos, P.​​ W.Peter W. Bates​​​‌ and X.Xinfu Chen​. Periodic traveling waves​‌ and locating oscillating patterns​​ in multidimensional domains.​​​‌Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.​35171999,​‌ 2777--2805URL: https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-99-02134-0DOI​​back to text
  • 37​​​‌ unpublishedL.Luís Almeida​, C.Chloe Audebert​‌, E.Emma Leschiera​​ and T.Tommaso Lorenzi​​​‌. Discrete and continuum​ models for the coevolutionary​‌ dynamics between CD8+ cytotoxic​​ T lymphocytes and tumour​​​‌ cells.September 2021​, working paper or​‌ preprintHALback to​​ text
  • 38 unpublishedL.​​​‌Luis Almeida, A.​Alexis Leculier and N.​‌Nicolas Vauchelet. Analysis​​ of the ''Rolling carpet''​​​‌ strategy to eradicate an​ invasive species.June​‌ 2021, working paper​​ or preprintHALback​​​‌ to textback to​ text
  • 39 articleL.​‌L. Alphey, M.​​M. Benedict, R.​​​‌R. Bellini, G.​G.G. Clark, D.​‌D.A. Dame, M.​​M.W. Service and S.​​​‌S.L. Dobson. Sterile-insect​ methods for control of​‌ mosquito-borne diseases: an analysis​​.Vector Borne Zoonotic​​​‌ Dis.2010back to​ text
  • 40 articleF.​‌ E.Frank Ernesto Alvarez​​, J. A.José​​​‌ Antonio Carrillo and J.​Jean Clairambault. Evolution​‌ of a structured cell​​ population endowed with plasticity​​​‌ of traits under constraints​ on and between the​‌ traits.Journal of​​ Mathematical Biologyon line,​​​‌ September 2022September 2022​HALback to text​‌back to textback​​ to textback to​​​‌ text
  • 41 articleD.​ F.David F Anderson​‌, G.Gheorghe Craciun​​ and T. G.Thomas​​​‌ G Kurtz. Product-form​ stationary distributions for deficiency​‌ zero chemical reaction networks​​.Bulletin of mathematical​​​‌ biology7282010​, 1947--1970back to​‌ text
  • 42 bookR.​​ M.Roy M Anderson​​​‌ and R. M.Robert​ M May. Infectious​‌ diseases of humans: dynamics​​ and control.Oxford​​​‌ university press1992back​ to text
  • 43 article​‌V.Viggo Andreasen,​​ J.Juan Lin and​​​‌ S. A.Simon A.​ Levin. The dynamics​‌ of cocirculating influenza strains​​ conferring partial cross-immunity.​​Journal of Mathematical Biology​​​‌3578 1997‌DOIback to text‌​‌
  • 44 incollectionJ.Julien​​ Arino. Diseases in​​​‌ metapopulations.Modeling and‌ dynamics of infectious diseases‌​‌World Scientific2009,​​ 64--122back to text​​​‌back to text
  • 45‌ articleJ.Julien Arino‌​‌, C. C.C​​ Connell McCluskey and P.​​​‌Pauline van den Driessche‌. Global results for‌​‌ an epidemic model with​​ vaccination that exhibits backward​​​‌ bifurcation.SIAM Journal‌ on Applied Mathematics64‌​‌12003, 260--276​​back to textback​​​‌ to text
  • 46 article‌J.Julien Arino and‌​‌ P.P Van den​​ Driessche. Disease spread​​​‌ in metapopulations.Fields‌ Institute Communications481‌​‌2006, 1--13back​​ to text
  • 47 article​​​‌E. F.Edilson F‌ Arruda, S. S.‌​‌Shyam S Das,​​ C. M.Claudia M​​​‌ Dias and D. H.‌Dayse H Pastore.‌​‌ Modelling and optimal control​​ of multi strain epidemics,​​​‌ with application to COVID-19‌.PLoS One16‌​‌92021, e0257512​​back to text
  • 48​​​‌ articleP.Pierre Auger‌, E.Etienne Kouokam‌​‌, G.Gauthier Sallet​​, M.Maurice Tchuente​​​‌ and B.Berge Tsanou‌. The Ross--Macdonald model‌​‌ in a patchy environment​​.Mathematical biosciences216​​​‌22008, 123--131‌back to text
  • 49‌​‌ inbookA.Aylin Aydoğdu​​, M.Marco Caponigro​​​‌, S.Sean McQuade‌, B.Benedetto Piccoli‌​‌, N.Nastassia Pouradier​​ Duteil, F.Francesco​​​‌ Rossi and E.Emmanuel‌ Trélat. Interaction Network,‌​‌ State Space, and Control​​ in Social Dynamics.​​​‌Active Particles, Volume 1‌ : Advances in Theory,‌​‌ Models, and ApplicationsN.​​Nicola Bellomo, P.​​​‌Pierre Degond and E.‌Eitan Tadmor, eds.‌​‌ ChamSpringer International Publishing​​2017, 99--140URL:​​​‌ https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-49996-3_3DOIback to‌ text
  • 50 articleN.‌​‌Nathalie Ayi and N.​​ P.Nastassia Pouradier Duteil​​​‌. Mean-field and graph‌ limits for collective dynamics‌​‌ models with time-varying weights​​.Journal of Differential​​​‌ Equations2992021,‌ 65-110URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022039621004472DOI‌​‌back to text
  • 51​​ articleI. A.Isa​​​‌ Abdullahi Baba, B.‌Bilgen Kaymakamzade and E.‌​‌Evren Hincal. Two-strain​​ epidemic model with two​​​‌ vaccinations.Chaos, Solitons‌ & Fractals1062018‌​‌, 342--348back to​​ text
  • 52 articleN.​​​‌ H.N. H. Barton‌ and M.M. Turelli‌​‌. Spatial waves of​​ advance with bistable dynamics:​​​‌ cytoplasmic and genetic analogues‌ of Allee effects.‌​‌The American Naturalist178​​2011, E48-E75back​​​‌ to textback to‌ text
  • 53 articleN.‌​‌ G.Nicolas G Bazan​​. Cell survival matters:​​​‌ docosahexaenoic acid signaling, neuroprotection‌ and photoreceptors.Trends‌​‌ in neurosciences295​​2006, 263--271back​​​‌ to text
  • 54 article‌O. G.O. G.‌​‌ Berg. A model​​ for the statistical fluctuations​​​‌ of protein numbers in‌ a microbial population.‌​‌Journal of theoretical biology​​714apr 1978​​​‌, 587--603back to‌ text
  • 55 articleF.‌​‌Frédérique Billy, J.​​Jean Clairambault, O.​​​‌Olivier Fercoq, S.‌Stéphane Gaubert, T.‌​‌Thomas Lepoutre, T.​​​‌Thomas Ouillon and S.​Shoko Saito. Synchronisation​‌ and control of proliferation​​ in cycling cell population​​​‌ models with age structure.​.Mathematics and Computers​‌ in Simulation962014​​, 66-94back to​​​‌ text
  • 56 articleP.-A.​Pierre-Alexandre Bliman. A​‌ feedback control perspective on​​ biological control of dengue​​​‌ vectors by Wolbachia infection​.European Journal of​‌ Control592021,​​ 188--206back to text​​​‌
  • 57 articleS.Samuel​ Bowong, Y.Yves​‌ Dumont and J. J.​​Jean Jules Tewa.​​​‌ A patchy model for​ chikungunya-like diseases.Biomath​‌212013,​​ 1307237back to text​​​‌
  • 58 articleF.Fred​ Brauer. Backward bifurcations​‌ in simple vaccination models​​.Journal of Mathematical​​​‌ Analysis and Applications298​22004, 418--431​‌back to text
  • 59​​ bookF.Fred Brauer​​​‌ and C.Carlos Castillo-Chavez​. Mathematical models for​‌ communicable diseases.SIAM​​2012back to text​​​‌
  • 60 articleM.Maria​ Bruna, M.Martin​‌ Burger, A.Antonio​​ Esposito and S. M.​​​‌Simon M Schulz.​ Phase separation in systems​‌ of interacting active Brownian​​ particles.SIAM Journal​​​‌ on Applied Mathematics82​42022, 1635--1660​‌back to textback​​ to text
  • 61 article​​​‌M.Maria Bruna,​ M.Martin Burger,​‌ A.Antonio Esposito and​​ S.Simon Schulz.​​​‌ Well-posedness of an integro-differential​ model for active Brownian​‌ particles.SIAM Journal​​ on Mathematical Analysis54​​​‌52022, 5662--5697​back to text
  • 62​‌ articleF.Federica Bubba​​, B.Benoît Perthame​​​‌, C.Camille Pouchol​ and M.Markus. Schmidtchen​‌. Hele--Shaw Limit for​​ a System of Two​​​‌ Reaction-(Cross-)Diffusion Equations for Living​ Tissues.Archive for​‌ Rational Mechanics and Analysis​​2362020back to​​​‌ text
  • 63 articleC.​Christian Caprara and C.​‌Christian Grimm. From​​ oxygen to erythropoietin: relevance​​​‌ of hypoxia for retinal​ development, health and disease​‌.Progress in retinal​​ and eye research31​​​‌12012, 89--119​back to text
  • 64​‌ articleJ. A.José​​ A Carrillo, S.​​​‌Simone Fagioli, F.​Filippo Santambrogio and M.​‌Markus Schmidtchen. Splitting​​ schemes and segregation in​​​‌ reaction cross-diffusion systems.​SIAM Journal on Mathematical​‌ Analysis5052018​​, 5695--5718back to​​​‌ text
  • 65 articleN.​Nicolas Champagnat and P.-E.​‌Pierre-Emmanuel Jabin. The​​ evolutionary limit for models​​​‌ of populations interacting competitively​ via several resources.​‌J. Differential Equations251​​12011, 176--195​​​‌URL: https://doi-org.accesdistant.sorbonne-universite.fr/10.1016/j.jde.2011.03.007DOIback​ to text
  • 66 article​‌C.C. Christiansen-Jucht,​​ K.K. Erguler,​​​‌ C.C.Y. Shek,​ M.M.G. Basánez and​‌ P.P.E. Parham.​​ Modelling Anopheles gambiae s.s.​​​‌ Population Dynamics with Temperature-​ and Age-Dependent Survival.​‌Int J Environ Res​​ Public Health126​​​‌2015, 5975-6005back​ to text
  • 67 article​‌J.Jean Clairambault.​​ Le cancer comme désorganisation​​​‌ localisée du plan corporel​.Revue Française de​‌ Psychosomatique66November 2024​​, 83-98HALback​​​‌ to textback to​ text
  • 68 articleJ.​‌Jean Clairambault, P.​​Philippe Michel and B.​​Benôit Perthame. Circadian​​​‌ rhythm and tumour growth‌.C. R. Acad.‌​‌ Sci. (Paris) Ser. I​​ Mathématique3422006,​​​‌ 17-22back to text‌
  • 69 incollectionJ.Jean‌​‌ Clairambault. Plasticity in​​ Cancer Cell Populations: Biology,​​​‌ Mathematics and Philosophy of‌ Cancer.``Mathematical and‌​‌ Computational Oncology'', Proceedings of​​ the Second International Symposium,​​​‌ ISMCO 2020, San Diego,‌ CA, USA, October 8-10,‌​‌ 2020, G. Bebis, M.​​ Alekseyev, H. Cho, J.​​​‌ Gevertz, M. Rodriguez Martinez‌ (Eds.), Springer LNBI 12508,‌​‌ pp. 3-9, October 2020.​​12508LNBI - Lecture​​​‌ Notes in BioinformaticsSpringer‌December 2020, 3-9‌​‌HALDOIback to​​ textback to text​​​‌
  • 70 articleJ.Jean‌ Clairambault and C.Camille‌​‌ Pouchol. A survey​​ of adaptive cell population​​​‌ dynamics models of emergence‌ of drug resistance in‌​‌ cancer, and open questions​​ about evolution and cancer​​​‌.BIOMATH81‌Copyright 2019 Clairambault et‌​‌ al. This article is​​ distributed under the terms​​​‌ of the Creative Commons‌ Attribution License (CC BY‌​‌ 4.0), which permits unrestricted​​ use, distribution, and reproduction​​​‌ in any medium, provided‌ the original author and‌​‌ source are credited.May​​ 2019, 23HAL​​​‌DOIback to text‌
  • 71 articleJ.Jean‌​‌ Clairambault. Stepping From​​ Modeling Cancer Plasticity to​​​‌ the Philosophy of Cancer‌.Frontiers in Genetics‌​‌2020, 11:579738back​​ to textback to​​​‌ text
  • 72 articleM.‌Marcello Colombino and R.‌​‌ S.Roy S. Smith​​. A Convex Characterization​​​‌ of Robust Stability for‌ Positive and Positively Dominated‌​‌ Linear Systems.IEEE​​ Transactions on Automatic Control​​​‌612016, 1965-1971‌back to text
  • 73‌​‌ articleC.Chloé Colson​​, F.Faustino Sánchez-Garduño​​​‌, H. M.Helen‌ M Byrne, P.‌​‌ K.Philip K Maini​​ and T.Tommaso Lorenzi​​​‌. Travelling-wave analysis of‌ a model of tumour‌​‌ invasion with degenerate, cross-dependent​​ diffusion.Proceedings of​​​‌ the Royal Society A‌47722562021,‌​‌ 20210593back to text​​
  • 74 articleF.F.​​​‌ Cucker and S.S.‌ Smale. Emergent behavior‌​‌ in flocks.IEEE​​ Transactions on Automatic Control​​​‌522007, 852--862‌back to textback‌​‌ to textback to​​ text
  • 75 articleN.​​​‌Noemi David and B.‌Benoît Perthame. Free‌​‌ boundary limit of tumor​​ growth model with nutrient​​​‌.Journal de Mathématiques‌ Pures et Appliquées155‌​‌https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.107312021, 62-82​​HALDOIback to​​​‌ text
  • 76 articleP.‌ C.Paul C.W. Davies‌​‌ and C. H.Charles​​ H. Lineweaver. Cancer​​​‌ tumors as Metazoa 1.0:‌ tapping genes of ancient‌​‌ ancestors.Physical Biology​​81feb 2011​​​‌, 015001URL: https://doi.org/10.1088/1478-3975/8/1/015001‌DOIback to text‌​‌
  • 77 inbookP.Pierre​​ Degond. MATHEMATICAL MODELS​​​‌ OF COLLECTIVE DYNAMICS AND‌ SELF-ORGANIZATION.Proceedings of‌​‌ the International Congress of​​ Mathematicians (ICM 2018)3925-3946​​​‌URL: https://www.worldscientific.com/doi/abs/10.1142/9789813272880_0206DOIback‌ to text
  • 78 article‌​‌L. V.Lucian V​​ Del Priore, Y.-H.​​​‌Ya-Hui Kuo and T.‌ H.Tongalp H Tezel‌​‌. Age-related changes in​​ human RPE cell density​​​‌ and apoptosis proportion in‌ situ.Investigative ophthalmology‌​‌ & visual science43​​​‌102002, 3312--3318​back to text
  • 79​‌ incollectionO.Odo Diekmann​​. A BEGINNER'S GUIDE​​​‌ TO ADAPTIVE DYNAMICS.​63MATHEMATICAL MODELLING OF​‌ POPULATION DYNAMICSBANACH CENTER​​ PUBLICATIONS, INSTITUTE OF MATHEMATICS​​​‌ POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES​ WARSZAWA2004, 47--86​‌back to text
  • 80​​ bookO.Odo Diekmann​​​‌ and J. A.Johan​ Andre Peter Heesterbeek.​‌ Mathematical epidemiology of infectious​​ diseases: model building, analysis​​​‌ and interpretation.5​John Wiley & Sons​‌2000back to text​​
  • 81 articleO.Odo​​​‌ Diekmann, P.-E.Pierre-Emmanuel​ Jabin, S.Stéphane​‌ Mischler and B.Benoît​​ Perthame. The dynamics​​​‌ of adaptation: An illuminating​ example and a Hamilton--Jacobi​‌ approach.Theoretical Population​​ Biology672005,​​​‌ 257--271back to text​
  • 82 articleW.Weiwei​‌ Ding and H.Hiroshi​​ Matano. Dynamics of​​​‌ time-periodic reaction-diffusion equations with​ compact initial support on​‌ .J. Math. Pures​​ Appl. (9)1312019​​​‌, 326--371URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpur.2019.09.010​DOIback to text​‌
  • 83 articleW.Weiwei​​ Ding and H.Hiroshi​​​‌ Matano. Dynamics of​ time-periodic reaction-diffusion equations with​‌ front-like initial data on​​ .SIAM J. Math.​​​‌ Anal.5232020​, 2411--2462URL: https://doi.org/10.1137/19M1268987​‌DOIback to text​​
  • 84 miscB. A.​​​‌Blanca Ayuso de Dios​, S.Simone Dovetta​‌ and L. V.Laura​​ V. Spinolo. On​​​‌ the continuum limit of​ epidemiological models on graphs:​‌ convergence results, approximation and​​ numerical simulations.2022​​​‌, URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.01932DOI​back to text
  • 85​‌ articleR.Ramsès Djidjou-Demasse​​, C.Christian Selinger​​​‌ and M. T.Mircea​ T Sofonea. Épidémiologie​‌ mathématique et modélisation de​​ la pandémie de Covid-19:​​​‌ enjeux et diversité.​Revue Francophone des Laboratoires​‌20205262020,​​ 63--69back to text​​​‌
  • 86 articleR. L.​R. L. Dobrushin.​‌ Vlasov equations.Functional​​ Analysis and Its Applications​​​‌1321979,​ 115--123URL: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01077243DOI​‌back to text
  • 87​​ articleJ.Jean Dolbeault​​​‌ and G.Gabriel Turinici​. Heterogeneous social interactions​‌ and the COVID-19 lockdown​​ outcome in a multi-group​​​‌ SEIR model.Mathematical​ Modelling of Natural Phenomena​‌152020, 36​​back to text
  • 88​​​‌ articleM.Marie Doumic​, K.Klemens Fellner​‌, M.Mathieu Mezache​​ and H.Human Rezaei​​​‌. A bi-monomeric, nonlinear​ Becker-Döring-type system to capture​‌ oscillatory aggregation kinetics in​​ prion dynamics.Journal​​​‌ of Theoretical Biology480​11 2019DOIback​‌ to text
  • 89 article​​M.Marie Doumic,​​​‌ S.Sophie Hecht and​ D.Diane Peurichard.​‌ A purely mechanical model​​ with asymmetric features for​​​‌ early morphogenesis of rod-shaped​ bacteria micro-colony.Mathematical​‌ Biosciences and Engineering17​​6October 2020,​​​‌ http://aimspress.com/article/doi/10.3934/mbe.2020356HALDOIback​ to textback to​‌ textback to text​​
  • 90 articleC.C.​​​‌ Dufourd and Y.Y.​ Dumont. Impact of​‌ environmental factors on mosquito​​ dispersal in the prospect​​​‌ of sterile insect technique​ control.Comput. Math.​‌ Appl.6692013​​, 1695--1715back to​​​‌ text
  • 91 articleM.​Michel Duprez, R.​‌Romane Hélie, Y.​​Yannick Privat and N.​​Nicolas Vauchelet. Optimization​​​‌ of spatial control strategies‌ for population replacement, application‌​‌ to \it Wolbachia.​​ESAIM Control Optim. Calc.​​​‌ Var.272021,‌ Paper No. 74, 30‌​‌URL: https://doi.org/10.1051/cocv/2021070DOIback​​ to text
  • 92 article​​​‌M.-C.Marie-Cécilia Duvernoy,‌ T.Thierry Mora,‌​‌ M.Maxime Ardré,​​ V.Vincent Croquette,​​​‌ D.David Bensimon,‌ C.Catherine Quilliet,‌​‌ J.-M.Jean-Marc Ghigo,​​ M.Martial Balland,​​​‌ C.Christophe Beloin,‌ S.Sigolène Lecuyer and‌​‌ others. Asymmetric adhesion​​ of rod-shaped bacteria controls​​​‌ microcolony morphogenesis.Nature‌ communications912018‌​‌, 1--10back to​​ textback to text​​​‌
  • 93 articleY.Yoshio‌ Ebihara, D.Dimitri‌​‌ Peaucelle and D.Denis​​ Arzelier. LMI approach​​​‌ to linear positive system‌ analysis and synthesis.‌​‌Systems & Control Letters​​632014, 50--56​​​‌back to text
  • 94‌ articleF.Frank Ernesto‌​‌ Alvarez and J.Jean​​ Clairambault. Phenotype divergence​​​‌ and cooperation in isogenic‌ multicellularity and in cancer‌​‌.Mathematical Medicine and​​ BiologyJuly 2024HAL​​​‌DOIback to text‌
  • 95 articleS.Selim‌​‌ Esedoġ Lu and F.​​Felix Otto. Threshold​​​‌ dynamics for networks with‌ arbitrary surface tensions.‌​‌Communications on pure and​​ applied mathematics685​​​‌2015, 808--864back‌ to text
  • 96 article‌​‌M.Marcel Fang and​​ P.-A.Pierre-Alexandre Bliman.​​​‌ Modelling, Analysis, Observability and‌ Identifiability of Epidemic Dynamics‌​‌ with Reinfections.arXiv​​ preprint arXiv:2201.101572022back​​​‌ to textback to‌ text
  • 97 articleJ.‌​‌ Z.József Z. Farkas​​ and P.Peter Hinow​​​‌. Structured and Unstructured‌ Continuous Models for Wolbachia‌​‌ Infections.Bulletin of​​ Mathematical Biology728​​​‌Nov 2010, 2067--2088‌URL: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11538-010-9528-1DOIback‌​‌ to text
  • 98 book​​M.Martin Feinberg.​​​‌ Foundations of chemical reaction‌ network theory.202‌​‌Applied Mathematical SciencesSpringer,​​ Cham2019, xxix+454​​​‌back to text
  • 99‌ articleA.A. Fenton‌​‌, K. N.K.​​ N. Johnson, J.​​​‌ C.J. C. Brownlie‌ and G. D.G.‌​‌ D. D. Hurst.​​ Solving the Wolbachia paradox:​​​‌ modeling the tripartite interaction‌ between host, Wolbachia,‌​‌ and a natural enemy​​.The American Naturalist​​​‌1782011, 333-342‌back to text
  • 100‌​‌ articleM.Miguel Fudolig​​ and R.Reka Howard​​​‌. The local stability‌ of a modified multi-strain‌​‌ SIR model for emerging​​ viral strains.PloS​​​‌ one15122020‌, e0243408back to‌​‌ text
  • 101 articleA.​​Antonio Gaudiello, O.​​​‌Olivier Guibé and F.‌François Murat. Homogenization‌​‌ of the Brush Problem​​ with a Source Term​​​‌ in L.Archive‌ for Rational Mechanics and‌​‌ Analysis22512017​​, 1--64back to​​​‌ text
  • 102 articleM.‌ G.M. Gabriela M.‌​‌ Gomes, L. J.​​Lisa J. White and​​​‌ G. F.Graham F.‌ Medley. Infection, reinfection,‌​‌ and vaccination under suboptimal​​ immune protection: epidemiological perspectives​​​‌.Journal of Theoretical‌ Biology22846‌​‌ 2004DOIback to​​ text
  • 103 articleI.​​​‌Ilkka Hanski and D.‌Daniel Simberloff. The‌​‌ metapopulation approach, its history,​​​‌ conceptual domain, and application​ to conservation.Metapopulation​‌ biology1997, 5--26​​back to text
  • 104​​​‌ articleS.Sophie Hecht​, G.Gantas Perez-Mockus​‌, D.Dominik Schienstock​​, C.Carles Recasens-Alvarez​​​‌, S.Sara Merino-Aceituno​, M. B.Matthew​‌ B. Smith, G.​​Guillaume Salbreux, P.​​​‌Pierre Degond and J.-P.​Jean-Paul Vincent. Mechanical​‌ constraints to cell-cycle progression​​ in a pseudostratified epithelium​​​‌.Current Biology212​92022, URL:​‌ https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2022.03.004DOIback to​​ textback to text​​​‌
  • 105 articleR.Rainer​ Hegselmann and U.Ulrich​‌ Krause. Opinion Dynamics​​ and Bounded Confidence Models,​​​‌ Analysis and Simulation.​Journal of Artificial Societies​‌ and Social Simulation5​​07 2002back to​​​‌ textback to text​back to text
  • 106​‌ articleA.A. Janulevicius​​, M. C.M.​​​‌ C. M. van Loosdrecht​, A.A. Simone​‌ and C.C. Picioreanu​​. Cell Flexibility Affects​​​‌ the Alignment of Model​ Myxobacteria.Biophysical Journal​‌992010back to​​ text
  • 107 bookA.​​​‌Ansgar Jüngel. Entropy​ methods for diffusive partial​‌ differential equations.804​​Springer2016back to​​​‌ text
  • 108 articleM.​Masashi Kamo and A.​‌Akira Sasaki. The​​ effect of cross-immunity and​​​‌ seasonal forcing in a​ multi-strain epidemic model.​‌Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena​​1653-42002,​​​‌ 228--241back to text​
  • 109 articleG.Guy​‌ Katriel. Epidemics with​​ partial immunity to reinfection​​​‌.Mathematical Biosciences228​212 2010DOI​‌back to text
  • 110​​ bookM. J.Matt​​​‌ J. Keeling and P.​Pejman Rohani. Modeling​‌ Infectious Diseases in Humans​​ and Animals.Princeton​​​‌ University Press9 2008​DOIback to text​‌back to text
  • 111​​ articleJ.Jeongho Kim​​​‌, B.Benoît Perthame​ and D.Delphine Salort​‌. Fast voltage dynamics​​ of voltage-conductance models for​​​‌ neural networks.Bull.​ Braz. Math. Soc. (N.S.)​‌5212021,​​ 101--134URL: https://doi-org.accesdistant.sorbonne-universite.fr/10.1007/s00574-019-00192-7DOI​​​‌back to text
  • 112​ articleN. J.Natalie​‌ J. Kirkland, A.​​ C.Alice C. Yuen​​​‌, M.Melda Tozluoglu​, N.Nancy Hui​‌, E. K.Ewa​​ K. Paluch and Y.​​​‌Yanlan Mao. Tissue​ Mechanics Regulate Mitotic Nuclear​‌ Dynamics during Epithelial Development​​.Current Biology2020​​​‌back to text
  • 113​ articleP. D.Philip​‌ D Kiser, M.​​Marcin Golczak and K.​​​‌Krzysztof Palczewski. Chemistry​ of the retinoid (visual)​‌ cycle.Chemical reviews​​11412014,​​​‌ 194--232back to text​back to text
  • 114​‌ articleM.Maxim Kuznetsov​​, J.Jean Clairambault​​​‌ and V.Vitaly Volpert​. Improving cancer treatments​‌ via dynamical biophysical models​​.Physics of Life​​​‌ ReviewsOctober 2021,​ 1-84HALDOIback​‌ to textback to​​ text
  • 115 articleT.​​​‌TD Lamb and E.​ N.Edward N Pugh​‌ Jr. Dark adaptation​​ and the retinoid cycle​​​‌ of vision.Progress​ in retinal and eye​‌ research2332004​​, 307--380back to​​​‌ text
  • 116 articleC.​ A.Clemens AK Lange​‌ and J. W.James​​ WB Bainbridge. Oxygen​​ sensing in retinal health​​​‌ and disease.Ophthalmologica‌22732012,‌​‌ 115--131back to text​​
  • 117 articleL.Lucie​​​‌ Laurence and P.Philippe‌ Robert. Analysis of‌​‌ Stochastic Chemical Reaction Networks​​ with a Hierarchy of​​​‌ Timescales.arXiv preprint‌ arXiv:2408.156972024back to‌​‌ text
  • 118 articleL.​​Lucie Laurence and P.​​​‌Philippe Robert. Stochastic‌ Chemical Reaction Networks with‌​‌ Discontinuous Limits and AIMD​​ processes.arXiv preprint​​​‌ arXiv:2406.126042024back to‌ text
  • 119 articleE.‌​‌Emma Leschiera, T.​​Tommaso Lorenzi, S.​​​‌Shensi Shen, L.‌Luis Almeida and C.‌​‌Chloe Audebert. A​​ mathematical model to study​​​‌ the impact of intra-tumour‌ heterogeneity on anti-tumour CD8+‌​‌ T cell immune response​​.Journal of Theoretical​​​‌ Biology538April 2022‌, 111028HALDOI‌​‌back to text
  • 120​​ articleT.Tommaso Lorenzi​​​‌ and C.Camille Pouchol‌. Asymptotic analysis of‌​‌ selection-mutation models in the​​ presence of multiple fitness​​​‌ peaks.Nonlinearity33‌2020, 5791--5816back‌​‌ to text
  • 121 phdthesis​​L. C.Lindsey C​​​‌ Macdougall. Mathematical modelling‌ of retinal metabolism.‌​‌University of Nottingham2015​​back to text
  • 122​​​‌ articleT.Tadao Maeda‌, M.Marcin Golczak‌​‌ and A.Akiko Maeda​​. Retinal Photodamage mediated​​​‌ by all-trans-retinal.Photochemistry‌ and photobiology886‌​‌2012, 1309--1319back​​ to text
  • 123 book​​​‌P.Piero Manfredi and‌ A. (.Alberto (eds)‌​‌ d'Onofrio. Modeling the​​ Interplay Between Human Behavior​​​‌ and the Spread of‌ Infectious Diseases.New‌​‌ YorkSpringer2013back​​ to text
  • 124 article​​​‌D.Doumic Marie,‌ H.Hecht Sophie,‌​‌ P.Perthame Benoit and​​ P.Peurichard Diane.​​​‌ Multispecies cross-diffusions: from a‌ nonlocal mean-field to a‌​‌ porous medium system without​​ self-diffusion.J. Diff.​​​‌ Eq. 3892024,‌ 228-256back to text‌​‌
  • 125 articleJ.James​​ Mason, C.Clément​​​‌ Erignoux, R. L.‌Robert L Jack and‌​‌ M.Maria Bruna.​​ Exact hydrodynamics and onset​​​‌ of phase separation for‌ an active exclusion process‌​‌.Proceedings of the​​ Royal Society A479​​​‌22792023, 20230524‌back to text
  • 126‌​‌ articleB.Bertrand Maury​​, A.Aude Roudneff-Chupin​​​‌, F.Filippo Santambrogio‌ and J.Juliette Venel‌​‌. Handling congestion in​​ crowd motion modeling.​​​‌Networks and Heterogeneous Media‌61556-18012011,‌​‌ 485URL: http://aimsciences.org//article/id/1ca7d746-eb9f-4f71-896b-3f647d510702DOI​​back to text
  • 127​​​‌ articleI.Idriss Mazari‌, G.Grégoire Nadin‌​‌ and Y.Yannick Privat​​. Optimisation of the​​​‌ total population size for‌ logistic diffusive equations: bang-bang‌​‌ property and fragmentation rate​​.To appear in​​​‌ Communications in PDEs2021‌back to text
  • 128‌​‌ articleG. S.Georgi​​ S. Medvedev. The​​​‌ Nonlinear Heat Equation on‌ Dense Graphs and Graph‌​‌ Limits.SIAM J.​​ Math. Analysis462014​​​‌, 2743-2766back to‌ textback to text‌​‌
  • 129 articleL.Lingyi​​ Meng, S.Shuixiang​​​‌ Li, P.Peng‌ Lu, T.Teng‌​‌ Li and W.Weiwei​​ Jin. Bending and​​​‌ elongation effects on the‌ random packing of curved‌​‌ spherocylinders.Physical Review​​​‌ E8662012​, 061309back to​‌ text
  • 130 articleJ.​​ C.Joel C Miller​​​‌ and I. Z.Istvan​ Z Kiss. Epidemic​‌ spread in networks: Existing​​ methods and current challenges​​​‌.Mathematical modelling of​ natural phenomena92​‌2014, 4--42back​​ to text
  • 131 article​​​‌P.Paul Mitchell,​ G.Gerald Liew,​‌ B.Bamini Gopinath and​​ T. Y.Tien Y​​​‌ Wong. Age-related macular​ degeneration.The Lancet​‌392101532018,​​ 1147--1159back to text​​​‌
  • 132 articleR. Z.​Rhudaina Z Mohammad,​‌ H.Hideki Murakawa,​​ K.Karel Svadlenka and​​​‌ H.Hideru Togashi.​ A numerical algorithm for​‌ modeling cellular rearrangements in​​ tissue morphogenesis.Communications​​​‌ Biology512022​, 239back to​‌ text
  • 133 articleR.​​ S.Robert S Molday​​​‌. ATP-binding cassette transporter​ ABCA4: molecular properties and​‌ role in vision and​​ macular degeneration.Journal​​​‌ of bioenergetics and biomembranes​3952007,​‌ 507--517back to text​​
  • 134 articleS. S.​​​‌Stephen S Morse and​ A.Ann Schluederberg.​‌ Emerging viruses: the evolution​​ of viruses and viral​​​‌ diseases.The Journal​ of infectious diseases162​‌11990, 1--7​​back to text
  • 135​​​‌ articleW. E.Werner​ E.G. Müller. Review:​‌ How was metazoan threshold​​ crossed? The hypothetical Urmetazoa​​​‌.Comparative Biochemistry and​ Physiology Part A129​‌2001, 433--460back​​ to text
  • 136 article​​​‌D. J.Daniel J​ Müller, N.Nan​‌ Wu and K.Krzysztof​​ Palczewski. Vertebrate membrane​​​‌ proteins: structure, function, and​ insights from biophysical approaches​‌.Pharmacological reviews60​​12008, 43--78​​​‌back to text
  • 137​ articleG.G. Nadin​‌, M.M. Strugarek​​ and N.N. Vauchelet​​​‌. Hindrances to bistable​ front propagation: application to​‌ Wolbachia invasion.J.​​ Math. Biol.766​​​‌2018, 1489--1533back​ to text
  • 138 article​‌G.Grégoire Nadin and​​ A. I.Ana Isis​​​‌ Toledo Marrero. On​ the maximization problem for​‌ solutions of reaction-diffusion equations​​ with respect to their​​​‌ initial data.Mathematical​ Modelling of Natural Phenomena​‌152020, URL:​​ https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02175063back to text​​​‌back to text
  • 139​ articleT. W.Tuen​‌ Wai Ng, G.​​Gabriel Turinici and A.​​​‌Antoine Danchin. A​ double epidemic model for​‌ the SARS propagation.​​BMC Infectious Diseases3​​​‌12003, 1--16​back to text
  • 140​‌ articleT. N.Thanh​​ Nam Nguyen, J.​​​‌Jean Clairambault, T.​Thierry Jaffredo, B.​‌Benôit Perthame and D.​​Delphine Salort. Adaptive​​​‌ dynamics of hematopoietic stem​ cells and their supporting​‌ stroma: A model and​​ mathematical analysis.Mathematical​​​‌ Biosciences and Engineering16​05May 2019,​‌ 4818--4845HALDOIback​​ to text
  • 141 article​​​‌M.Miriam Nuño,​ Z.Zhilan Feng,​‌ M.Maia Martcheva and​​ C.Carlos Castillo-Chavez.​​​‌ Dynamics of two-strain influenza​ with isolation and partial​‌ cross-immunity.SIAM Journal​​ on Applied Mathematics65​​​‌32005, 964--982​back to text
  • 142​‌ articleA.Anastasia Pacary​​, D.Diane Peurichard​​, L.Laurence Vaysse​​​‌, P.Paul Monsarrat‌, C.Clémence Bolut‌​‌, A.Adeline Girel​​, C.Christophe Guissard​​​‌, A.Anne Lorsignol‌, V.Valérie Planat-Benard‌​‌, J.Jenny Paupert​​, M.Marielle Ousset​​​‌ and L.Louis Casteilla‌. A computational model‌​‌ reveals an early transient​​ decrease in fiber cross-linking​​​‌ that unlocks adult regeneration‌.NPJ Regenerative medicine‌​‌91October 2024​​, 29HALDOI​​​‌back to text
  • 143‌ articleJ.Jeremie Palacci‌​‌, S.Stefano Sacanna​​, A. P.Asher​​​‌ Preska Steinberg, D.‌ J.David J Pine‌​‌ and P. M.Paul​​ M Chaikin. Living​​​‌ crystals of light-activated colloidal‌ surfers.Science339‌​‌61222013, 936--940​​back to text
  • 144​​​‌ articleM.Michel Paques‌, N.Nathaniel Norberg‌​‌, C.Céline Chaumette​​, F.Florian Sennlaub​​​‌, E.Ethan Rossi‌, Y.Ysé Borella‌​‌ and K.Kate Grieve​​. Long Term Time-Lapse​​​‌ Imaging of Geographic Atrophy:‌ A Pilot Study.‌​‌Frontiers in Medicine9​​2022, 868163back​​​‌ to text
  • 145 article‌C.Chassonnery Pauline,‌​‌ P.Pauper Jenny,​​ L.Lorsignol Anne,​​​‌ S.Séverac Childerick,‌ O.Ousset Marielle,‌​‌ D.Degond Pierre,​​ C.Casteilla Louis and​​​‌ P.Peurichard Diane.‌ Fiber crosslinking drives the‌​‌ emergence of order in​​ a 3D dynamical network​​​‌ model.R. Soc.‌ Open Sci.12024‌​‌, 1231456231456back to​​ text
  • 146 articleJ.​​​‌J. Paulsson. Models‌ of stochastic gene expression‌​‌.Physics of Life​​ Reviews22June​​​‌ 2005, 157--175back‌ to text
  • 147 article‌​‌B.Benoît Perthame and​​ G.Guy Barles.​​​‌ Dirac concentrations in Lotka-Volterra‌ parabolic PDEs.Indiana‌​‌ Univ. Math. J.57​​72008, 3275--3301​​​‌URL: https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.2008.57.3398back to‌ text
  • 148 articleB.‌​‌Benôit Perthame and A.​​Alexandre Poulain. Relaxation​​​‌ of the Cahn-Hilliard equation‌ with singular single-well potential‌​‌ and degenerate mobility.​​European Journal of Applied​​​‌ MathematicsMarch 2020HAL‌DOIback to text‌​‌back to text
  • 149​​ articleD.Diane Peurichard​​​‌, M.Marielle Ousset‌, J.Jenny Paupert‌​‌, B.Benjamin Aymard​​, A.Anne Lorsignol​​​‌, L.Louis Casteilla‌ and P.Pierre Degond‌​‌. Extra-cellular matrix rigidity​​ may dictate the fate​​​‌ of injury outcome.‌Journal of Theoretical Biology‌​‌469May 2019,​​ 127-136HALDOIback​​​‌ to text
  • 150 article‌D. e.Diane et‌​‌ al Peurichard. Simple​​ mechanical cues could explain​​​‌ adipose tissue morphology.‌J. Theor Biol2017‌​‌, URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtbi.2017.06.030back​​ to text
  • 151 article​​​‌P.P. Poláċik.‌ Threshold solutions and sharp‌​‌ transitions for nonautonomous parabolic​​ equations on N .​​​‌Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal.‌19912011,‌​‌ 69--97URL: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-010-0316-8DOI​​back to text
  • 152​​​‌ unpublishedC.Camille Pouchol‌, J.Jean Clairambault‌​‌, A.Alexander Lorz​​ and E.Emmanuel Trélat​​​‌. Asymptotic analysis and‌ optimal control of an‌​‌ integro-differential system modelling healthy​​ and cancer cells exposed​​​‌ to chemotherapy.December‌ 2016, accepted in‌​‌ the J. Math. Pures​​​‌ et App.HALback​ to text
  • 153 mastersthesis​‌C.Camille Pouchol.​​ Modelling interactions between tumour​​​‌ cells and supporting adipocytes​ in breast cancer.​‌MA ThesisUPMCSeptember​​ 2015HALback to​​​‌ text
  • 154 articleM.​Marion Rabé, S.​‌Solenne Dumont, A.​​Arturo Álvarez-Arenas, H.​​​‌Hicham Janati, J.​Juan Belmonte-Beitia, G.​‌ F.Gabriel F Calvo​​, C.Christelle Thibault-Carpentier​​​‌, Q.Quentin Séry​, C.Cynthia Chauvin​‌, N.Noémie Joalland​​, F.Floriane Briand​​​‌, S.Stéphanie Blandin​, E.Emmanuel Scotet​‌, C.Claire Pecqueur​​, J.Jean Clairambault​​​‌, L.Lisa Oliver​, V.Victor Pérez-Garc\'ia​‌, A. M.Arulraj​​ M Nadaradjane, P.-F.​​​‌Pierre-Francois Cartron, C.​Catherine Gratas and F.​‌François Vallette. Identification​​ of a transient state​​​‌ during the acquisition of​ temozolomide resistance in glioblastoma​‌.Cell Death and​​ Disease111January​​​‌ 2020HALDOIback​ to text
  • 155 article​‌P.Philippe Robert.​​ Mathematical Models of Gene​​​‌ Expression.Probability Surveys​16October 2019,​‌ 56HALback to​​ textback to text​​​‌
  • 156 articleP.Philippe​ Robert and G.Gaëtan​‌ Vignoud. Averaging Principles​​ for Markovian Models of​​​‌ Plasticity.Journal of​ Statistical Physics1833​‌June 2021, 47--90​​HALDOIback to​​​‌ textback to text​
  • 157 articleP.Philippe​‌ Robert and G.Gaëtan​​ Vignoud. Stochastic Models​​​‌ of Neural Plasticity.​SIAM Journal on Applied​‌ Mathematics815September​​ 2021, 1821--1846HAL​​​‌DOIback to text​back to text
  • 158​‌ articleP.Philippe Robert​​ and G.Gaëtan Vignoud​​​‌. Stochastic Models of​ Neural Plasticity: A Scaling​‌ Approach.SIAM Journal​​ on Applied Mathematics81​​​‌6November 2021,​ 2362---2386HALDOIback​‌ to text
  • 159 book​​M.-M.Marie-Monique Robin.​​​‌ La fabrique des pandémies:​ Préserver la biodiversité, un​‌ impératif pour la santé​​ planétaire.La Découverte​​​‌2021back to text​
  • 160 articleM. P.​‌Maarten P Rozing,​​ J. A.Jon A​​​‌ Durhuus, M. K.​Marie Krogh Nielsen,​‌ Y.Yousif Subhi,​​ T. B.Thomas BL​​​‌ Kirkwood, R. G.​Rudi GJ Westendorp and​‌ T. L.Torben Lykke​​ S\o{}rensen. Age-related macular​​​‌ degeneration: A two-level model​ hypothesis.Progress in​‌ retinal and eye research​​762020, 100825​​​‌back to text
  • 161​ articleH. C.Hsu​‌ C. Shapiro JA.​​ Escherichia coli K-12 cell-cell​​​‌ interactions seen by time-lapse​ video.J Bacteriol.​‌1989, 11:171back​​ to text
  • 162 article​​​‌S.Shensi Shen and​ J.Jean Clairambault.​‌ Cell plasticity in cancer​​ cell populations.F1000Research​​​‌2020, 9:635back​ to textback to​‌ text
  • 163 articleN.​​Nanako Shigesada, K.​​​‌Kohkichi Kawasaki and E.​Ei Teramoto. Spatial​‌ segregation of interacting species​​.Journal of theoretical​​​‌ biology7911979​, 83--99back to​‌ text
  • 164 articleN.​​ K.Nguyen Khoa Son​​​‌ and D.Diederich Hinrichsen​. Robust stability of​‌ positive continuous time systems​​.Numerical functional analysis​​ and optimization175-6​​​‌1996, 649--659back‌ to text
  • 165 article‌​‌J. R.Janet R​​ Sparrow, N.Nathan​​​‌ Fishkin, J.Jilin‌ Zhou, B.Bolin‌​‌ Cai, Y. P.​​Young P Jang,​​​‌ S.Sonja Krane,‌ Y.Yasuhiro Itagaki and‌​‌ K.Koji Nakanishi.​​ A2E, a byproduct of​​​‌ the visual cycle.‌Vision research4328‌​‌2003, 2983--2990back​​ to text
  • 166 article​​​‌J. R.Janet R‌ Sparrow, E.Emily‌​‌ Gregory-Roberts, K.Kazunori​​ Yamamoto, A.Anna​​​‌ Blonska, S. K.‌Shanti Kaligotla Ghosh,‌​‌ K.Keiko Ueda and​​ J.Jilin Zhou.​​​‌ The bisretinoids of retinal‌ pigment epithelium.Progress‌​‌ in retinal and eye​​ research3122012​​​‌, 121--135back to‌ text
  • 167 articleT.‌​‌Thomas Speck, A.​​ M.Andreas M Menzel​​​‌, J.Julian Bialké‌ and H.Hartmut Löwen‌​‌. Dynamical mean-field theory​​ and weakly non-linear analysis​​​‌ for the phase separation‌ of active Brownian particles‌​‌.The Journal of​​ chemical physics14222​​​‌2015back to text‌
  • 168 articleI.-S.Ioana-Sandra‌​‌ Tarau, A.Andreas​​ Berlin, C. A.​​​‌Christine A Curcio and‌ T.Thomas Ach.‌​‌ The cytoskeleton of the​​ retinal pigment epithelium: from​​​‌ normal aging to age-related‌ macular degeneration.International‌​‌ Journal of Molecular Sciences​​20142019,​​​‌ 3578back to text‌
  • 169 articleA.A.‌​‌ Tran, M.M.​​ Mangeas, M.M.​​​‌ Demarchi, E.E.‌ Roux, P.P.‌​‌ Degenne, M.M.​​ Haramboure, G.G.​​​‌ Le Goff, D.‌D. Damiens, L.-C.‌​‌L-C. Gouagna, V.​​V. Herbreteau and J.-S.​​​‌J-S. Dehecq. Complementarity‌ of empirical and process-based‌​‌ approaches to modelling mosquito​​ population dynamics with Aedes​​​‌ albopictus as an example‌ - Application to the‌​‌ development of an operational​​ mapping tool of vector​​​‌ populations.PLoS ONE‌1512020,‌​‌ e0227407back to text​​
  • 170 articleS.S​​​‌ Tripathi, H.H‌ Levine and M.MK‌​‌ Jolly. The Physics​​ of Cellular Decision Making​​​‌ During Epithelial-Mesenchymal Transition.‌Annu Rev Biophys.49‌​‌2020, 1-18DOI​​back to text
  • 171​​​‌ articleT.Tamás Vicsek‌, A.András Czirók‌​‌, E.Eshel Ben-Jacob​​, I.Inon Cohen​​​‌ and O.Ofer Shochet‌. Novel Type of‌​‌ Phase Transition in a​​ System of Self-Driven Particles​​​‌.Phys. Rev. Lett.‌756Aug 1995‌​‌, 1226--1229URL: https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.75.1226​​DOIback to text​​​‌back to text
  • 172‌ articleG.Gaëtan Vignoud‌​‌ and P.Philippe Robert​​. On the Spontaneous​​​‌ Dynamics of Synaptic Weights‌ in Stochastic Models with‌​‌ Pair-Based STDP.Physical​​ Review E 1055​​​‌May 2022, 054405‌HALback to text‌​‌
  • 173 unpublishedG.Gaëtan​​ Vignoud, J.Jonathan​​​‌ Touboul and L.Laurent‌ Venance. A synaptic‌​‌ theory for sequence learning​​ in the striatum.​​​‌2022, Preprintback‌ to text
  • 174 article‌​‌M.Mark Vincent.​​ Cancer: A de-repression of​​​‌ a default survival program‌ common to all cells?‌​‌BioEssays3412012​​​‌, 72-82URL: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/bies.201100049​DOIback to text​‌
  • 175 articleW. L.​​Wan Ling Wong,​​​‌ X.Xinyi Su,​ X.Xiang Li,​‌ C. M.Chui Ming​​ G Cheung, R.​​​‌Ronald Klein, C.-Y.​Ching-Yu Cheng and T.​‌ Y.Tien Yin Wong​​. Global prevalence of​​​‌ age-related macular degeneration and​ disease burden projection for​‌ 2020 and 2040: a​​ systematic review and meta-analysis​​​‌.The Lancet Global​ Health222014​‌, e106--e116back to​​ text
  • 176 articleY.-C.​​​‌ E.Y. E. S.-C​ et al. Morphometrics​‌ of complex cell shapes:​​ lobe contribution elliptic fourier​​​‌ analysis (loco-efa).Development​2018back to text​‌
  1. 1This type of​​ infinite-dimensional systems is reminiscent​​​‌ of Becker-Döring system 88​.
  2. 2A new​‌ trans-disciplinary research domain has​​ recently emerged, termed Behavioural​​​‌ Epidemiology of Infectious Diseases​123. The referred​‌ `behaviour' includes the spontaneous​​ changes at individual and​​​‌ collective, but also the​ political decisions and their​‌ consequences.